Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Needaname]

What do people think of Adam Elliott. Obviously he would need to stay off the drink or learn how to handle it but he wouldnt be Robinson Crusoe their

Adam Elliot is decent imo.
I know everyone hates him and his team sucks.
He could do a lot for us though.

Very Bellamy like signing and I hope we are the question.

Blore one side, Elliot the other. Luciano to the bench. Would be an improvement. He’s a massive idiot though.

No his just a massive tool, or at least part of him is.

 

[jadtiger]

A player who a lot on this forum have little time for Dylan Walker made a big difference for Manly when he came on against Storm would not be a bad pick up for WT'S especially with Douehi and Talau being out for the first few months of season 2022 and with Mbye gone would make a good bench player.Hope his learnt his lesson in regard to off field issues but surely his contract could be drawn up to cover

It would be impossible for me to want a bloke who allegedly beats up women at our club.I would hope we would have learned from the Lui experience

 

[Demps]

A player who a lot on this forum have little time for Dylan Walker made a big difference for Manly when he came on against Storm would not be a bad pick up for WT'S especially with Douehi and Talau being out for the first few months of season 2022 and with Mbye gone would make a good bench player.Hope his learnt his lesson in regard to off field issues but surely his contract could be drawn up to cover


It would be impossible for me to want a bloke who allegedly beats up women at our club.I would hope we would have learned from the Lui experience

Walker is a maniac.
No thanks.

Doubt it'd happen anyway.
I gotta feeling Madge doesn't like him.

 

[watersider]

Just fantasy stuff here:

Is Welch off contract anytime soon? If we signed Welch and Brandon Smith on really good money we'd be a good team. Those two would change our club and are exactly what we need. I'd be happy to get Grant instead of Smith, but I think Smith is definitely the better player this year.

 

[yeahcaz]

I would give Elliot a go under some conditions.
No Drinking as this clearly seem to be the start of any issues and 2 years with 2nd year CO. That way he can prove himself and we have a get out if it goes wrong. He is a very good player and only 26 years old.

No players that banged ex team mates wives. Lowest act you can do. I have zero issue with the toilet action.

Pfft there is way more to this story than you know. Painting lichaa as the victim is a joke ?

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

A player who a lot on this forum have little time for Dylan Walker made a big difference for Manly when he came on against Storm would not be a bad pick up for WT'S especially with Douehi and Talau being out for the first few months of season 2022 and with Mbye gone would make a good bench player.Hope his learnt his lesson in regard to off field issues but surely his contract could be drawn up to cover


It would be impossible for me to want a bloke who allegedly beats up women at our club.I would hope we would have learned from the Lui experience

Walker is a maniac.
No thanks.

Doubt it'd happen anyway.
I gotta feeling Madge doesn't like him.

let's hope Madge is not here then

 

[BZN]

No to Elliot ... may as well buy Duggan if we want to head down that path... surely we are learning something about character

Because he made out with a gorgeous women in a toilet or because he got naked at mad monday piss up ? He is almost a saint in nrl terms.

He also does a tremendous amount for charity.

Bit silly on the drink but then so am i

He didn't make out with her @boonboon
They only went into the men's toilet to kiss cause they were old friends...I read it in the paper so it must be true :smirk:

 

[BAGNF05]

Kikau at 900k? I don't know what the world is coming to. I would say he's better value than the likes of TPJ but I wouldn't go above 800k for Kikau, I think that his realistic pay ceiling.

Yeah no way you could give Kikau Mbye money 😂

 

[TIGERPOWER]

A player who a lot on this forum have little time for Dylan Walker made a big difference for Manly when he came on against Storm would not be a bad pick up for WT'S especially with Douehi and Talau being out for the first few months of season 2022 and with Mbye gone would make a good bench player.Hope his learnt his lesson in regard to off field issues but surely his contract could be drawn up to cover

I would definitely be looking at him. He looked great against the best team in the Comp.

 

[TIGERPOWER]

I would give Elliot a go under some conditions.
No Drinking as this clearly seem to be the start of any issues and 2 years with 2nd year CO. That way he can prove himself and we have a get out if it goes wrong. He is a very good player and only 26 years old.

No players that banged ex team mates wives. Lowest act you can do. I have zero issue with the toilet action.

True. Doesn’t say much about the girl though either right.

Why is a married lady hanging out in the back shed with her husbands best mate while her husband is asleep at 4am in the morning?

 

[balmain boy]

I would give Elliot a go under some conditions.
No Drinking as this clearly seem to be the start of any issues and 2 years with 2nd year CO. That way he can prove himself and we have a get out if it goes wrong. He is a very good player and only 26 years old.

No players that banged ex team mates wives. Lowest act you can do. I have zero issue with the toilet action.

Yeah this is his major flaw. But seriously I doubt he'd do it again. Surely he can't be that stupid.

He'd be a definite starter for us and a much better gamble than Leilua or Roberts

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Elliot is 27 and has just played 100 games.
If he was on low wage for squad depth sure.
If he was viewed as a starting forward no thanks.

He isn’t that great and comes from a losing culture. He is the signing we should be avoiding as an option for a starting spot.

Would take Simms over him anyday of the week

 

[tony soprano]

A player who a lot on this forum have little time for Dylan Walker made a big difference for Manly when he came on against Storm would not be a bad pick up for WT'S especially with Douehi and Talau being out for the first few months of season 2022 and with Mbye gone would make a good bench player.Hope his learnt his lesson in regard to off field issues but surely his contract could be drawn up to cover

I would definitely be looking at him. He looked great against the best team in the Comp.

Talk is he's re-signing Manly two years.

 

[tony soprano]

Elliot is 27 and has just played 100 games.
If he was on low wage for squad depth sure.
If he was viewed as a starting forward no thanks.

He isn’t that great and comes from a losing culture. He is the signing we should be avoiding as an option for a starting spot.

Would take Simms over him anyday of the week

Beggers can't be choosers

 

[Roar_Power]

Elliott and Sims both make our team a better one.

 

[Ultimate Warrior]

I would give Elliot a go under some conditions.
No Drinking as this clearly seem to be the start of any issues and 2 years with 2nd year CO. That way he can prove himself and we have a get out if it goes wrong. He is a very good player and only 26 years old.

No players that banged ex team mates wives. Lowest act you can do. I have zero issue with the toilet action.

True. Doesn’t say much about the girl though either right.

Why is a married lady hanging out in the back shed with her husbands best mate while her husband is asleep at 4am in the morning?

They were doing laundry together.

Who doesn’t at 4am??

 

[Furious1]

Elliot is a goose. He's been front and centre of anything controversial with the Bulldogs for years.

I'm not one of these people that thinks we shouldn't sign a player because their behaviour is beneath our lofty standards, but if we are going to sign a goose, lets at least make it somebody who will be worth the grief.

 

[Aceshigh]

Some team will snap up Elliott he may be a fool but is a good player would def add some steel to our pack

 

[Bula]

I would give Elliot a go under some conditions.
No Drinking as this clearly seem to be the start of any issues and 2 years with 2nd year CO. That way he can prove himself and we have a get out if it goes wrong. He is a very good player and only 26 years old.

No players that banged ex team mates wives. Lowest act you can do. I have zero issue with the toilet action.

True. Doesn’t say much about the girl though either right.

Why is a married lady hanging out in the back shed with her husbands best mate while her husband is asleep at 4am in the morning?

They were doing laundry together.

Who doesn’t at 4am??

He should done a load by hand and stayed out of strife.

 

[tony soprano]

Some team will snap up Elliott he may be a fool but is a good player would def add some steel to our pack

He's a dope dog's must be cheering free cap space. Should of stuck solid with his contract.