Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Thats a heavy statement, I'd say he does have some idea.

He has had a baptism of fire with various unusual situations to deal with, and he has less resources than every other club, so considering his circumstances, I'd say he's learnt a fair bit and has some idea.

And the other thing about Benji compared to other coaches is that I think he genuinely wants the club to succeed and wears his heart on his sleeve.

And its fair to say the players do hold him in high regard.
Theyre the only ones who do..he treats them like royalty
 
look I still don’t like the loaning idea. as others have said you take him out of the system for 12 months and you risk teams playing him while injured.

but that doesn’t mean I can’t see the thinking.
I agree . I’m not for it either . I don’t understand how he can be behind AD . With what AD has dished up since may , both on and off the field , I don’t understand it. But I have tot take my own prejudiced hat off and acknowledge that it’s not the worst idea if everyone is on board . Including his loan club giving him real game time . Otherwise what’s the point ?
I know in EPL loans there’s clauses about game time .
 
Yes but why won't he succeed?

Is it because he's "............a coach who has no idea what he’s doing"


Sometimes black and white statements don't help, imagine if a journo came out and said this?
Who has improved as a player in Benjis time here as coach? (Twal i would say) Why does Latu still have a shit tackling technique after 3 years? Why does Bula not lurk around the middle of the field every set of six looking to pick up offloads off the forwards and create links between the backs? Why was Latu used so much last year for 10 minutes, or even no minutes instead of getting game time in cup?
Why when a player refused to take the field did he fold like a cheap suit a week later and put him back in?
I could keep going, but I kind of feel it would be easier for people to list all the good things Benji has done. I know it doesn't seem like it from this reply, but I wanted and still want Benji to succeed as much as anyone else, but if you are honest, nothing is really pointing to that occurring. Too much on the plate? Perhaps. Benji needed Richo, someone who doesn't take any crap, because the Lord knows HBG would be the last people you would want backing you up if you were going to war and at the end of the day they will still be there and he won't.
 
Who has improved as a player in Benjis time here as coach? (Twal i would say) Why does Latu still have a shit tackling technique after 3 years? Why does Bula not lurk around the middle of the field every set of six looking to pick up offloads off the forwards and create links between the backs? Why was Latu used so much last year for 10 minutes, or even no minutes instead of getting game time in cup?
Why when a player refused to take the field did he fold like a cheap suit a week later and put him back in?
I could keep going, but I kind of feel it would be easier for people to list all the good things Benji has done. I know it doesn't seem like it from this reply, but I wanted and still want Benji to succeed as much as anyone else, but if you are honest, nothing is really pointing to that occurring. Too much on the plate? Perhaps. Benji needed Richo, someone who doesn't take any crap, because the Lord knows HBG would be the last people you would want backing you up if you were going to war and at the end of the day they will still be there and he won't.
It would seem to me most of the good things he’s done are “off field” whilst his “on field “ achievements are not that major.
Things like, we’re a family club, everybody go home to collect their children after school are nice but not really all of what we beed. Sure, morale needs to be high but that should come from the pursuit of a common goal and continuous improvement.
Now I say this in a non racial way but those feel good things are very slanted toward our Polynesian players where family values are so important.We see the emotion, at jersey presentations, games etc
And I agree they are but there has to be a hard edge to make players and other coaches accountable if the identified goals are not being met.
My many years of corporate life tell me that the strategy is to win the comp whilst the family values, along with a hundred other things are the tactics to get us there.
Mr Luai told us all how good Benji was, how he understood, people , family values etc. but we didn’t move forward and were royally shafted for the holy dollar.
Gotta toughen up Benji and let a few of these princesses know to shape up, win games or ship out.
And yes, I’m proudly old school , with a family that I love.
 
Been away for a month. For some reason I couldn't access the site in Japan.

Can anyone give me an abbreviated update pls?
possible in's JAC ,Fogarty
possible out's Royce - of to SL Latu -loaned out for next year
And 2 hbg stooges stood down
Cheers. Had a lot to do yesterday - didn't get back here.
 

Latest posts

Staff online

Back
Top