Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

@swag_tiger said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1021798) said:
@avocadoontoast Gagai left NewCastle to play under Madge so you never know.

Man I'd love it if we brought Gagai to the club.

It seems we're looking for a fullback, centre and a forward or two. Gagai isn't on massive coin either. Didn't he get cut by Bennett?
 
@swag_tiger said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1021798) said:
@avocadoontoast Gagai left NewCastle to play under Madge so you never know.


There’s more chance of you flying to the moon than Gagai coming here.
 
@jirskyr said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1021781) said:
@Nelson said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1021777) said:
@jirskyr said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1021764) said:
@Bones said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1021747) said:
@The_Patriot said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1021730) said:
Dane Gagai wants out of Souths. Not happy Jimmy The Jet got his spot.

Thoughts


Go hard. This is the sort of player we need. No more out of form down on their luck kind of blokes. Either sign top shelf players or promote the young blokes.

It only takes 2-3 top class players to turn a team around. Gagai is top class.

Would love to sign a bloke who is an Origin champion but club nufty. Legitimately he has done nothing for Souths his entire contract.

He did the same at Newcastle.

In fairness I thought he had a few good years at Newcastle, maybe 3/6 seasons. At Souths he has been so poor; a really disappointing signing for them.

Also he hasn't scored more than 4 tries in a season since 2015. To put that into perspective: he's scored 11 tries in 11 Origin games (1.00) but only 38 tries in 170 club appearances (0.22).

Surprising stats...could it have a bit to do with being a winger for QLD and centre/fullback in clubland?

I always thought he went alright, but never watched him that closely.
 
If we get the Gagai that plays Origin yes..the Club level Gagai not so much..Unca nailed it...
 
I know this is probably as a pessimistic as it gets , but I would love the next players poll to ask the question " which club would you be least likely to join "

Interesting to see what the response was
 
@The_Patriot said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1021782) said:
@jirskyr said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1021764) said:
@Bones said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1021747) said:
@The_Patriot said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1021730) said:
Dane Gagai wants out of Souths. Not happy Jimmy The Jet got his spot.

Thoughts


Go hard. This is the sort of player we need. No more out of form down on their luck kind of blokes. Either sign top shelf players or promote the young blokes.

It only takes 2-3 top class players to turn a team around. Gagai is top class.

Would love to sign a bloke who is an Origin champion but club nufty. Legitimately he has done nothing for Souths his entire contract.



No sorry thats exactly who i want at this club. The guy who knows how to play well when the pressure is on.

It is sadly sadly lacking at this club.

I agree with you but I don't think that is what Gagai is. Gagai knows how to play when he is surrounded by superstars who do most of the heavy lifting. He's super-effective in putting finishing touches on the ground work other people do.

In fairness to someone like Darius Boyd, who also scored a lot of tries on the end of a hot backline, Boyd actually took control of club matches and was highly successful / influential in club matches, at 3 different clubs.
 
I hope the club is strong enough to make the hard decisions when it comes to moving players on. I am referring to those who transit between cc and NRL or promise everything but don't deliver
 
@yeti said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1022129) said:
@pawsandclaws1 it looks like that is underway. Not so easy when some are tied up for another year or two.

He Yeti, my reference is to the Nofoaluma's, Josh A's and co. I remember last year Josh A playing an outstanding game against the Cowboys. He was toasted high and low but I remember writing he needs to deliver consistency of performance. For his future, a move under Belllamy may find the remaining 4 cylinders.
 
@pawsandclaws1 said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1022145) said:
@yeti said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1022129) said:
@pawsandclaws1 it looks like that is underway. Not so easy when some are tied up for another year or two.

He Yeti, my reference is to the Nofoaluma's, Josh A's and co. I remember last year Josh A playing an outstanding game against the Cowboys. He was toasted high and low but I remember writing he needs to deliver consistency of performance. For his future, a move under Belllamy may find the remaining 4 cylinders.

Would prefer he find his next year here.
 
I'm gonna throw it out there but hear me out..... I think we should target both Tom and Jake Trbojevic - now I know it's obvious of the talent of the pair but I'm gonna explain to you how this wouldn't be fantasy but an actual possibility!

Now if we were to successfully cut some of Packer, Mbye, Reynolds, Taylor and Mcqueen from our roster we would have a pretty significant war chest to attack the market for marquee signings - along with picking and choosing who to re-sign etc which would only free up more space

Not many clubs out there have the salary cap to attract both Tom and Jake as they would command quite significant money and I believe they want to play with each other - while also most teams have fullbacks and locks on there roster and don't necessarily need them

Brisbane - Issako and Pangai
Raiders - Chance and Tapine
Cronulla - Moylan/Dugan and Gallen (retiring)
Titans - Brimson and Arrow
Warriors - RTS and Adam Blair
Cowboys - Morgan and Tamololou
Knights - Ponga and Glasby
Storm - Hughes/Papenhyzen and Finucane
Rabbits - Johnston and Burgess
Penrith - Edwards and Martin (however zero cap space)
Parra - Gutho and Brown
Dragons - Dufty and Frizzell
Roosters - Tedesco/Latrell and Lui
Dogs - Meaney and Elliot

Out of all those teams potentially only the Bulldogs have an ideal chance of signing them and will have cap space if they operate there cap well enough as most players are off contract within the next 2 years

Parra also have a chance however, they're just resigned Gutho on a pretty lenghty deal to play fullback plus probs won't have the cap space if they do re-sign Moses on good coin

And then there's us after looking at all the teams fullback/lock combo - I think it's fair to say ours might not match up well. This week it's Thompson/Huth which tbh is quite depressing if you ask me.

We will have the cap space if we do end up clearing the roster which is predicted to happen, it's hard to sell the Wests Tigers but when the rivals are Manly I think we have something in our favor as they're screwed for the future and in a mess with terrible cap managment and very poor mangement with facilties as worse as ours - if this centre of excellence does happen along with being coached by a former premiership-winning coach with some good young players around we could be attractive for the pair

Players such as Brooks, Masters, Twal, Mats, Matterson, Liddle, Mikaele, Alioai and Nofo would all benefit significantly just with the presence of Tom and Jake - especially Brooks

Offer Tom 1-1.1 mil and Jake 850-900k a year as both would add to 2 million a year - if we think about it Reynolds, Packer and Mbye together are on about around 2.3 million

I think it's time to be aggressive in the market - if a team like Newcastle who was in the state they were in can sign Ponga, Pearce and Klemmer - I'm sure we can bloody do it too, enough with the low expectations of being content with mediocre signings and I think Madge has come to that realization hence the reported clean out!
 
Forget Drinkwater, he has joined the cows:

https://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nrl-premiership/teams/cowboys/cowboys-snap-up-storm-fullback-scott-drinkwater-who-was-earmarked-to-replace-slater/news-story/99ff45a0fe3a25f7d674dccc58f9a6b0
 
Titans have signed Tanah Boyd from the Broncos who had huge wraps on him. We might be able to trade Russell Packer for Ash Taylor
 
I think we need a releases thread as without these there are no signings. This thread is pointless until players leave and or it’s 2021.
 
Back
Top