Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

wtf are you talking about . You’re just redirecting the conversation to win . It’s annoying . You stated there was no possible reason to go . I just gave you 2 . And now you want to play semantics.
I didn't say there is no possible reason to go. I asked what his motivation to go would be? You provided 2 potential answers.
1) he has been told he is behind others for a starting spot.
Except as far as we know he has not and every indication is this not the case. He was selected ahead of others all of last season and every indication that is the case again this year.
2) fragile ego because he was the bloke asked to leave
There is some merit to this. More so if he was the only bloke singled out. But as I said he wasn't, half the squad is reportedly for sale.

So of you're 2 answers one seems wrong and one possible but weak.
 
Weird we haven’t been linked to anyone for 2028 yet (besides the Cleary thing)
Well surely they are in negotiations with Latu Fainu (Mario Tartak) & Fonua Pole (Black Money) about extensions.

Then there is Tony Sukkar (Cove/Isaac Moses) pending for '27 or perhaps Sam Elliott (agent Michael Redpath) for a depth backrow spot.

Plus talks with Jamal Fogarty & Josh Addo-Carr for '27 & '28.

Think the club will see how all of the above pans out before dipping into others for '28. i.e. if Pole goes, then we should be in market for a 1st team ready middle.
 
Think Benji & leaders have realised that banking on youth immediately making the transition to NRL is high risk and rarely works out. Hence the strategic recruitment of experienced players who lead standards on the training track & playing field.

If our gun youth (Mak, Latu, Javon, Bryenton, Godinet, Haywood, CTM, Havea Jr etc) are to succeed, they need to be surrounded by more leaders & mentors, not just poor old Api & Twally all the time.
Rubbish. Do these senior players jog any memories?

Matt Ballin, Braith Anasta, Jamal Idris, Matt McIlwrick, James Tamou, James Roberts, Joe Ofahengaue, Ken Maumalo, Tyrone Peachey, Jackson Hastings, David Klemmer, John Bateman, Isaiah Papali’i, Aidan Sezer, Justin Olam, Jack Bird and my all-time favourite, Jarome Luai. All duds.

When we won the premiership in 2005, our average age was under 24. Our oldest player was our captain, Mark O’Neill, and he was 28.
 
Rubbish. Do these senior players jog any memories?

Matt Ballin, Braith Anasta, Jamal Idris, Matt McIlwrick, James Tamou, James Roberts, Joe Ofahengaue, Ken Maumalo, Tyrone Peachey, Jackson Hastings, David Klemmer, John Bateman, Isaiah Papali’i, Aidan Sezer, Justin Olam, Jack Bird and my all-time favourite, Jarome Luai. All duds.

When we won the premiership in 2005, our average age was under 24. Our oldest player was our captain, Mark O’Neill, and he was 28.
Yeah all duds for us.

All we can hope is that most of the ones incoming for '27 are to add value in the depth (except possibly Forgaty & JAC if they come) whereas many of the ones you listed we were hanging our hats on leading us to the promised land.
 
Rubbish. Do these senior players jog any memories?

Matt Ballin, Braith Anasta, Jamal Idris, Matt McIlwrick, James Tamou, James Roberts, Joe Ofahengaue, Ken Maumalo, Tyrone Peachey, Jackson Hastings, David Klemmer, John Bateman, Isaiah Papali’i, Aidan Sezer, Justin Olam, Jack Bird and my all-time favourite, Jarome Luai. All duds.

When we won the premiership in 2005, our average age was under 24. Our oldest player was our captain, Mark O’Neill, and he was 28.
You really think the older guys we’ve signed fall into the same mould as guys like Peachey, Roberts and Bateman?
 
Yes.
He was really good in 25 until that finals series came along. He relies a lot on his other halves partner to get the backline moving and Strange was on fire that year as well, although missing the second final with illness.
Fogarty and Brooks were both playing great footy during that 8 (or however many) game winning streak Manly had under Fozball this season. Brooks’ game improved a lot with Fogarty at the helm. Probably no coincidence that Strange was great in 2025 also. Maybe our young guys could benefit from playing alongside Fogarty as well? It’s worth a shot, imo. At the moment Doueihi is teaching them nothing.
 
Back
Top