Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[weststigers]

He's been at the club 3 years and his truly great performances are countable on 1 hand.

Taylan is a much better player and with Makasini being the future... he'd be an expensive back up.

He doesn't seem that keen to stay based on his interview a week or so ago.

 

[Demps]

He would likely push Skelton out of our top 17 when we are full strength, but other way it would certainly create great competition for NRL positions.

I think he'll stay at the Sharks.

Much like Kayal Iro, who was available but stayed in cup developing now he's a genuine star and starter [when not injured]... they've taken the same approach with Stonestreet.

He'll replace Sione Katoa eventually and become that guy.

 

[Vicious]

He's been at the club 3 years and his truly great performances are countable on 1 hand.

Taylan is a much better player and with Makasini being the future... he'd be an expensive back up.

And it’s debatable if he would be a better centre back up than Luke Laulilli at this time next year.

 

[weststigers]

Is it better to keep our first grade backs on their toes or sign a couple of starting mids ?

You and everyone else k ows the answer. Poor old Vicious is always window shopping.

 

[Vicious]

I think he'll stay at the Sharks.

Much like Kayal Iro, who was available but stayed in cup developing now he's a genuine star and starter [when not injured]... they've taken the same approach with Stonestreet.

He'll replace Sione Katoa eventually and become that guy.

Possibly, but there’s also a chance that he’s fed up waiting and not prepared to wait any longer.

 

[Tom Shines]

You and everyone else k ows the answer. Poor old Vicious is always window shopping.

I wonder how local junior Luke Lauilii feels if we sign another depth winger to force him down the depth chart …

 

[Demps]

He doesn't seem that keen to stay based on his interview a week or so ago.

Yeah, along with his form has fallen off massively..

Can say that's because he's injured. That arm looks cooked... but, I think he's on the way out for sure.

Which could see us moving to keep other options such as Staines, Mapapalangi, Tui'toops and MOST importantly, Taylan May.

 

[weststigers]

We finally agree on one.
It’s very clear our current team lacks aggression, Talakai is highly aggressive, so helps fix that problem.
I’d also take a close look at Hamlin-Uele for the same reason.

Talakai yes. Hamlin-Uele, not as sure. It would depend on the dollars he was asking.

 

[Vicious]

You and everyone else k ows the answer. Poor old Vicious is always window shopping.

Correct.
I am not staying loyal to too many players who have helped us to 14th position on the ladder.
The ones I’m getting rid of are not capable of winning grand finals at NRL level anytime soon.

 

[Vicious]

Talakai yes. Hamlin-Uele, not as sure. It would depend on the dollars he was asking.

Maybe offload his old mate Royce and bring Hamlin-Uele in to replace him ?

 

[Tom Shines]

Maybe offload his old mate Royce and bring Hamlin-Uele in to replace him ?

Offloading is our thing … maybe he could do us a solid and show up late for training a couple of times ?

 

[Demps]

Talakai.
Tongan connection with the Fainu bros.

 

[Vicious]

Offloading is our thing … maybe he could do us a solid and show up late for training a couple of times ?

Just tell him he will be doing the Beep Test every day for 3 months over the offseason with standards to meet and he will volunteer to leave.

 

[weststigers]

Maybe offload his old mate Royce and bring Hamlin-Uele in to replace him ?

Royce is alright. He's probably on a bit too much money though. The word is they are trying to extract more minutes out of him and that's why he's been in cup so long.

 

[Tom Shines]

Just tell him he will be doing the Beep Test every day for 3 months over the offseason, he will volunteer to leave.

Based on his early form this season he is far from the worst in the squad … he is probably smart enough to get himself through reserve grade for two years if they want to play hard ball

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

I wonder how local junior Luke Lauilii feels if we sign another depth winger to force him down the depth chart …

I wonder how local junior Luke Laulilii feels about Heath Mason being played at fullback to force him down the depth chart too ... (imo Luke L already a better fullback & higher ceiling).

 

[tigahhh]

I wonder how local junior Luke Laulilii feels about Heath Mason being played at fullback to force him down the depth chart too ... (imo Luke L already a better fullback & higher ceiling).

exactly 😂 sick of them not playing him at fb

 

[Tom Shines]

I wonder how local junior Luke Laulilii feels about Heath Mason being played at fullback to force him down the depth chart too ... (imo Luke L already a better fullback & higher ceiling).

I agree Luke would feel he is better …

I assume Luke feels he will beat out Mason who is probably on a minimum deal..,Mason is a bad option at 1 until he can acquire more confidence under the high ball,,

Tino looks like he is the reserve fullback now …so Luke needs to concentrate on that no 3 wing spot

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

I'd love Talakai he's a beast, on To'a i don't rate him he's games are far more rocks than diamonds he's too inconsistent if he left i wouldnt be fussed. Even if you picked up a Hiroti type player to cover him what are you really losing that one or two decent games he has a season.

 

[mtd#2]

I wonder how local junior Luke Lauilii feels if we sign another depth winger to force him down the depth chart …

He's only forced down the depth chart if he isn't as good as someone we sign... So who's problem is that? Is that not then on Luke to improve? Or do we keep trying to hand everything on a platter to players just because they come through our system?