Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

my understanding re the brooks stuff at present is he wants 2028 as well.
Catch is a club may take 2027 subsidised by manly but 2028 would be full freight.
That might limit a few things

He may have to accept less money in 2028. Thats the year of a fresh new contract, and many players at the age of 33/34 take less money.
 
Wiedler/SMH:

It was a flashpoint on a night out that is the stuff of the NRL’s worst nightmares. A look into the price of fame of a big-time player.

When five internationals had to deal with a member of the public who pulled a knife on them – or, more specifically, on Tigers forward Terrell May.

Terrell May in action for Samoa against Tonga at the 2025 Pacific Championships.

Terrell May in action for Samoa against Tonga at the 2025 Pacific Championships.NRL Imagery

The incident has been kept quiet from the NRL and the Samoans. But it was the final straw for May, who left camp the next day.

He had other issues going on at home. He was worried about his little brother Taylan, who would have been in the squad but was ruled out with a hamstring injury. Taylan had been through his own troubles and Terrell didn’t feel right being away at that time.

But back to the night in question.

Jarome Luai, Terrell May, Izack Tago, Brian To’o, Blaize Talagi

Jarome Luai, Terrell May, Izack Tago, Brian To’o, Blaize TalagiNine

His target was May, who is fiercely proud of where he grew up. May, who can handle himself, reacted by grabbing a stool to go after the knife-wielding youngster. It was instinctual. Fear and shock turned into anger, and he had to be held back by his teammates.


As a witness to the incident explained to me, there was a chance the teenager with the knife was going to find himself in danger from May.

The NRL said they did not know about the incident when asked for comment on Saturday.

That moment was not the worst thing to happen to May as part of that camp, and it’s not why he isn’t in the Samoan World Cup squad.

May wouldn’t go into the reasons for his absence when we contacted him to ask about the knife incident.

But what we have been told is that he has an ambition to captain the Tigers. To lead from the front. He is unhappy with what he gave the Tigers this year and genuinely believes he needs a big off-season to set himself up for 2027.

He also believes that, on form, he didn’t deserve to be part of the Samoa squad this time. May wants to focus on being a better player for Tigers coach Benji Marshall next year.

Bitter end for Tigers’ Luai era​

The Wests Tigers are sick of Jarome Luai’s impact on their club and are hoping his no-show at the end-of-season awards night is the last time they need to deal with him.

Luai is braced for strategic leaks about his time at Concord, but it wasn’t the club that alerted the media to him not attending the presentation night – it was his own social media post.

Tigers assistant coach Brett Hodgson.

Tigers assistant coach Brett Hodgson.

Jarome Luai enjoys a drink on arrival at the Taumeasina Island Resort in Apia, Samoa.

Jarome Luai enjoys a drink on arrival at the Taumeasina Island Resort in Apia, Samoa.Instagram

But Luai gets singled out, so it’s only fair to highlight the fact he wasn’t the only one who failed to front. And as far as we know, Hodgson still has an important role next year.

Defence coach John Morris was not present after being shoved out the door a few days prior, and no one would expect him to front.

There is no question pressure is piling on Marshall.

Eighteen months on from the ugly exit of Lachlan Galvin, whose management told the Tigers they had no faith in Marshall’s coaching, the word coming out of the Tigers is “regret”. There is mild anger and embarrassment as well, but it will never be conveyed publicly.

Luai is laughing all the way to the bank – courtesy of a tax-free contract at the Papua New Guinea Chiefs from 2028 andthird-party deals that come with it – and he is also upset with the way he was treated in the end by the Tigers.

Bulldogs halfback and player of the year, Lachlan Galvin.

Bulldogs halfback and player of the year, Lachlan Galvin.Getty Images

The coach and his staff put their faith in Luai to establish a strong culture. Privately, Marshall believes that culture and the make-up of the playing group need to change.

The blow-up between Marshall and Adam Doueihi over a selection issue highlighted it.

Bust up: Benji Marshall and Adam Doueihi.

Bust up: Benji Marshall and Adam Doueihi.Getty/Monique Westermann

It’s why the club is now trying to recruit “solid citizens” – like the Raiders’ Jayden Brailey. They should have a look at a homecoming for Manly five-eighth Luke Brooks. He’d probably return the barbecue they gifted him when he departed the club at the end of 2023.

The way Galvin was isolated by some at the Tigers has never been addressed, but there are those within the organisation who will privately concede it was wrong.

It was so bad that Galvin didn’t even want to entertain a $6 million, five-year offer from the Tigers and left for a three-and-a-half-year term at the Bulldogs worth about $700,000 a season. Some within the Tigers are calling it a textbook case of an inexperienced coach listening to his playing group.

Marshall is stubborn, but he knows change is needed. He’s the Tigers’ greatest player and a legend of the game.

Fire up ... Luke Brooks received a new barbecue from the Tigers as a leaving gift in 2023 after 11 seasons with the club.

Fire up ... Luke Brooks received a new barbecue from the Tigers as a leaving gift in 2023 after 11 seasons with the club.

But the truth is out there and can’t be ignored.
My god this article is so hard to follow. It reads like a 15 year submitting a half arsed English assignment.

Im sure there is a coherent point in there somewhere. Is he is being deliberately vague?
 
Where did I say he was shit in that reply?

I just said he is not superstar material
Hes worth 900k-1 mil because thats what the offers were . The market dictates his value. At the moment that’s elite money. I refuse to participate in hive mind bullshit pile ons that go on on here. Especially when half the time it’s from the most armchair of armchair fans.
There’s a huge disconnect there . Ive brought it up before. Some of the nastiest shit said on here , I’d hazard a guess most of the really vile shit said , is from guys who were either too afraid to play , or mum didn’t let them . The dudes who would jump to the side , when you ran at them in lunchtime footy , are the ones calling nrl professionals dogs and soft , pea hearts… I wish I had a an ounce of bulas talent . Evert game the dude comes across and chucks his face right where giant wingers forearms are to stop tries , makes 7/10 cover tackles and people call him soft .
Anyways rant over . This is why I limit offseason participation on here . It’s just full of dog shit comments .
 
Just cos he kissed Ciraldo’s ring, doesn’t mean the Benji stuff isn’t justified. There isn’t enough of it. He’s protected by the media to a sickening degree.
It's not really about criticising the club, just his agenda's are so completely obvious. In this article, he's got information from luai's agent which is muddying Hodgson to take pressure off luai. Then it's another dig about Galvin courtesy of Moses. Finally it's a puff piece with absolutely no news value for ciraldo and the great work of Phil Gould courtesy of presumably Phil Gould. None of it is anything but agents agendas. Like what is interesting about the dogs item? Isn't every coach doing that sort of comment? It's just puff to support Gould's club.

He can call himself a journalist, but he's a spoon fed gossip columnist to agents connected to his paid work. He's simply a mouthpiece for channel 9 associated interests, has no individual thought or values at all.

The worst, scummiest sort of media person going round. His opinion is worth absolutely nothing.
 
It's not really about criticising the club, just his agenda's are so completely obvious. In this article, he's got information from luai's agent which is muddying Hodgson to take pressure off luai. Then it's another dig about Galvin courtesy of Moses. Finally it's a puff piece with absolutely no news value for ciraldo and the great work of Phil Gould courtesy of presumably Phil Gould. None of it is anything but agents agendas. Like what is interesting about the dogs item? Isn't every coach doing that sort of comment? It's just puff to support Gould's club.

He can call himself a journalist, but he's a spoon fed gossip columnist to agents connected to his paid work. He's simply a mouthpiece for channel 9 associated interests, has no individual thought or values at all.

The worst, scummiest sort of media person going round. His opinion is worth absolutely nothing.
At this point, I don’t know why anyone cares about who writes the article or what the agenda is. This club is a circus with a clown for a coach. They deserve to get called out.
 
It's not really about criticising the club, just his agenda's are so completely obvious. In this article, he's got information from luai's agent which is muddying Hodgson to take pressure off luai. Then it's another dig about Galvin courtesy of Moses. Finally it's a puff piece with absolutely no news value for ciraldo and the great work of Phil Gould courtesy of presumably Phil Gould. None of it is anything but agents agendas. Like what is interesting about the dogs item? Isn't every coach doing that sort of comment? It's just puff to support Gould's club.

He can call himself a journalist, but he's a spoon fed gossip columnist to agents connected to his paid work. He's simply a mouthpiece for channel 9 associated interests, has no individual thought or values at all.

The worst, scummiest sort of media person going round. His opinion is worth absolutely nothing.
How about a feel good piece about the game this arvo? Some background on a player people might not know?

That would actually require some work. Much easier to flog the deadest of horses and get fed lines by people more important than you.
 
At this point, I don’t know why anyone cares about who writes the article or what the agenda is. This club is a circus with a clown for a coach. They deserve to get called out.
Isn't time to let the negativity go for now, the season for us is over, with all your constant whining I'm beginning to wonder if you're suffering from purple haze syndrome.
 
Us , dogs , png inquired, st merge and the bears …. Pretty sure that’s 5
You’ve done well to invent that many ‘offers’ of a million dollars - pretty sure he was resigned under contract.

There were no offers, there may have been interest - but interest isn’t offers, and interest certainly isn’t offers of a million dollars - or 5 of them,

Try again.
 
How about a feel good piece about the game this arvo? Some background on a player people might not know?

That would actually require some work. Much easier to flog the deadest of horses and get fed lines by people more important than you.

Wouldn’t you rather prefer to read about stories that completely suit Issac Moses agenda?

I’m being sarcastic in case it’s not clear enough to some ,,,
 
Last edited:
Hes worth 900k-1 mil because thats what the offers were . The market dictates his value. At the moment that’s elite money. I refuse to participate in hive mind bullshit pile ons that go on on here. Especially when half the time it’s from the most armchair of armchair fans.
There’s a huge disconnect there . Ive brought it up before. Some of the nastiest shit said on here , I’d hazard a guess most of the really vile shit said , is from guys who were either too afraid to play , or mum didn’t let them . The dudes who would jump to the side , when you ran at them in lunchtime footy , are the ones calling nrl professionals dogs and soft , pea hearts… I wish I had a an ounce of bulas talent . Evert game the dude comes across and chucks his face right where giant wingers forearms are to stop tries , makes 7/10 cover tackles and people call him soft .
Anyways rant over . This is why I limit offseason participation on here . It’s just full of dog shit comments .
This place is a bit toxic atm isn’t it
 
Since I have been on this forum and it goes back a long time players have been signaled out for stuff you would call cyber bullying. Tim Moltzen was the first I could remember who copped it week in and week out. Fitzhenry was the next and Brooks the most recent.

These guys never dogged it and competed in the most physical competition I know. They did not pick themselves and they signed contracts the club offered them. Moltzen suffered a horrendous knee injury, Fitzy was a 100 times better winger than most people think. Brooks was the victim of coaches wanting to make him something he wasn’t.

I just wish people would take a second to think before pounding the keyboards. Not saying you can’t criticise but constant barrage and personal attacks is not on.

PS…I would be happy to have Brooks back but I think the roster spot needs to be used elsewhere
 
Back
Top