Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[2005magic]

@Lukic - agree. I think mixing Mitchell with Maguire's no nonsense coaching and fitness regime would be a recipe for probable disaster. He might respond positively and go to the next level but I really, really doubt it. AND WT would have another Packer / Reynolds high value player, little to show for it situation after just resolving the previous ones.

We need to make sure we pick the right players to suit Maguire's methods and style, not just talent. Thats why I also think Moylan would be a disaster too but maybe not Milford.

 

[Snake]

@matchball every Tigers Centre will end up in the second row ... pity there’s not 5 second rowers Allowed in the pack !

 

[Snake]

@2005magic Mitchell is trouble stay right away has Mundine advising that’s enough to run a mile!

 

[Spacecub]

@Spacecub that was me who posted it champion - last Monday to be precise .
I was just sharing what a sponsor of two of our higher profile players shared with me. Not talking out of my rear as you have suggested .
In that same post I mentioned ;
- Matterson situation needed to be sorted by 31/10.
Outcome : He we was given a formal release by the end of that same week
- Matalino likely to be medically retired.
Outcome : was formally approved by NRL at the end of the same week too. You may recall many of us fans thought we would not get that outcome given concerns about a possible pre-existing injury

I am sorry the dominos have not quite fallen regarding the WTF signing . Last week we were linked to several players for the first time (Milford , JWH) . My client is very close to two board members . The board members lips are sealed until the deal is done , which I don’t think is a bad thing. Until then people are going to speculate.

Time will tell about my other two points re Packer proving a point in 2020 and a former sponsor returning

Hey wounded tiger, I wasnt having a go at you personally....its just there's so much rubbish being thrown around atm you don't know what's fair dinkum and what's not.....hope you weren't offended if you were I apologize......unfortunately we all cop it on here from time to time, I cop it because I'm good friends with josh Reynolds mum, she tells me a bit that's going on....I keep it to myself now......anyway hope we do get that big signing

 

[Regan]

@matchball every Tigers Centre will end up in the second row ... pity there’s not 5 second rowers Allowed in the pack !

You don't remember Tim Sheens?

 

[TillLindemann]

Not sure if this has already been posted but looks like we're still in the hunt for Arrow, Brimson, and Frizell

https://www.sportingnews.com/au/league/news/wests-tigers-set-to-up-the-ante-in-their-pursuit-of-three-off-contract-stars/mp7tgl9kl5p71ch3pxgvhh9di

 

[Tiger5150]

@Lukic - agree. I think mixing Mitchell with Maguire's no nonsense coaching and fitness regime would be a recipe for probable disaster. He might respond positively and go to the next level but I really, really doubt it. AND WT would have another Packer / Reynolds high value player, little to show for it situation after just resolving the previous ones.

We need to make sure we pick the right players to suit Maguire's methods and style, not just talent. Thats why I also think Moylan would be a disaster too but maybe not Milford.

I agree that Mitchell would be a risk in that his (supposed) laziness meeting Madges hard nosed methods will go one of two ways (one bad, one VERY good) but there is a massive difference in ability and talent between Mitchell and Reynolds or Packer for that matter.

Whilst its a risk at some level, at least there is one known factor and that is the talent of the kid. It would be an exciting risk to take and to be honest the only potential downside is the cap space. If it is somewhat successful it will help attract players once we start getting the deadwood off our roster.

FWIW I think its all smoke, I cant imagine him as a Tiger.

 

[momo_amp_medo]

Frizell

It’s all smoke until you have it confirmed by WT website so in the meantime just sit back and enjoy the games.

 

[Bathursttiger2]

Can anyone break down what the wtf signing is?
I’m assuming it means West’s Tigers Forum? But what is it that signifies it is a big signing?
Why is it named the WTF signing?

It could be “Why the F” are we signing so n so.

 

[Dyloh]

Didn't Brooks and Brown grow up as good mates? Not sure how much it matters but I feel as though we haven't had an enforcer for the lil blokes in awhile until recently in Garner. That's my personal upside if we were to sign Brown. Has to be good for the lil fellas to have some sense of protection doesn't it?

 

[BZN]

@hsvjones funneeeeeee :smiley:

 

[Wounded_magpie]

@Spacecub all good mate . Just pointing out that a few other things my client said at the same time came to fruition quite quickly. Unfortunately things still remain quiet re the WTF signing

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Didn't Brooks and Brown grow up as good mates? Not sure how much it matters but I feel as though we haven't had an enforcer for the lil blokes in awhile until recently in Garner. That's my personal upside if we were to sign Brown. Has to be good for the lil fellas to have some sense of protection doesn't it?

I think it is outstanding that one of our junior players wants to return to WTs. I wish one or two more had the same mindset.

 

[dazza65]

@Bathursttiger2 It could also mean WTF!!!!!! I never thought a player of that quality would sign with us.......... well it could, maybe......:face_palm:

 

[2005magic]

Ok guys, here's a compromise. WT approach both Mitchell and Suli for a centre role. See what happens then.

 

[2005magic]

Any news on what we are doing hooker wise since Liddle is gone for a major part of the season already? Will be interesting to see how they start training with team structure. I can't see Reynolds there, maybe Walters but hopefully we can buy Billy Brittain for a couple of seasons for cover. Some people have mentioned Mbye to hooker but I've no idea how that would go.

 

[TheDaBoss]

cricket is on tonight


sit back and enjoy that while we wait for the impending doom of a signing

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Any news on what we are doing hooker wise since Liddle is gone for a major part of the season already? Will be interesting to see how they start training with team structure. I can't see Reynolds there, maybe Walters but hopefully we can buy Billy Brittain for a couple of seasons for cover. Some people have mentioned Mbye to hooker but I've no idea how that would go.

Billy Walters, I'm pretty sure Madge has eyes on him filling in at hooker.

 

[2005magic]

@Cultured_Bogan - Cheers. I hope Liddle's fragility is at an end when he recovers and gets back on the field. He has talent but he can't ever seen to stay on the field. Geez, he sure must have crossed paths with a black cat in the past...

 

[Go_You_Good_Things]

@Dyloh
On the subject of Brown, I remember him upsetting his grandmother during the season.
I don't think that is the sort of character we need moving forward.