Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

They are 20 and 21 respectively. They spent seven and eight years in the WT system, only to be discarded.

For WT to think that recruiting mercenaries at the end of their careers makes more sense is absolutely ludicrous.
If the mercenaries are better players and are replacing players that haven’t set the world on fire when given opportunities, then decisions have to be made. As I said, let’s see if they develop in WA, if not the right decision was made.
 
Don't reply to me. Problem solved.

That's good advice - people's opinions are just that, not a declaration of war or personal insult (unless meant that way)
 
You have convinced me.

My initial thought was similar. There is little between Madden and Fogarty in terms of playing style and playing ability. In a fairly miserable 2026 season one of the positives was the combination between Jock and Adam. I thought they played great together and we won 3 out of 4 with those two in the halves.
I get the sentiment on this line of thinking in that Madden is a similar style of player as Fogarty, but saying they're basically a like for like is a pretty big stretch. Since Fogarty debuted in 2020, he's made the finals as a starting halfback more times than he's missed them. Jock, by contrast, has never made the finals as a starting 7 and has never really even locked down a starting half role. And I like Jock, don't get me wrong. But Fogarty is much more of a proven commodity than Jock is and that's why we'd be bringing him on board if we do end up signing him. Also, in defence of Fogarty's age, like Cody Walker, the guy debuted in his late 20s so he doesn't quite have the mileage that a 33-year-old who debuted at 19 or 20 would have. I'm all for the signing.
 
If the mercenaries are better players and are replacing players that haven’t set the world on fire when given opportunities, then decisions have to be made. As I said, let’s see if they develop in WA, if not the right decision was made.
What? They are juniors that spent multiple years in our system.

Could the problem possibly be our system?
 
I get the sentiment on this line of thinking in that Madden is a similar style of player as Fogarty, but saying they're basically a like for like is a pretty big stretch. Since Fogarty debuted in 2020, he's made the finals as a starting halfback more times than he's missed them. Jock, by contrast, has never made the finals as a starting 7 and has never really even locked down a starting half role. And I like Jock, don't get me wrong. But Fogarty is much more of a proven commodity than Jock is and that's why we'd be bringing him on board if we do end up signing him. Also, in defence of Fogarty's age, like Cody Walker, the guy debuted in his late 20s so he doesn't quite have the mileage that a 33-year-old who debuted at 19 or 20 would have. I'm all for the signing.
Fogarty for 2years at half freight or less is the only way
 
They are 20 and 21 respectively. They spent seven and eight years in the WT system, only to be discarded.

For WT to think that recruiting mercenaries at the end of their careers makes more sense is absolutely ludicrous.
Think Benji & leaders have realised that banking on youth immediately making the transition to NRL is high risk and rarely works out. Hence the strategic recruitment of experienced players who lead standards on the training track & playing field.

If our gun youth (Mak, Latu, Javon, Bryenton, Godinet, Haywood, CTM, Havea Jr etc) are to succeed, they need to be surrounded by more leaders & mentors, not just poor old Api & Twally all the time.
 
Think Benji & leaders have realised that banking on youth immediately making the transition to NRL is high risk and rarely works out. Hence the strategic recruitment of experienced players who lead standards on the training track & playing field.

If our gun youth (Mak, Latu, Javon, Bryenton, Godinet, Haywood, CTM, Havea Jr etc) are to succeed, they need to be surrounded by more leaders & mentors, not just poor old Api & Twally all the time.
We need to get the blend right, think we are approaching it now but after Fogerty, we have enough approaching the mid 30's.
 
This is the hard part that comes with signing older players who are temporarily blocking the paths of promising younger players.
In our current position, it’s damned if we do, damned if we don’t.
If we go into the 2027 season season with the halves currently on our books and they do not perform up to expectation, how many people will say I told you so?
Ideally we could sign Fogarty on a subsidised contract of hopefully around 500k to us, but realistically we will probably have to pay closer to 600k to secure him for 2 seasons at age 33 and 34.
If it happens, surely the deal is that he would have to be performing somewhere near his best on a regular basis and if he’s not, be prepared to play NSW Cup, or if his form dips dramatically during g the 2027 seasons, hopefully be prepared to head to the UK Super League for 2028 and beyond.
On the other hand, if he’s doing for us what he did in his final year at the Raiders, it’s a success.
Hate to say it but when ‘Batman’ arrived we had a halves pairing of Lachie Galvin who was on his way to being a gun and Luai (a 4 time premiership winner), I thought there’s half the spine locked in and the only way is up. Wow didn’t that turn to s$&t within the first few months. We might as well give something a try, surely something will stick soon 🤞🙏
 
Name players who have put their foot down? I can only think of one. A certain ex captain of our club.
Greg Eastwood did it best at the Bulldogs. Was signed for a hugely back ended deal. They tried to get rid of him in his final year and he refused. Played reserve grade all year on $850k (and that was years ago). Good on him.
 
Back
Top