Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[pawsandclaws1]

I think I will take a punt on JREY still being with us next year,he is working well with Brooks and his game is becoming more dynamic with Grub in the team...just my opinion Im not Madge,but he has made some decisions we didn't expect from him eg Benji relegated to bench,McIntyre into 17 and generally getting the team to make their defense a priority rather than hail mary attack that we have been used to..
Whatever Madge decides for this team I bet it will be for their benefit for a competitive future getting to be top finals prospects,playing for 80 and being consistent week in week out..

I honestly don't know what plans he has for Walters and Madden,but Im sure Madge will give them an opportunity to show their worth....

TT he is on $800k so his game should be up there with Munster and Ponga. Do you honestly believe he is?

I believe JR is doing what Madge wants atm...irrespective of what his price is,it was negotiated by a former coach,not JRs fault,so in having said that,he must be in good shape and Madge is utilising him in the 5/8 position...I believe he is doing the best he can for us and always TRIES his best,I don't want to compare him to other people because he is what we have got to best fill the void....
Munster and Ponga are very good footballers in 2 different systems atm,I wonder how they would go here under the same circumstances JR has been through with injuries etc..

You have been very critical of Brooks. Isn't he doing what Maguire wants atm also, albeit on far less $ and with less experience than JR? I believe JR is not providing bang for buck and needs to lift his game significantly.

Paws you have an opinion that your entitled to in regards to JR...Madge must have a view where he seems to think JR is benefitting the team and that's why he selects him...If you read my post in the wts v dogs thread you would have read that I admitted openly of being critical of Brooks in the past but have also praised his improved game …
The one main theme in your post is how JR must lift his game significantly because of the money he is on...that was what he was contracted on,go and speak to Cleary about that,as far as I can see is that Madge is playing JR because our Iconic 5/8 had defensive issues so Madge is utilising JR because he was an origin player and has significant experience in that position,albeit he was sidelined for a very long time and is now getting game time and adapting to the new rules as well..

As far as Brooks goes I have praised him in the other thread,its a poor argument saying he hasn't got the experience JR has,he has had 7 years of NRL experience and JR is a fair bit older..

Regardless of who is in charge, an employee should be performing commensurate with their contract. He has more experience than any half at our club. He should be doing much better but is not. The.team needs him to lift.

You keep saying he needs to lift...he has been sidelined for a long time and was put it because our specialist iconic 5/8 wasn't doing what Madge wanted in regard to defence..JR is just starting to get into a rythym and working with Brooks,they are both improving their game..
You keep pushing your agenda against JR,we get it you don't like him and he should be putting in more...How about you get his injuries and go through what he has in his personal life and see if you SIGNIFICANTLY put in overnight...

TT, the Cowboys are not in the best of form. We handback possession, gift tries or giveaway field position like we did in the second half it will be a carve up when we play the Roosters, Panthers or the Storm. The fact the one, if not the main offender was JR,seems to be lost on you.

Brooks won Dally M halfback with I believe Marshall at his side and also at least one WTs player of the year. If I recall Marshall came back from a number of very serious shoulder injuries, is a WTs great and will always be remembered fondly by most discerning supporters of RL. JR not so much.

 

[Telltails]

If you keep laying blame at the players around Brooks instead of making him accountable for his own flaws - he will never improve I think Brooks is fine player but his faults are his alone.The common denominator for all the games Brooks hasn't played well is Brooks.

 

[Elderslie_Tiger]

Jarrod Wallace apparently a chance to depart Gold Coast Titans effective immediately, the dragons are interested...

I’d take him on a good deal for sure, would be a great starting prop alongside Aloiai - with Mikaele coming off the bench

Much better than Clarke and would be a good replacement for Musgrove

What's going on at the Titans, Arrow going Wallace wants out must be their version of last man standing.

 

[Cairnstigers]

How many releases can dragons deny him? Third one next week apparently

Do you really want someone who wants a release cause it's too far to travel..

Chris Heighnington use to come from the Central Coast as a young bloke ...just to get a shot..

Not really a good attitude that Maguire would be looking for..

Just a smoke screen
If he was playing every week travelling wouldn't be an issue

Oh..make up a smokescreen for not getting a run..even better..

What happens the next Club doesn't give him a run for any reason..is that the sort of standard you want..?

Difference is right now he deserves a run and isn’t getting it. If you deserve a promotion and your boss is picking someone who’s worse than you to do it, wouldn’t you move? I would. Kid shouldn’t of signed an extension for so long he royally stuffed up there and if dragons make him stay I’ve got no issue with that.

I guess that's the youth of today..entitlement

What if the next Club he goes to is not giving him a run for whatever reason..?

If it’s for a valid reason then he shouldn’t chuck a sook. He deserves that spot and isn’t getting it from what I can see, that doesn’t seem like entitlement. Heard dogs are favourites to sign him anyway

I understand what you're saying but unless he signed the contract with a guarantee he'd be put in first grade he really doesn't have the right to complain. Should just work hard to try and make first grade.

Who’s to say he hasn’t worked hard? He’d be better than Ravalawa that bloke can’t catch a footy. Doueihi left Rabbitohs for the same reasons and he’s turned out very good. I have faith that Madge knows who’s gonna work hard and who won’t. Signed some good guys and got rid of lazy guys like Marsters

The Doueihi situation was a little different. He was a consistent first grader who was (reportedly) told he'd have the fullback spot for 2020. After Mitchell signed, that went away. Understandably AD asked Wayne if he could go elsewhere and Wayne obliged. Pretty amicable.

Compare that with a guy like Saab who was signed to a 4 year contract in late 2018 with the understanding the first two years (19/20) would be on a development contract, with him moving to firsts in 21. He got his opportunity in late 2019 due to good performances in in reserves and now he wants to play 1st grade all the time. Asking for a release every week because you're not getting game time is a bit stupid. He's still meant to be a development player.

When was he told he’s a development player? He’s in the top 30 if he’s earned the spot he should be there I can understand his frustration.

This is off the Dragons website when announcing his signing:

"Saab will join the development player squad for the next two years, before he joins the NRL Top 30 for the 2021 and 2022 NRL Telstra Premiership seasons."

I think he's going on like a bit of a goose actually. If I asked for a release and my coach said no i'd say fair enough, and get back to it. I wouldn't ask every bloody week. Saints have enough issues, he's not helping his teammates by acting this way. Might be a great player, but sounds to be a bit entitled...

But he’s not a development player now he’s in the top 30 and deserves the spot. Kid shouldn’t of signed such a long deal a blind man could see how poor the dragons were going. Like I said Madge wouldn’t sign someone who has a poor attitude and work ethic

He was happy to be a development player when he signed the contract and the Saints have done absolutely nothing wrong by him. The Saints only mistake was giving the guy a chance in 2019. If they hadn't, he wouldn't have any interest from other clubs. He's the one that's out of line, not the Saints.

Madge isn't some mystical oracle that knows all. He's just a coach, better than some and not as good as others. He wouldn't have any more of an understanding of his attitude or work ethic than any other coach would.

BTW, didn't Musgrove sit out the first game because he came back from the break in poor condition? Who signed him again?

Exactly mate, almost like this kid is trying to do a Matterson/Moses to the Dragons.
Maybe he should go join the Slime with that attitude.

He is not getting a game at the Dragons
Nothing wrong with him looking elsewhere
I wouldn't mind if McQueen, Packer, Taylor all asked for a release
I am sure we would all be ok with that

 

[momo_amp_medo]

How many releases can dragons deny him? Third one next week apparently

Do you really want someone who wants a release cause it's too far to travel..

Chris Heighnington use to come from the Central Coast as a young bloke ...just to get a shot..

Not really a good attitude that Maguire would be looking for..

Just a smoke screen
If he was playing every week travelling wouldn't be an issue

Oh..make up a smokescreen for not getting a run..even better..

What happens the next Club doesn't give him a run for any reason..is that the sort of standard you want..?

Difference is right now he deserves a run and isn’t getting it. If you deserve a promotion and your boss is picking someone who’s worse than you to do it, wouldn’t you move? I would. Kid shouldn’t of signed an extension for so long he royally stuffed up there and if dragons make him stay I’ve got no issue with that.

I guess that's the youth of today..entitlement

What if the next Club he goes to is not giving him a run for whatever reason..?

If it’s for a valid reason then he shouldn’t chuck a sook. He deserves that spot and isn’t getting it from what I can see, that doesn’t seem like entitlement. Heard dogs are favourites to sign him anyway

I understand what you're saying but unless he signed the contract with a guarantee he'd be put in first grade he really doesn't have the right to complain. Should just work hard to try and make first grade.

Who’s to say he hasn’t worked hard? He’d be better than Ravalawa that bloke can’t catch a footy. Doueihi left Rabbitohs for the same reasons and he’s turned out very good. I have faith that Madge knows who’s gonna work hard and who won’t. Signed some good guys and got rid of lazy guys like Marsters

The Doueihi situation was a little different. He was a consistent first grader who was (reportedly) told he'd have the fullback spot for 2020. After Mitchell signed, that went away. Understandably AD asked Wayne if he could go elsewhere and Wayne obliged. Pretty amicable.

Compare that with a guy like Saab who was signed to a 4 year contract in late 2018 with the understanding the first two years (19/20) would be on a development contract, with him moving to firsts in 21. He got his opportunity in late 2019 due to good performances in in reserves and now he wants to play 1st grade all the time. Asking for a release every week because you're not getting game time is a bit stupid. He's still meant to be a development player.

When was he told he’s a development player? He’s in the top 30 if he’s earned the spot he should be there I can understand his frustration.

This is off the Dragons website when announcing his signing:

"Saab will join the development player squad for the next two years, before he joins the NRL Top 30 for the 2021 and 2022 NRL Telstra Premiership seasons."

I think he's going on like a bit of a goose actually. If I asked for a release and my coach said no i'd say fair enough, and get back to it. I wouldn't ask every bloody week. Saints have enough issues, he's not helping his teammates by acting this way. Might be a great player, but sounds to be a bit entitled...

But he’s not a development player now he’s in the top 30 and deserves the spot. Kid shouldn’t of signed such a long deal a blind man could see how poor the dragons were going. Like I said Madge wouldn’t sign someone who has a poor attitude and work ethic

He was happy to be a development player when he signed the contract and the Saints have done absolutely nothing wrong by him. The Saints only mistake was giving the guy a chance in 2019. If they hadn't, he wouldn't have any interest from other clubs. He's the one that's out of line, not the Saints.

Madge isn't some mystical oracle that knows all. He's just a coach, better than some and not as good as others. He wouldn't have any more of an understanding of his attitude or work ethic than any other coach would.

BTW, didn't Musgrove sit out the first game because he came back from the break in poor condition? Who signed him again?

Exactly mate, almost like this kid is trying to do a Matterson/Moses to the Dragons.
Maybe he should go join the Slime with that attitude.

He is not getting a game at the Dragons
Nothing wrong with him looking elsewhere
I wouldn't mind if McQueen, Packer, Taylor all asked for a release
I am sure we would all be ok with that

Two out of three are out of contract after this season ..... so your wish has materialised ..... almost!

 

[WT2K]

Jarrod Wallace apparently a chance to depart Gold Coast Titans effective immediately, the dragons are interested...

I’d take him on a good deal for sure, would be a great starting prop alongside Aloiai - with Mikaele coming off the bench

Much better than Clarke and would be a good replacement for Musgrove

Would be a good next to Aloiai as you say.

 

[tonza]

I think I will take a punt on JREY still being with us next year,he is working well with Brooks and his game is becoming more dynamic with Grub in the team...just my opinion Im not Madge,but he has made some decisions we didn't expect from him eg Benji relegated to bench,McIntyre into 17 and generally getting the team to make their defense a priority rather than hail mary attack that we have been used to..
Whatever Madge decides for this team I bet it will be for their benefit for a competitive future getting to be top finals prospects,playing for 80 and being consistent week in week out..

I honestly don't know what plans he has for Walters and Madden,but Im sure Madge will give them an opportunity to show their worth....

TT he is on $800k so his game should be up there with Munster and Ponga. Do you honestly believe he is?

I believe JR is doing what Madge wants atm...irrespective of what his price is,it was negotiated by a former coach,not JRs fault,so in having said that,he must be in good shape and Madge is utilising him in the 5/8 position...I believe he is doing the best he can for us and always TRIES his best,I don't want to compare him to other people because he is what we have got to best fill the void....
Munster and Ponga are very good footballers in 2 different systems atm,I wonder how they would go here under the same circumstances JR has been through with injuries etc..

You have been very critical of Brooks. Isn't he doing what Maguire wants atm also, albeit on far less $ and with less experience than JR? I believe JR is not providing bang for buck and needs to lift his game significantly.

Paws you have an opinion that your entitled to in regards to JR...Madge must have a view where he seems to think JR is benefitting the team and that's why he selects him...If you read my post in the wts v dogs thread you would have read that I admitted openly of being critical of Brooks in the past but have also praised his improved game …
The one main theme in your post is how JR must lift his game significantly because of the money he is on...that was what he was contracted on,go and speak to Cleary about that,as far as I can see is that Madge is playing JR because our Iconic 5/8 had defensive issues so Madge is utilising JR because he was an origin player and has significant experience in that position,albeit he was sidelined for a very long time and is now getting game time and adapting to the new rules as well..

As far as Brooks goes I have praised him in the other thread,its a poor argument saying he hasn't got the experience JR has,he has had 7 years of NRL experience and JR is a fair bit older..

Regardless of who is in charge, an employee should be performing commensurate with their contract. He has more experience than any half at our club. He should be doing much better but is not. The.team needs him to lift.

You keep saying he needs to lift...he has been sidelined for a long time and was put it because our specialist iconic 5/8 wasn't doing what Madge wanted in regard to defence..JR is just starting to get into a rythym and working with Brooks,they are both improving their game..
You keep pushing your agenda against JR,we get it you don't like him and he should be putting in more...How about you get his injuries and go through what he has in his personal life and see if you SIGNIFICANTLY put in overnight...

You add the footy experience between our 3 halves as a whole and they are far more experienced than any other side ..and by a fair bit

They are underachieving ....simple as that

Happy,you can say what you like,Benji defensive liability and is on the way out..
Brooks has improved immensely since Benji was benched...
Reynolds has been put in to play 5/8 because our club legend is fading slightly in his game...Reynolds had to play reggies while Benji kept getting selected,he is now getting game time and adapting to the new rules...
You reckon you know so much about the game but don't give credit to a bloke (JR) for at least having a go and giving what he can from the little game time he has had..
we know what simple is....

Reynolds is a good player ...just doesn't suit our side

Not sure how you have seen Brooks improve without Marshall around

His Canberra game wasn't great ...even Geo owned that

I agree his Raiders game wasn't that good,but when he played the Cows his game was much improved,especially his running game,and it will only get better as the season progresses ...In my opinion he is playing his natural game with JR in the side,he is not being choked by Benji calling the shots and he has to get used to having Grub as his halves partner after having Benji there all the time...

Was Benji playing with Brooks when he was at dragon’s or the broncos, but I guess he was still holding him back even when he wasn’t at the club

As much as I respect Reynolds and Brooks, neither of them was able to come up with any points for us, when needed, in the second half of our last two games. Benji would have at least tried. For me , Foran is the answer for the next few years. Subject to him getting through these coming months without injury. The bloke is all class, will not cost anything like he is being paid now, and is at the top of the list of those halves available. He turns 30 in July and we could get 2 or 3 years at the top level.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Jarrod Wallace apparently a chance to depart Gold Coast Titans effective immediately, the dragons are interested...

I’d take him on a good deal for sure, would be a great starting prop alongside Aloiai - with Mikaele coming off the bench

Much better than Clarke and would be a good replacement for Musgrove

What's going on at the Titans, Arrow going Wallace wants out must be their version of last man standing.

Irony that the Dragons want the Titans to release Wallace but are resisting the same outcome for Saab.

 

[Cairnstigers]

Jarrod Wallace apparently a chance to depart Gold Coast Titans effective immediately, the dragons are interested...

I’d take him on a good deal for sure, would be a great starting prop alongside Aloiai - with Mikaele coming off the bench

Much better than Clarke and would be a good replacement for Musgrove

What's going on at the Titans, Arrow going Wallace wants out must be their version of last man standing.

Irony that the Dragons want the Titans to release Wallace but are resisting the same outcome for Saab.

Hang on
If only we waited
Thompson to Titans
Wallace to StGeorge
Saab to Tigers
Dam
We pulled the trigger to early again

 

[bbobb]

@pawsandclaws1 said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1168833)

I think I will take a punt on JREY still being with us next year,he is working well with Brooks and his game is becoming more dynamic with Grub in the team...just my opinion Im not Madge,but he has made some decisions we didn't expect from him eg Benji relegated to bench,McIntyre into 17 and generally getting the team to make their defense a priority rather than hail mary attack that we have been used to..
Whatever Madge decides for this team I bet it will be for their benefit for a competitive future getting to be top finals prospects,playing for 80 and being consistent week in week out..

I honestly don't know what plans he has for Walters and Madden,but Im sure Madge will give them an opportunity to show their worth....

TT he is on $800k so his game should be up there with Munster and Ponga. Do you honestly believe he is?

I believe JR is doing what Madge wants atm...irrespective of what his price is,it was negotiated by a former coach,not JRs fault,so in having said that,he must be in good shape and Madge is utilising him in the 5/8 position...I believe he is doing the best he can for us and always TRIES his best,I don't want to compare him to other people because he is what we have got to best fill the void....
Munster and Ponga are very good footballers in 2 different systems atm,I wonder how they would go here under the same circumstances JR has been through with injuries etc..

You have been very critical of Brooks. Isn't he doing what Maguire wants atm also, albeit on far less $ and with less experience than JR? I believe JR is not providing bang for buck and needs to lift his game significantly.

Paws you have an opinion that your entitled to in regards to JR...Madge must have a view where he seems to think JR is benefitting the team and that's why he selects him...If you read my post in the wts v dogs thread you would have read that I admitted openly of being critical of Brooks in the past but have also praised his improved game …
The one main theme in your post is how JR must lift his game significantly because of the money he is on...that was what he was contracted on,go and speak to Cleary about that,as far as I can see is that Madge is playing JR because our Iconic 5/8 had defensive issues so Madge is utilising JR because he was an origin player and has significant experience in that position,albeit he was sidelined for a very long time and is now getting game time and adapting to the new rules as well..

As far as Brooks goes I have praised him in the other thread,its a poor argument saying he hasn't got the experience JR has,he has had 7 years of NRL experience and JR is a fair bit older..

Regardless of who is in charge, an employee should be performing commensurate with their contract. He has more experience than any half at our club. He should be doing much better but is not. The.team needs him to lift.

You keep saying he needs to lift...he has been sidelined for a long time and was put it because our specialist iconic 5/8 wasn't doing what Madge wanted in regard to defence..JR is just starting to get into a rythym and working with Brooks,they are both improving their game..
You keep pushing your agenda against JR,we get it you don't like him and he should be putting in more...How about you get his injuries and go through what he has in his personal life and see if you SIGNIFICANTLY put in overnight...

You add the footy experience between our 3 halves as a whole and they are far more experienced than any other side ..and by a fair bit

They are underachieving ....simple as that

Happy,you can say what you like,Benji defensive liability and is on the way out..
Brooks has improved immensely since Benji was benched...
Reynolds has been put in to play 5/8 because our club legend is fading slightly in his game...Reynolds had to play reggies while Benji kept getting selected,he is now getting game time and adapting to the new rules...
You reckon you know so much about the game but don't give credit to a bloke (JR) for at least having a go and giving what he can from the little game time he has had..
we know what simple is....

Reynolds is a good player ...just doesn't suit our side

Not sure how you have seen Brooks improve without Marshall around

His Canberra game wasn't great ...even Geo owned that

I agree his Raiders game wasn't that good,but when he played the Cows his game was much improved,especially his running game,and it will only get better as the season progresses ...In my opinion he is playing his natural game with JR in the side,he is not being choked by Benji calling the shots and he has to get used to having Grub as his halves partner after having Benji there all the time...

Was Benji playing with Brooks when he was at dragon’s or the broncos, but I guess he was still holding him back even when he wasn’t at the club

Doesn't matter how much you want to sugar coat it,,,Benji stagnated Brooks game once he came back here...

didn't Brooks win Dally M halfback of the year when Marshall came back?

He did but do you put that down to Benji or Lukes natural ability and being coached by Madge...

Cleary coached our team in 2018....

So Brooks win Dally M in 2018 under Cleary who is now coaching the Leaders of the comp this year...I thought Luke won 2019 Dally M under Madge who is a premiership winning coach....

But lets put it down to the brilliance of our 5/8 Benji who has defensive liabilities and is on the bench as we speak...

I think Brooks plays better when he isn’t the dominant half. He needs someone to run the team and he plays a bit more “eyes up” footy and has the freedom to run the ball . I think he is far more effective in that type of role.

Trouble is so is JRey

 

[Geo]

Cammy is off Contract ..2 year deal to play halfback..

 

[TheDaBoss]

Cammy is off Contract ..2 year deal to play halfback..

isnt he already on a 2 year contract to ref ?

 

[Guest]

I think I will take a punt on JREY still being with us next year,he is working well with Brooks and his game is becoming more dynamic with Grub in the team...just my opinion Im not Madge,but he has made some decisions we didn't expect from him eg Benji relegated to bench,McIntyre into 17 and generally getting the team to make their defense a priority rather than hail mary attack that we have been used to..
Whatever Madge decides for this team I bet it will be for their benefit for a competitive future getting to be top finals prospects,playing for 80 and being consistent week in week out..

I honestly don't know what plans he has for Walters and Madden,but Im sure Madge will give them an opportunity to show their worth....

TT he is on $800k so his game should be up there with Munster and Ponga. Do you honestly believe he is?

I believe JR is doing what Madge wants atm...irrespective of what his price is,it was negotiated by a former coach,not JRs fault,so in having said that,he must be in good shape and Madge is utilising him in the 5/8 position...I believe he is doing the best he can for us and always TRIES his best,I don't want to compare him to other people because he is what we have got to best fill the void....
Munster and Ponga are very good footballers in 2 different systems atm,I wonder how they would go here under the same circumstances JR has been through with injuries etc..

You have been very critical of Brooks. Isn't he doing what Maguire wants atm also, albeit on far less $ and with less experience than JR? I believe JR is not providing bang for buck and needs to lift his game significantly.

Paws you have an opinion that your entitled to in regards to JR...Madge must have a view where he seems to think JR is benefitting the team and that's why he selects him...If you read my post in the wts v dogs thread you would have read that I admitted openly of being critical of Brooks in the past but have also praised his improved game …
The one main theme in your post is how JR must lift his game significantly because of the money he is on...that was what he was contracted on,go and speak to Cleary about that,as far as I can see is that Madge is playing JR because our Iconic 5/8 had defensive issues so Madge is utilising JR because he was an origin player and has significant experience in that position,albeit he was sidelined for a very long time and is now getting game time and adapting to the new rules as well..

As far as Brooks goes I have praised him in the other thread,its a poor argument saying he hasn't got the experience JR has,he has had 7 years of NRL experience and JR is a fair bit older..

Regardless of who is in charge, an employee should be performing commensurate with their contract. He has more experience than any half at our club. He should be doing much better but is not. The.team needs him to lift.

You keep saying he needs to lift...he has been sidelined for a long time and was put it because our specialist iconic 5/8 wasn't doing what Madge wanted in regard to defence..JR is just starting to get into a rythym and working with Brooks,they are both improving their game..
You keep pushing your agenda against JR,we get it you don't like him and he should be putting in more...How about you get his injuries and go through what he has in his personal life and see if you SIGNIFICANTLY put in overnight...

You add the footy experience between our 3 halves as a whole and they are far more experienced than any other side ..and by a fair bit

They are underachieving ....simple as that

Happy,you can say what you like,Benji defensive liability and is on the way out..
Brooks has improved immensely since Benji was benched...
Reynolds has been put in to play 5/8 because our club legend is fading slightly in his game...Reynolds had to play reggies while Benji kept getting selected,he is now getting game time and adapting to the new rules...
You reckon you know so much about the game but don't give credit to a bloke (JR) for at least having a go and giving what he can from the little game time he has had..
we know what simple is....

Reynolds is a good player ...just doesn't suit our side

Not sure how you have seen Brooks improve without Marshall around

His Canberra game wasn't great ...even Geo owned that

I agree his Raiders game wasn't that good,but when he played the Cows his game was much improved,especially his running game,and it will only get better as the season progresses ...In my opinion he is playing his natural game with JR in the side,he is not being choked by Benji calling the shots and he has to get used to having Grub as his halves partner after having Benji there all the time...

Was Benji playing with Brooks when he was at dragon’s or the broncos, but I guess he was still holding him back even when he wasn’t at the club

As much as I respect Reynolds and Brooks, neither of them was able to come up with any points for us, when needed, in the second half of our last two games. Benji would have at least tried. For me , Foran is the answer for the next few years. Subject to him getting through these coming months without injury. The bloke is all class, will not cost anything like he is being paid now, and is at the top of the list of those halves available. He turns 30 in July and we could get 2 or 3 years at the top level.

Foran's body is broken. He makes about as much sense as Milo Kerrigan.

 

[Fade.To.Black]

I think I will take a punt on JREY still being with us next year,he is working well with Brooks and his game is becoming more dynamic with Grub in the team...just my opinion Im not Madge,but he has made some decisions we didn't expect from him eg Benji relegated to bench,McIntyre into 17 and generally getting the team to make their defense a priority rather than hail mary attack that we have been used to..
Whatever Madge decides for this team I bet it will be for their benefit for a competitive future getting to be top finals prospects,playing for 80 and being consistent week in week out..

I honestly don't know what plans he has for Walters and Madden,but Im sure Madge will give them an opportunity to show their worth....

TT he is on $800k so his game should be up there with Munster and Ponga. Do you honestly believe he is?

I believe JR is doing what Madge wants atm...irrespective of what his price is,it was negotiated by a former coach,not JRs fault,so in having said that,he must be in good shape and Madge is utilising him in the 5/8 position...I believe he is doing the best he can for us and always TRIES his best,I don't want to compare him to other people because he is what we have got to best fill the void....
Munster and Ponga are very good footballers in 2 different systems atm,I wonder how they would go here under the same circumstances JR has been through with injuries etc..

You have been very critical of Brooks. Isn't he doing what Maguire wants atm also, albeit on far less $ and with less experience than JR? I believe JR is not providing bang for buck and needs to lift his game significantly.

Paws you have an opinion that your entitled to in regards to JR...Madge must have a view where he seems to think JR is benefitting the team and that's why he selects him...If you read my post in the wts v dogs thread you would have read that I admitted openly of being critical of Brooks in the past but have also praised his improved game …
The one main theme in your post is how JR must lift his game significantly because of the money he is on...that was what he was contracted on,go and speak to Cleary about that,as far as I can see is that Madge is playing JR because our Iconic 5/8 had defensive issues so Madge is utilising JR because he was an origin player and has significant experience in that position,albeit he was sidelined for a very long time and is now getting game time and adapting to the new rules as well..

As far as Brooks goes I have praised him in the other thread,its a poor argument saying he hasn't got the experience JR has,he has had 7 years of NRL experience and JR is a fair bit older..

Regardless of who is in charge, an employee should be performing commensurate with their contract. He has more experience than any half at our club. He should be doing much better but is not. The.team needs him to lift.

You keep saying he needs to lift...he has been sidelined for a long time and was put it because our specialist iconic 5/8 wasn't doing what Madge wanted in regard to defence..JR is just starting to get into a rythym and working with Brooks,they are both improving their game..
You keep pushing your agenda against JR,we get it you don't like him and he should be putting in more...How about you get his injuries and go through what he has in his personal life and see if you SIGNIFICANTLY put in overnight...

You add the footy experience between our 3 halves as a whole and they are far more experienced than any other side ..and by a fair bit

They are underachieving ....simple as that

Happy,you can say what you like,Benji defensive liability and is on the way out..
Brooks has improved immensely since Benji was benched...
Reynolds has been put in to play 5/8 because our club legend is fading slightly in his game...Reynolds had to play reggies while Benji kept getting selected,he is now getting game time and adapting to the new rules...
You reckon you know so much about the game but don't give credit to a bloke (JR) for at least having a go and giving what he can from the little game time he has had..
we know what simple is....

Reynolds is a good player ...just doesn't suit our side

Not sure how you have seen Brooks improve without Marshall around

His Canberra game wasn't great ...even Geo owned that

I agree his Raiders game wasn't that good,but when he played the Cows his game was much improved,especially his running game,and it will only get better as the season progresses ...In my opinion he is playing his natural game with JR in the side,he is not being choked by Benji calling the shots and he has to get used to having Grub as his halves partner after having Benji there all the time...

Was Benji playing with Brooks when he was at dragon’s or the broncos, but I guess he was still holding him back even when he wasn’t at the club

As much as I respect Reynolds and Brooks, neither of them was able to come up with any points for us, when needed, in the second half of our last two games. Benji would have at least tried. For me , Foran is the answer for the next few years. Subject to him getting through these coming months without injury. The bloke is all class, will not cost anything like he is being paid now, and is at the top of the list of those halves available. He turns 30 in July and we could get 2 or 3 years at the top level.

Foran's body is broken. He makes about as much sense as Milo Kerrigan.

Milo Kerrigan aka Sammy Burgess

 

[happy_tiger]

I think I will take a punt on JREY still being with us next year,he is working well with Brooks and his game is becoming more dynamic with Grub in the team...just my opinion Im not Madge,but he has made some decisions we didn't expect from him eg Benji relegated to bench,McIntyre into 17 and generally getting the team to make their defense a priority rather than hail mary attack that we have been used to..
Whatever Madge decides for this team I bet it will be for their benefit for a competitive future getting to be top finals prospects,playing for 80 and being consistent week in week out..

I honestly don't know what plans he has for Walters and Madden,but Im sure Madge will give them an opportunity to show their worth....

TT he is on $800k so his game should be up there with Munster and Ponga. Do you honestly believe he is?

I believe JR is doing what Madge wants atm...irrespective of what his price is,it was negotiated by a former coach,not JRs fault,so in having said that,he must be in good shape and Madge is utilising him in the 5/8 position...I believe he is doing the best he can for us and always TRIES his best,I don't want to compare him to other people because he is what we have got to best fill the void....
Munster and Ponga are very good footballers in 2 different systems atm,I wonder how they would go here under the same circumstances JR has been through with injuries etc..

You have been very critical of Brooks. Isn't he doing what Maguire wants atm also, albeit on far less $ and with less experience than JR? I believe JR is not providing bang for buck and needs to lift his game significantly.

Paws you have an opinion that your entitled to in regards to JR...Madge must have a view where he seems to think JR is benefitting the team and that's why he selects him...If you read my post in the wts v dogs thread you would have read that I admitted openly of being critical of Brooks in the past but have also praised his improved game …
The one main theme in your post is how JR must lift his game significantly because of the money he is on...that was what he was contracted on,go and speak to Cleary about that,as far as I can see is that Madge is playing JR because our Iconic 5/8 had defensive issues so Madge is utilising JR because he was an origin player and has significant experience in that position,albeit he was sidelined for a very long time and is now getting game time and adapting to the new rules as well..

As far as Brooks goes I have praised him in the other thread,its a poor argument saying he hasn't got the experience JR has,he has had 7 years of NRL experience and JR is a fair bit older..

Regardless of who is in charge, an employee should be performing commensurate with their contract. He has more experience than any half at our club. He should be doing much better but is not. The.team needs him to lift.

You keep saying he needs to lift...he has been sidelined for a long time and was put it because our specialist iconic 5/8 wasn't doing what Madge wanted in regard to defence..JR is just starting to get into a rythym and working with Brooks,they are both improving their game..
You keep pushing your agenda against JR,we get it you don't like him and he should be putting in more...How about you get his injuries and go through what he has in his personal life and see if you SIGNIFICANTLY put in overnight...

You add the footy experience between our 3 halves as a whole and they are far more experienced than any other side ..and by a fair bit

They are underachieving ....simple as that

Happy,you can say what you like,Benji defensive liability and is on the way out..
Brooks has improved immensely since Benji was benched...
Reynolds has been put in to play 5/8 because our club legend is fading slightly in his game...Reynolds had to play reggies while Benji kept getting selected,he is now getting game time and adapting to the new rules...
You reckon you know so much about the game but don't give credit to a bloke (JR) for at least having a go and giving what he can from the little game time he has had..
we know what simple is....

Reynolds is a good player ...just doesn't suit our side

Not sure how you have seen Brooks improve without Marshall around

His Canberra game wasn't great ...even Geo owned that

I agree his Raiders game wasn't that good,but when he played the Cows his game was much improved,especially his running game,and it will only get better as the season progresses ...In my opinion he is playing his natural game with JR in the side,he is not being choked by Benji calling the shots and he has to get used to having Grub as his halves partner after having Benji there all the time...

Was Benji playing with Brooks when he was at dragon’s or the broncos, but I guess he was still holding him back even when he wasn’t at the club

As much as I respect Reynolds and Brooks, neither of them was able to come up with any points for us, when needed, in the second half of our last two games. Benji would have at least tried. For me , Foran is the answer for the next few years. Subject to him getting through these coming months without injury. The bloke is all class, will not cost anything like he is being paid now, and is at the top of the list of those halves available. He turns 30 in July and we could get 2 or 3 years at the top level.

Foran's body is broken. He makes about as much sense as Milo Kerrigan.

Leave Milo out of this ...the man was a genius

 

[Holman Barnes #1 Fan]

On Saab, looking like he will be at the dogs IF released but it is really up in the air. Major cash being thrown at a some players by them.

On another note, most Sydney clubs have been in discussions to resume playing informal (non-Canterbury Cup) reserve grade games against one another to keep players fit. Will need clearance from the NRL.

Why would the dogs have more cash than us? Unless they're offering 500k then we can match what they can.
They don't have much cash having already splurged on Thompson. And Dwz, hopoate already on big money and no halves. And who knows who their coach will be. A lot of risk.

On the other hand we're a perennially unsuccessful side. What do we have to offer him? Compete without his material for a spot? Does he want to take Tommy's spot? From memory Saab is a right winger in any case, and while nof is replaceable he's doing well enough not to get dropped ahead of others at the moment.

The Dogs have 3m this year Foran was signed on 1m per season which is unbelievable but true. They stop paying Mbye this year also.
They lost CHN and Okunbur and they have Mariner, Elliot, Sue, Tolman all off contract.

They are going big game hunting we need to stay away from this as our last haul was Grub, Mbye, Packer, Matulino and McQueen.

The Dogs are gonna stuff it. They need spine players, but there aren't that many good ones going around. Like you said, it's us in 2018 all over again.

I'd go after Adam Elliot. Talented player, a bit under the radar. Mariner is a shot in the dark too. Don't know what market there will be for Sue.

I used to strongly dislike Adam Elliot because I thought he wasn't good enough. Turns out he just needed time to develop his game. He is genuinely good now. I agree that we should go after him.

 

[tony soprano]

Saab is terrible.

 

[tony soprano]

On Saab, looking like he will be at the dogs IF released but it is really up in the air. Major cash being thrown at a some players by them.

On another note, most Sydney clubs have been in discussions to resume playing informal (non-Canterbury Cup) reserve grade games against one another to keep players fit. Will need clearance from the NRL.

Why would the dogs have more cash than us? Unless they're offering 500k then we can match what they can.
They don't have much cash having already splurged on Thompson. And Dwz, hopoate already on big money and no halves. And who knows who their coach will be. A lot of risk.

On the other hand we're a perennially unsuccessful side. What do we have to offer him? Compete without his material for a spot? Does he want to take Tommy's spot? From memory Saab is a right winger in any case, and while nof is replaceable he's doing well enough not to get dropped ahead of others at the moment.

The Dogs have 3m this year Foran was signed on 1m per season which is unbelievable but true. They stop paying Mbye this year also.
They lost CHN and Okunbur and they have Mariner, Elliot, Sue, Tolman all off contract.

They are going big game hunting we need to stay away from this as our last haul was Grub, Mbye, Packer, Matulino and McQueen.

The Dogs are gonna stuff it. They need spine players, but there aren't that many good ones going around. Like you said, it's us in 2018 all over again.

I'd go after Adam Elliot. Talented player, a bit under the radar. Mariner is a shot in the dark too. Don't know what market there will be for Sue.

I used to strongly dislike Adam Elliot because I thought he wasn't good enough. Turns out he just needed time to develop his game. He is genuinely good now. I agree that we should go after him.

Elliot would be great.

 

[TYGA]

On Saab, looking like he will be at the dogs IF released but it is really up in the air. Major cash being thrown at a some players by them.

On another note, most Sydney clubs have been in discussions to resume playing informal (non-Canterbury Cup) reserve grade games against one another to keep players fit. Will need clearance from the NRL.

Why would the dogs have more cash than us? Unless they're offering 500k then we can match what they can.
They don't have much cash having already splurged on Thompson. And Dwz, hopoate already on big money and no halves. And who knows who their coach will be. A lot of risk.

On the other hand we're a perennially unsuccessful side. What do we have to offer him? Compete without his material for a spot? Does he want to take Tommy's spot? From memory Saab is a right winger in any case, and while nof is replaceable he's doing well enough not to get dropped ahead of others at the moment.

The Dogs have 3m this year Foran was signed on 1m per season which is unbelievable but true. They stop paying Mbye this year also.
They lost CHN and Okunbur and they have Mariner, Elliot, Sue, Tolman all off contract.

They are going big game hunting we need to stay away from this as our last haul was Grub, Mbye, Packer, Matulino and McQueen.

The Dogs are gonna stuff it. They need spine players, but there aren't that many good ones going around. Like you said, it's us in 2018 all over again.

I'd go after Adam Elliot. Talented player, a bit under the radar. Mariner is a shot in the dark too. Don't know what market there will be for Sue.

I used to strongly dislike Adam Elliot because I thought he wasn't good enough. Turns out he just needed time to develop his game. He is genuinely good now. I agree that we should go after him.

Elliot And Mariner are a big reason the Dogs can’t score points. It’s like Gallen and Greg Bird at Cronulla years ago. Strong player but the SlDogs won’t pay him there is a reason why.

 

[TYGA]

Saab is terrible.

Marika is good. Saab is a future prospect great athlete and tall but he will take another 18 months to grow into that long frame.