Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Shooter Mcgavin]

News story indicating that Viliame Kikau rejecting Panthers extension. Similar peak to TPJ to me, without the drama. Wonder if we will be enquiring?

For the money he wants I say No as i think he is lazy some of the times and we already have some of them. Last year he was this damaging forward and players hated to tackle him but this year he is back to the field. That's just my thoughts but for under 600k I would not be unhappy but unlikely as he wants like 800k or something. Dragons or Dogs will get him

Yeah my Penrith supporting family really wouldn’t be sad to see him go. Really clumsy player, quite poor hands and good for a brain fart. At his best pretty damaging though

 

[weststigerman]

Mikaele has signed on for 1 year

50-50 on this one, 1 year is enough at this stage IMO.

Needs to work on 2 things:

1. Stop switching off in defence
2. Either learn to pass or don’t pass. Every time he passes the ball I cringe.

 

[hsvjones]

News story indicating that Viliame Kikau rejecting Panthers extension. Similar peak to TPJ to me, without the drama. Wonder if we will be enquiring?

For the money he wants I say No as i think he is lazy some of the times and we already have some of them. Last year he was this damaging forward and players hated to tackle him but this year he is back to the field. That's just my thoughts but for under 600k I would not be unhappy but unlikely as he wants like 800k or something. Dragons or Dogs will get him

Yeah my Penrith supporting family really wouldn’t be sad to see him go. Really clumsy player, quite poor hands and good for a brain fart. At his best pretty damaging though

For me he is not a top line player you pay 800k etc for.. I think the Dragons will through and good luck to them.

 

[Roar_Power]

Kikau goes missing all the time. I would not spend big on that bloke. Flat track bully.

 

[Aceshigh]

Bulldogs can fit him in

 

[weststigerman]

Kikau is much more valuable than TPJ IMO. Just having him on the field opens opportunities for others.

 

[Guest]

Also Momirovski showing tonight his hands still as bad as Talau’s.

tbh i'd rather have momo than our current center options

I’d rather we got Laurie a year early than have another average centre on the books.

Another average centre?
Who's our first average centre?
We have a couple of diabolical centres and a centre that rarely plays and never touches the ball.
An average centre? We have none of those.

 

[weststigerman]

Also Momirovski showing tonight his hands still as bad as Talau’s.

tbh i'd rather have momo than our current center options

I’d rather we got Laurie a year early than have another average centre on the books.

Another average centre?
Who's our first average centre?
We have a couple of diabolical centres and a centre that rarely plays and never touches the ball.
An average centre? We have none of those.

Is the centre that rarely plays or touches the ball average or below average?

 

[GCfan]

Watching Lomax tonight makes me think he wants out of the Dragons.. Did not look really happy and team mates really didn't celebrate with him for this try assist. Fingers crossed there is something to this and we can snap him up

Thought the same.

Body language

But what does he say on the podcast?

 

[Eyeofthetiger 0]

Egan Butcher playing like he has signed for us

 

[cktiger]

Egan Butcher playing like he has signed for us

Manu the same… hiding the whole night letting Tedesco do everything.

 

[weststigerman]

Egan Butcher playing like he has signed for us

He won them the game by failing to play the ball.

 

[JC99]

Kikau been pretty average this year to be honest, teams have figured him out and he's not great defensively. Not worth big coin

 

[Moh]

Even we've been able to keep Kikau quiet in recent times. Not unless it's a good deal.

 

[rihannafan1]

Interested to know why both sides agreed on one year for Mikaele.

 

[momo_amp_medo]

Egan Butcher playing like he has signed for us

Will fit right in.

 

[BirchgroveTigers]

Interested to know why both sides agreed on one year for Mikaele.

yeah wierd hey. You'd think mikaele would want more security than that and youd think we'd offer at least 2 years...maybe 2nd brisbane team as someone mentioned...

Hopefully can get Seyfarth for 2/3 years. Feel his best footy is still to come - reckon he could put on 3-5kgs and be our starting 13 either 2022 or 2023.

 

[Demps]

Interested to know why both sides agreed on one year for Mikaele.

1 year is a bit weird eh?

 

[jadtiger]

Even we've been able to keep Kikau quiet in recent times. Not unless it's a good deal.

He will go to the dogs on massive overs and do very little but collect his money.He wont have the support he gets at the pamfers

 

[Demps]

Even we've been able to keep Kikau quiet in recent times. Not unless it's a good deal.


He will go to the dogs on massive overs and do very little but collect his money.He wont have the support he gets at the pamfers

Can't see Kikau going to the Dogs.
Is that what talks are or is it just jokes ?