Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Large bros and Galvin had one common factor- overbearing parents with excessive interference and demands on the club and coaching staff for their children. It got to the stage, no matter how accommodating the club was, it was never good enough. Hence they were allowed to go. Good riddance.

Galvin generally may have been a unique case , as I don’t believe he was ever going to stay here … but expect a lot of these kids and their parents to be overbearing …its part of the clubs brief to be able to handle them and get positive outcomes out of them…Im sure Richo has dealt with their ilk all his life
 
Do you think they're 'letting him walk'?

My understanding is that they want him to stay and he wants to stay, but he will not continue to wait long enough for the transition from Api.

I don't care what anyone says, someone willing to walk away from his childhood club, where he wants to stay and who want to keep him because he's being asked to play a smaller role a little longer, to the betterment of both his own experience and the club itself, only to then almost be guaranteed the starting role a year later in 2028 or otherwise.... is the wrong decision by Tallyn.

Like, almost laughably bad.

He'll be 22 at the start of the 2028 season. Twenty-two.

And, if he's good enough, he should be backing himself to win the hooking role of Api earlier.

It's just woeful, woeful stuff from the TDS camp in my opinion. It's non-sensical and really poor advice from Tartak if he's recommending a change.

There HAS to be more to it.

I've said it before and I'll say it again, I think there's every chance we sound out Manase following his sentence and that we see him on a T and T in 27 alongside his brothers. He's eligible for parole in October next year, will be only 28 years old for the 2027 season, hasn't had the wear and tear of week in week out first grade for the past 6 years and originally, was that good that he forced Api out of Manly.

Maybe Tallyn sees the writing on the wall competing with Manase, Haywood and Api, the same way that many are suspecting Galvin did with Latu. Maybe its a case of the HM crew from back in the day being a little too egoist for their own good.

Who knows.

Benji makes no secret how much he loves Api…. I’ve heard him say several times that he is the best player in the side …maybe TDS feels he won’t get a fair go … I mean that might not necessarily be the case but thats he way he feels? He knows better than us though , so I guess he will make the call that he believes is best for him

I also suspect money is an issue as well….if he goes and becomes the No 1 somewhere else , he is going to earn more money than being the No 2 here ..
 
I called this two months ago. He was spotted having a coffee with Gus. This was even before Galvin gate blew up. Obviously Gus has had this all planned for sometime.

Of course we will roll over once again and let him swan out the door with F all compensation. It is getting harder and harder to ride the Weststigers emotional roll a coaster
What is "compensation" - if it's money then ok ask for $$ but if you want a player then the Dogs just can't give us a player against his will. We live in a world of contracts - some are broken, some are held and someone the Dogs want to keep isn't going to come to the Tigers that's just fact.
 
Well,, if TDS does go to Dogs in 2026 (or earlier), wouldnt it make very suss The Dogs telling Mahoney to move on a few weeks ago before any of the TDS things became open? Why doesnt the NRL investigate such very odd / opportunistic events happening as trigger events in the next steps to happen?
If Galvin says my mates not happy there then it might be on the Dogs radar and as long as they don't offer him an incentive to leave before his contract expires it's all above board - that's the way it works. The Dogs can meet with him all they like - discuss planetary alignments , Woordle answers they just can't mention contracts.
 
Makes no sense to me, stupid thing is Richo should step in because if next year he taps Benji on the shoulder we lose a decent young player because Benji wanted Api instead. Move Api to 14 on the bench and give Tallyn the 9. Let Api cover for him till he gets up to speed then get Api as our utility for 2 years, can cover halves, hooker and could do a job in the backrow if we're desperate.
Why. Api is 5 times the player that TDS is, and will be for quite some time
 
These rumours about TDS can’t happen.

The CEO has repeatedly said we need to build from our junior base.

We have to keep him, it will be up there with some of the dumbest decisions this club has made…..and that’s saying something.

The potential this kid has, is great and we can’t ignore that.
 
These rumours about TDS can’t happen.

The CEO has repeatedly said we need to build from our junior base.

We have to keep him, it will be up there with some of the dumbest decisions this club has made…..and that’s saying something.

The potential this kid has, is great and we can’t ignore that.
How much do you pay to keep him
We have tabled a 3 year deal worth 550k a year..
I think that's more than fair
 
Back
Top