Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Not sure how you came to that conclusion, sine AD has played 7 seasons with us and Latu has played 3 with significant time in cup.

AD has missed significantly more game time through injuries across his career than Latu Fainu, largely due to multiple major knee reconstructions and late-season surgeries. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
Injury Comparison
PlayerNRL DebutCareer NRL Games (Tigers/Club)Major & Notable Injuries
Adam Doueihi2018 (South Sydney)129 appearances (through 2026)Three ACL knee tears/reconstructions (including a ~12-month layoff in 2023), multiple facial fractures (2025), and a shoulder dislocation/reconstruction (2026).
Latu Fainu2024 (Wests Tigers)36 appearances (2024–2026)Recurring hamstring issues early in his career, concussion/HIA stand-downs, a shoulder reconstruction after the 2025 season (affecting early 2026), and a minor hamstring/pec setback in late 2026.
I know what you're saying, and im not here to stick up for Doueihi, but the frustrating thing is the type of injuries that Latu seems to experience. Muscle injuries, head knocks etc one after another.

Most of Doueihi's absence is explained by two major but relatively common injuries
 
Rubbish. Do these senior players jog any memories?

Matt Ballin, Braith Anasta, Jamal Idris, Matt McIlwrick, James Tamou, James Roberts, Joe Ofahengaue, Ken Maumalo, Tyrone Peachey, Jackson Hastings, David Klemmer, John Bateman, Isaiah Papali’i, Aidan Sezer, Justin Olam, Jack Bird and my all-time favourite, Jarome Luai. All duds.

When we won the premiership in 2005, our average age was under 24. Our oldest player was our captain, Mark O’Neill, and he was 28.
Thank you finally someone who has taken notes.
 
I know what you're saying, and im not here to stick up for Doueihi, but the frustrating thing is the type of injuries that Latu seems to experience. Muscle injuries, head knocks etc one after another.

Most of Doueihi's absence is explained by two major but relatively common injuries
Missed game is a missed game, the type of injuries sustained has no consequence to it.

They are all still missed games no matter the type of injury or what caused it.

It's kind of like saying I'd rather be die buy fatal car crash than by a fatal gun shot... In the end it don't matter because they both result in you being dead ....
 
Not sure how you came to that conclusion, sine AD has played 7 seasons with us and Latu has played 3 with significant time in cup.

AD has missed significantly more game time through injuries across his career than Latu Fainu, largely due to multiple major knee reconstructions and late-season surgeries. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
Injury Comparison

PlayerNRL DebutCareer NRL Games (Tigers/Club)Major & Notable Injuries
Adam Doueihi2018 (South Sydney)129 appearances (through 2026)Three ACL knee tears/reconstructions (including a ~12-month layoff in 2023), multiple facial fractures (2025), and a shoulder dislocation/reconstruction (2026).
Latu Fainu2024 (Wests Tigers)36 appearances (2024–2026)Recurring hamstring issues early in his career, concussion/HIA stand-downs, a shoulder reconstruction after the 2025 season (affecting early 2026), and a minor hamstring/pec setback in late 2026.
My numbers were over the same period mate, so from when latu signed so it was comparative..
 
Fogarty is a must. Our other guys aren’t ready. As for the comparisons with Madden, Maddens kicking game is shit house. He’s a good back up. Fogarty has also played finals. Perfect player to get us around the field.

Latu is too injury prone and Andrew needs time. If we don’t sign him, everyone will be complaining we need a game managing half. This is it.

Who is your six?
 
My numbers were over the same period mate, so from when latu signed so it was comparative..
Your math ain't mathing.... You have only taken into consideration ADs last 3 years.

AD has been in grade for nine years.

The proper comparison ist to take games missed away from available games for each player and get the percentage for each player.

Latu comes out Infront by some distance .....
 
Your math ain't mathing.... You have only taken into consideration ADs last 3 years.

AD has been in grade for nine years.

The proper comparison ist to take games missed away from available games for each player and get the percentage for each player.

Latu comes out Infront by some distance .....
The numbers are over the same period that BOTH were playing for the tigers. So from 2024-2026.

Douhei has played 6 more games during that period, but double the minutes.

Thats why people aren't complaining about Douhei, because he was on the field for a far greater period of time.
 
We could have at least had a go at some prospect rather than wasting it on some retirees
Yeah I get it, but if the strategy was to provide a shit load of depth landing a big fish would have spread it thin.

Let's face it at full strength last season the side looked pretty good early, we have a lot of depth to hopefully cover a horror injury toll, just not the 2nd row please.
 
Rubbish. Do these senior players jog any memories?

Matt Ballin, Braith Anasta, Jamal Idris, Matt McIlwrick, James Tamou, James Roberts, Joe Ofahengaue, Ken Maumalo, Tyrone Peachey, Jackson Hastings, David Klemmer, John Bateman, Isaiah Papali’i, Aidan Sezer, Justin Olam, Jack Bird and my all-time favourite, Jarome Luai. All duds.

When we won the premiership in 2005, our average age was under 24. Our oldest player was our captain, Mark O’Neill, and he was 28.
Jo Ofenhengaue did nothing wrong , wish he never left .....he'd be good in our current 17
 
Rubbish. Do these senior players jog any memories?

Matt Ballin, Braith Anasta, Jamal Idris, Matt McIlwrick, James Tamou, James Roberts, Joe Ofahengaue, Ken Maumalo, Tyrone Peachey, Jackson Hastings, David Klemmer, John Bateman, Isaiah Papali’i, Aidan Sezer, Justin Olam, Jack Bird and my all-time favourite, Jarome Luai. All duds.

When we won the premiership in 2005, our average age was under 24. Our oldest player was our captain, Mark O’Neill, and he was 28.
You forgot another Uber Dud Adam Blair!!

I'm sure there are others, Russel Packer, Moses Mbye for example.
 
Rubbish. Do these senior players jog any memories?

Matt Ballin, Braith Anasta, Jamal Idris, Matt McIlwrick, James Tamou, James Roberts, Joe Ofahengaue, Ken Maumalo, Tyrone Peachey, Jackson Hastings, David Klemmer, John Bateman, Isaiah Papali’i, Aidan Sezer, Justin Olam, Jack Bird and my all-time favourite, Jarome Luai. All duds.

When we won the premiership in 2005, our average age was under 24. Our oldest player was our captain, Mark O’Neill, and he was 28.
Please take more than 3 seconds to check the accuracy of your AI overview before you post.

O’Neill was born on the 19th of June 1975, making him 30 on the grand final date. Several other squad members were 29 at the GF including Skandalis.
 
We need to get this Fogerty deal done ASAP and let AD know its 13 or bench or look elsewhere.
Hopefully Latu is healthy and can play in the 6 and develop a nice combo with Fogerty.
IMO I think the club has done a pretty good job this off season adding these vets who just play hard and train hard. Something we clearly lacked last year when players went down.
 
You forgot another Uber Dud Adam Blair!!

I'm sure there are others, Russel Packer, Moses Mbye for example.
poor Linda Blair ,Bellamy gave 1 simple instruction 2 him ,ball under arm and run straight ,also worked well with the Kiwi Team.
But Sheens gave her a brain ,not only did her head spin but constantly tripped over its own feet or team player , and we lost Fifita and Heinington to accommodate
 
Back
Top