Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Lestronge]

Oh I get it. The guy is very charismatic. However, how do players view him once they play under him is another question. Ask Ice, Stef and Bateman.

You could also ask Seyfarth , Pole and it looks like Galvin is extending . Seems they have a different story to tell .
That’s such confirmation bias nonsense to prove a point . Each one of those examples is a completely different and unique situation .
For starters ICE got told to leave early into the season , Stef is being paid for potential , and the only coach in the nrl who thinks he might have a chance at pulling Batemans head in is a 70 year old .
this is gibberish

 

[The Chad]

Regarding Souths- I highly doubt they are looking to move their star players on. Arrow will play prop I imagine. Duncan possibly as well. Murray & Koloamatangi are locked in- probably second row & lock. Add Bateman.

Euan Aitken probably gets a bench spot. Moale. Tatola.

I'd say Liam Le Blanc & Jacob Host could be the likely guys to miss out.

That said- if Bateman goes, Sione Fainu is likely to get that spot.

Maybe it's a T&T player we are likely to target? There's always Liam Knight...

 

[upthetigers]

Oh I get it. The guy is very charismatic. However, how players view him once they play under him is another question. Ask Ice, Stef and Bateman.

I'd argue Ice was good for us and still wish he was playing for us. Stef has no heart and we didn't get the Bateman from the raider days. Next.

 

[Wildcat777]

It's a bit sad some posters on here care more about being right & boosting their own egos above anything else.

Agree and there seems to be a few posters that also have invested heavily in a backyard doomsday bunker!

 

[Nonotmeagain]

So if Bateman goes to Souths, it would appear they have a bit of a glut of 2RWs.
Koloamatangi, Arrow, Host, Duncan, Murray (potentially Schuster).
Would we be happy with the advertised release of Bateman (incl paying $300k of salary for next 2 years) if Souths offered Tallis Duncan in return?

They won't

 

[weststigers]

My last word on this , luai, if Pascoe had done this there would have been people screaming for his head , but because it’s Richo he seems to get a pass . It’s a done deal just dirty the fans where left in the dark about his 5 years , great start to our new culture

I think people are pretty reasonable all things considered.

If you get 9 out of 10 things right, most won't harp on about the 1 they get wrong.

The old administration was all round atrocious. Even a broken clock is right twice a day.

On the whole, I can't think of another available CEO that could have turned this roster around so quickly.

 

[balmain boy]

Any clauses

yep

 

[happy_tiger]

Probably right , and some wins early will ease the fans tension as we build and win more games , any more info on players we are still looking at for 25 or 26 .
Any one moving on that was still hear , Bateman , Naden, Bud , Tumeth , Matta.

Who is Matta ??

 

[balmain boy]

To be honest, I am not that phased. When Luai signed, he did so to a club that had just collected 2 wooden spoons and a roster that did not look likely to improve any time soon. His manager probably did the right thing here.

When he signed, we did not have any of Turuva, May, Hunt, Bird. The uncertainty over Stefano was already out in the media at this stage. Galvin hadn't stepped foot on an NRL field. Samuela Fainu was simply an add on to bring Latu to the club. No one else of his calibre even wanted to take the punt on coming aboard. The roster is looking far better since last January.

He will put 100% on the field and I can't see him signing anywhere on November 1. He will give it a red hot crack and if we can't sort our shit out and show improvement over the next 2 years...then maybe he wasn't the answer anyway and the club is stuffed anyway. If we show improvement and are at least pushing to a top 8 spot, he will remain.

Luai is a Tiger in 2025...let's focus on that! Onwards and upwards!

Luai is here to prove he can be the main man, he can run his show and be elite. He's not leaving anytime soon, he just wants to be able to renegotiate his deal for a payrise when tv deal kicks in.

Why are there so many sensationalists on here?

Would we prefer there were no clauses, sure. Was that an option? Seemingly not. If he was going to have the clauses regardless of which club he was at then it's just a non-event. Just clickbait bs from the media.

 

[balmain boy]

If Bateman is due back on a certain date then he is due back , but flying across the world for one day then going back so he can spend time with his family is a bit ruff and as said others would see this and go geezus that’s a stinker , but I’ve heard on hear the players association has confirmed he is not due back until after Xmas , again only hear say , maybe Richo can clarify it or Benji can clarify it at some point , Benji was all over what’s been said about him and John is false , no blow up etc , I gotta a feeling Benji has said to John you play like that again ( poorly and il drop you , John said we il,be next to half the team then if that how it is , Stef , John , Sezer , Naden , API at times , all played shit

What I don't get with Bateman is that his wife is here in Australia. Presumably his chid is with his wife here too.

What family is it he's spending his time with? Does he have one wife in Australia and one in the UK?? WHy is he so desperate to avoid spending time with his missus?

 

[426Tlgerland]

What I don't get with Bateman is that his wife is here in Australia. Presumably his chid is with his wife here too.

What family is it he's spending his time with? Does he have one wife in Australia and one in the UK?? WHy is he so desperate to avoid spending time with his missus?

First partner he has a daughter with who is about 12 I think , new wife is Aussie and lives hear , old partner and first child live UK

 

[426Tlgerland]

Who is Matta ??

Justin mattamau , excuse the spelling

 

[426Tlgerland]

Bulla got clauses as well , re money $ 900 k min. after couple years on current contract

 

[Nonotmeagain]

1) I don't think anyone has a right to know the employment contract provisions of anyone - just because you are a supporter gives you no greater right to a persons private work contract than anyone else.
2) It's not up to the club/player to divulge the details of a contract to anyone outside the contracting parties.
3) love this forum - part way through a psychology degree and this place tops anything my tutors have seen.

Thanks

 

[Jolls]

this was the issue to begin with !

WT will have this hanging over their heads for as long as JL is here 😂

The media doesn’t care about Brown at Parra

That was a deal done by Pascoe and Sheens - what relevance does it have to where we are now. It is also a mutual option so Bula needs to perform before we decide to take it up. It is simply a non event that we as supporters give air time to. The media will care about Brown as soon as something happens with either him or Moses - simply the nature of the beast.

 

[Tom Shines]

That was a deal done by Pascoe and Sheens - what relevance does it have to where we are now. It is also a mutual option so Bula needs to perform before we decide to take it up. It is simply a non event that we as supporters give air time to. The media will care about Brown as soon as something happens with either him or Moses - simply the nature of the beast.

It was done years ago … but just news worthy now? Why is that ?

I haven’t even read the article as yet … just reacting to what you said earlier

 

[WestsEffTheRest]

It was done years ago … but just news worthy now? Why is that ?

I haven’t even read the article as yet … just reacting to what you said earlier

Bula's mutual option was known shortly after he signed. They're just taking advantage of the clicks they'll get now that the Luai clause is known.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

Let’s all be honest

This sucks so hard

It’s a sh’t position for the club

They’ll be speculation every year about whether luai stays or leaves

Is it worth it by having him instead of him going to the bulldogs - probably

That’s all there is to it

Maybe for you. I think its pretty good. In fact. Keep us on our toes. This ain't a retirement village afterall.

 

[Tom Shines]

Bula's mutual option was known shortly after he signed. They're just taking advantage of the clicks they'll get now that the Luai clause is known.

Which is my point when others bring up Dylan Brown

 

[momo_amp_medo]

That’s pretty offensive . Calling people trained seals like you’re the oracle ? You’re a bit of a dickhead to be honest mate . You don’t even know anything about the game .
Just bitching constantly .
I take offense to your bullshit . Imagine thinking being the contrarian all the time over everything is a good thing ! It just makes you a punish .
The arrogance to even validate your existence that way .
You’re confusing pragmatism and the critical thinking with perpetual disagreement as some kind of virtue .
Hot tip ! It’s absolutely not ! Sometimes , in fact most times I’ve found that irrational confidence in something or someone makes all the difference . You can almost will something into existence .
Being a perpetual Daria is hardly an awesome to get about your existence .

Just hit ignore button on him.
You’ll have a much better time of it reading comments without his crap.