Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[batboy]

Strong mail the Dogs nab him

Wonder what they’ll do
With avarillo? They’ve got some
Decisions to make with kids coming through there in the backs - made worse by buying more of them….

 

[Cobarcats]

Not even a decent 5/8 yet - now he’s a halfback 😂😂😂

He doesn't have any of the attributes of a halfback imo, to slow, cant tackle, too tall. A half really needs to be like a hooker in the mould of Souths and Panthers hookers... They play very similar roles.

 

[the_third]

Not even a decent 5/8 yet - now he’s a halfback 😂😂😂

@Kaito AD thinks he's all

he's more like

He's got a lot to prove, not a halfbacks bootlace - even brooks's

 

[cktiger]

What then would WT do for a halfback?

Actually have one 🤣

 

[Cobarcats]

What then would WT do for a halfback?

Brooks, if we lose him it's Hastings, if we lose him...can you play ½back Newy? 😂

 

[balmain boy]

I read at the start of the season, so cant remember the exact details. But, i think it was, he broke his leg pretty bad during contract negotiations when at the Tigers. It was expected to be a long recovery with no guarantee he would get back to his best. 3 months later his leg was healed, and he was playing Aus Rugby Schoolboys and got signed by Souths.

The fact we thought it was so bad yet it clearly wasn't suggests that once again our medical team just isn't up to scratch. They really don't seem to know what they're doing

 

[Kaito]

@Kaito AD thinks he's all

he's more like

He's got a lot to prove, not a halfbacks bootlace - even brooks's

Let's give it a chance bro 😃

 

[bigsiro]

Yeah, yeah. We've seen this movie before. 😒

Yup. Cross between Groundhog Day and The Shining

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I’m starting to suspect Sheens has been saying we are keeping Brooks to increase the price Newcastle pay for him and lessen the dead money we retain. There’s whispers Laurie will be “cover” in the halves next year. Staines was a fullback coming through and there’s rumours the swap with Penrith is on. I wonder if Sheens and Gould discussed this at their recent meeting? Gould has been open in saying he thinks Laurie’s best position is 5/8, and he would know a lot about Staines from his time at Penrith.

Tim Sheens holds the highest position in the footballing dept. at WTs and has made at least two public statements on Brooks. Why would he undermine his own authority by doing what you are suggestiing? Your post is based on rumour, whereas Sheens has made public statements.

 

[Calbremic]

I’m starting to suspect Sheens has been saying we are keeping Brooks to increase the price Newcastle pay for him and lessen the dead money we retain. There’s whispers Laurie will be “cover” in the halves next year. Staines was a fullback coming through and there’s rumours the swap with Penrith is on. I wonder if Sheens and Gould discussed this at their recent meeting? Gould has been open in saying he thinks Laurie’s best position is 5/8, and he would know a lot about Staines from his time at Penrith.

I agree.
Sheens may be old and has been out of the NRL for years but he knows how to play the game. He’s no idiot.

 

[Stevec]

Tim Sheens holds the highest position in the footballing dept. at WTs and has made at least two public statements on Brooks. Why would he undermine his own authority by doing what you are suggestiing? Your post is based on rumour, whereas Sheens has made public statements.

Yes Sheens has made it clear he wants Brooks but wants him to sign a new 3 year contract which is in effect a 2 year extension .Dont know the exact figure but he won't be the million dollar man . Brooks has 3 options accept the new deal , just play out his existing contract to end 2023 or accept new deal at Newcastle .Where we get someone our way as compensation .
Point is Brooks is in driver seat while he has this very high value remaining but a year from now he has no chips left to bargain with

 

[boonboon]

All everyone on here talks about is the spine when it the forwards that matter. Without them it doesn't matter who we keep the halves

 

[Cobarcats]

We need forwards as tough as this bloke!

 

[Long Term Fan]

A Brooks and Frizzell swap in my opinion is a win/win to both sides plus I really want to see Brooks in another environment to he can show the NRL Public what he has got or not.

I would be fine for the right money to give brothers and former WT players Andrew and David Fifita a one year deal and a second year in the clubs favour as they seem obtainable.

Would rather have Klemmer and Lodge but can't see both leaving their current clubs especially Lodge now he is in the hands of Uncle Nick.

I am sure there are some hidden gems in other teams State Cup Teams that have their NRL pathways block like Dean Hawkins (Souths Half Back who top the stats in 4 categories) and Kayal Iro (Centre/Winger who appears to top all the important stats. Son of Kevin Iro).

 

[Cobarcats]

We need forwards as tough as this bloke!

View attachment 2669

Forwards win matches, lets get a formidable pack before we look at also rans backs.
Unless we sign a marquee back, I don't want to hear it nor do I care.
If we sign someone like Tapine, Curran, Frizzlesticks, Adrian Morley, Gareth Ellis, Sam Burgess then wake me up!

 

[twentyforty]

All everyone on here talks about is the spine when it the forwards that matter. Without them it doesn't matter who we keep the halves

You’re right, not many halfbacks would get excited about playing behind a pack which gets rag dolled every week and gets up to ptb like it’s Sunday morning.

 

[Demps]

Shouldn't Daine be going into Australian training camp soon

More important stuff to do.

 

[batboy]

The fact we things it was so bad yet it clearly wasn't suggests that one again our medical team just isn't up to scratch. They really don't seem to know what they're doing

Was in junior footy wasn't it?
How much of a medical "team" would Matts have?

If I remember how it was, The club wasn't prepared to extend him long term while he was injured.
He took exception and went in a different direction.

Funny there's folk here that are bashing the club for the Ilias situation, Then Bashing the club for doing the opposite with Talau.

 

[batboy]

View attachment 2670


More important stuff to do.

That's Roberts Davis too isn't it?
Plenty of Magpies legends in there....

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

A Brooks and Frizzell swap in my opinion is a win/win to both sides plus I really want to see Brooks in another environment to he can show the NRL Public what he has got or not.

I would be fine for the right money to give brothers and former WT players Andrew and David Fifita a one year deal and a second year in the clubs favour as they seem obtainable.

Would rather have Klemmer and Lodge but can't see both leaving their current clubs especially Lodge now he is in the hands of Uncle Nick.

I am sure there are some hidden gems in other teams State Cup Teams that have their NRL pathways block like Dean Hawkins (Souths Half Back who top the stats in 4 categories) and Kayal Iro (Centre/Winger who appears to top all the important stats. Son of Kevin Iro).

I think kayak iro has re signed with sharks ?
If we lose Brooks Dean Hawkins would be a good buy he is better than Illias