Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Joel Helmes]

Big fan of Lowe

 

[Guest]

Ethan Lowe insights for 2019.

Here he is. Hear Anything else mate??

The Mbye talk/deal is real & would be a good coup. Only 24, has a lot in front of him. Cleary will get the best from him.

Likelihood?

 

[swag_tiger]

Here he is. Hear Anything else mate??

The Mbye talk/deal is real & would be a good coup. Only 24, has a lot in front of him. Cleary will get the best from him.

Heard anything of the Brian Kelly talk?

All but done.

As in done deal or talks have broken up and who are you talking about??

 

[Guest]

The Mbye talk/deal is real & would be a good coup. Only 24, has a lot in front of him. Cleary will get the best from him.

Heard anything of the Brian Kelly talk?

All but done.

As in done deal or talks have broken up and who are you talking about??

Kelly is on the bus next year basically.

 

[Nucky_Thompson]

Heard anything of the Brian Kelly talk?

All but done.

As in done deal or talks have broken up and who are you talking about??

Kelly is on the bus next year basically.

Nice we are just missing nathan.

 

[goldcoast_tiger]

I’m not going against the idea no one expected him to get picked round 1, the problem was we lacked pace and attacking threat especially with Rankin and everyone on this forum could see the potential JAC had and it took them 7 weeks to give him a go which isn’t necessarily bad.

But when he gets selected and also proves he can do it a hell of a lot better than Rankin in round 7 and looking much better in attack, what does our coach do….. he gets him dropped and doesn’t come back until a month later and so on

I’m sorry but no one can justify the way JT selected the side between Rankin and JAC

100% correct Teddy.

Good luck though, some people just wont ever see it that way.

People forget that Rankin was 1st choice kicker at the time

We let Fifita go , every club has horror stories

Look at the Broncos , they let Hunt go ,Arrow go , Wallace go etc and they have the master coach …..

So is there any rumour of Addo Carr coming back or is this just irrelevant squabble?

Its no rumour!
He's coming back before the June deadline , and not only that, Bellamy is coming with him.
Its not Cammie that he cant bear to live without, its JAC. :laughing:

 

[swag_tiger]

Is Pom saying that Mbye is a done deal as well because it looks like that to me as he said will as in he is going to come and not may come. But i may be wrong.

 

[Nucky_Thompson]

Is Pom saying that Mbye is a done deal as well because it looks like that to me as he said will as in he is going to come and not may come. But i may be wrong.

The offer is real up uto mbye and dogs to take it.

 

[Geo]

I've heard people talk up Su'a before and to me he seems solid without being a game breaker - but i've only seen him once or twice.. Who would people compare him to?

Imo he's an Ava type player.

I don't think I've ever seen Seumanufagai do what Su'a just did..

 

[happy_tiger]

Big fan of Lowe

He has had his share of HIA issues this season

Definitely not the player of the last 2 seasons

 

[Nelson]

Here he is. Hear Anything else mate??

The Mbye talk/deal is real & would be a good coup. Only 24, has a lot in front of him. Cleary will get the best from him.

Heard anything of the Brian Kelly talk?

All but done.

Thanks for the update, good to hear.

 

[Spud_Murphy]

Ethan Lowe insights for 2019.

Cool

I don't mind Lowe, but he's pretty much more of what we already have in the forwards, though he can kick goals very well. I would rather we target some sort of impact backrower instead.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Ethan Lowe insights for 2019.

Cool

I don't mind Lowe, but he's pretty much more of what we already have in the forwards, though he can kick goals very well. I would rather we target some sort of impact backrower instead.

Yeah I tend to agree with you. With the exception of his goal kicking i’m not sure what else he adds to what we already have.

And with Kelly if he’s signed to play centre I assume Marsters to back row? But then why look at Lowe as well?

 

[king_sirro]

Ethan Lowe insights for 2019.

Cool

I don't mind Lowe, but he's pretty much more of what we already have in the forwards, though he can kick goals very well. I would rather we target some sort of impact backrower instead.

Yeah I tend to agree with you. With the exception of his goal kicking i’m not sure what else he adds to what we already have.

And with Kelly if he’s signed to play centre I assume Marsters to back row? But then why look at Lowe as well?

Kelly is left centre. Won't effect Marsters.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Cool

I don't mind Lowe, but he's pretty much more of what we already have in the forwards, though he can kick goals very well. I would rather we target some sort of impact backrower instead.

Yeah I tend to agree with you. With the exception of his goal kicking i’m not sure what else he adds to what we already have.

And with Kelly if he’s signed to play centre I assume Marsters to back row? But then why look at Lowe as well?

Kelly is left centre. Won't effect Marsters.

Ah ok cool, that explains it then.

 

[Tweed_Tiger]

Lodge just said in his motm interview Western Sydney is gods country, he has been really good for the Broncos this year.

Only signed for this year and could be tempted back to Sydney…

 

[newtiger]

Ethan Lowe insights for 2019.

Has been bog average this year. Why do we sign players that are past their peak & not wanted by his current club.

Correct he has gone off the boil big time this year, now starting from the bench.
Whether he has the sookie la la’s because Hess is getting a start in front of him, but he is nowhere the player he was last year.

 

[Nelson]

Lodge just said in his motm interview Western Sydney is gods country, he has been really good for the Broncos this year.

Only signed for this year and could be tempted back to Sydney…

No, he's dirt. Plus Penrith are after him and the Broncos want to keep him = $$$

 

[TYGA]

Ethan Lowe insights for 2019.

Good I’ve been campaigning for him on here since last year. Makes too much sense plays 80, no mistakes, good defender and kicks goals at a good clip.

 

[Tweed_Tiger]

Lodge just said in his motm interview Western Sydney is gods country, he has been really good for the Broncos this year.

Only signed for this year and could be tempted back to Sydney…

No, he's dirt. Plus Penrith are after him and the Broncos want to keep him = $$$

Surprised Penrith think they need him, they seem stacked up front.