innsaneink
Well-known member
… It seems most people here want a coach that has no say who is in His team.
I see
We really have progressed haven't we?
I see
We really have progressed haven't we?
So....
- Thread starter innsaneink
- Start date
gallagher
Well-known member
We want someone to come in here, clean all the crap up that former managment have put in place and sort out the playing roster.
That's until someone comes here and actually does it. Then it's a disgrace.
That's until someone comes here and actually does it. Then it's a disgrace.
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
Col put it best in another thread. For yrs supporters have been demanding accountability, and now they're getting what they've demanded. Be careful what you wish for as the saying goes.
westTAHger
Well-known member
@gallagher said:
This would seem to be the situation at the moment.
Damned if they do, damned if they don't.
I think most people taking emotion aside are quite ok with Farah being told to look elsewhere. everyone agrees he is not playing anywhere near like a 900 K player and captain. Tough calls do need to be made.
I think it is more the fact the people have little faith in Taylor based on how he has got the squad to perform so far. And telling Farah he will he playing reserve grade and training with the part time squad was disrespectful for mine.
I think it is more the fact the people have little faith in Taylor based on how he has got the squad to perform so far. And telling Farah he will he playing reserve grade and training with the part time squad was disrespectful for mine.
gallagher
Well-known member
It would be disrespectful if that was said to the media. Being told that in a private meeting is just honesty.
Wayne Benett makes these descisions and every one gives him the benefit of the doubt, problem is our coach hasn't shown the same success. We are last but this maybe the rite choice who knows? If we were showing real improvement through out the year and near the 8 alot of people would be more optimistic he is making the rite call and have more faith. I know that's how i personally feel.
I know that i am all in favour of making tough decisions and getting things right however the timing in all of this and the way it has been done is quite disgraceful.Robbie is definately coming to the end of his career it should have been mentioned to him at 2-3 months ago so that he could find another club before the rosters are full even if we still have to top up his contract.Doing it this late in the season makes it very difficult to get a contact and we could quite conceivably be paying nearly all of it. hardly a win/win situation at the moment it is lose/lose and smacks of incompetence and bias.I wonder when the board was made aware of all of this not that we will ever know
We need a disciplinarian who is tough and a track record better than the players he coaches.
No one would question Bellamy, Bennet, Macguire coming in and doing the. The issue is no one trusts this current administration. I believe we are on the rift track however, our inexperience and lack of a winning culture is shining through.
No one would question Bellamy, Bennet, Macguire coming in and doing the. The issue is no one trusts this current administration. I believe we are on the rift track however, our inexperience and lack of a winning culture is shining through.
fibrodreaming
Well-known member
@innsaneink said:
Ink - I think it depends. If the coach is a good coach then clearly he should control who is in the squad. If, however; the coach is not a good coach, then this role should fall to the captain.
That seems to be the consensus.
Tigerdave
Well-known member
@gallagher said:
Hit the nail on the head.
The clean up is happening, they are trying to fix the problems caused by prior admins, still not good enough for some and apparently ex-players have a right to complain about the club trying to fix the problems too.
Some of you blokes are off yer heads.
Taylor is a complete dud…..sucked the life right out of us.....blind Freddie could see it.
You coach to yer strengths...good coaches realize where there advantage is. Not try to change how they play cos the stats dont lie....dumb dumb dumb.
Why anyone would have faith in him is beyond me.
Why anyone would want him to stay and Robbie to go beggars belief!
Taylor is a complete dud…..sucked the life right out of us.....blind Freddie could see it.
You coach to yer strengths...good coaches realize where there advantage is. Not try to change how they play cos the stats dont lie....dumb dumb dumb.
Why anyone would have faith in him is beyond me.
Why anyone would want him to stay and Robbie to go beggars belief!
@Chris said:
What have they actually done by this decision that has benefited anyone! If it was about money and easing the salary cap pressures - epic fail. If it was about attracting new players - epic fail. If it was about getting rid of Robbie Farah at the moment - epic fail. If it was about creating a stable environment for the players and providing the fans some hope that success is not far way- epic fail. If it was about making us look the most inept club in the competition at the moment- congratulations achieved.
innsaneink
Well-known member
Agree with pretty much all the comments here… I don't think anyone's saying Taylor's a great coach... Not me anyway... But he's allwe got... We can't keep punting coaches... That gets us nowhere except back to square one.
Someone has to make the tough decisions... It's never going to be easy
Someone has to make the tough decisions... It's never going to be easy
T
Tiger_In_The_Gong
Guest
@Telltails said:
Well said.
These guys are having a bit of a field day at the moment but the more you look at the facts of this situation the more you realise this is almost one of the clubs greatest ever fails. The previous administration look good in comparison.
@innsaneink said:
I'd give him credit for making a tough decision if he had the balls to come out and state his real reasons. Instead he craps on about salary cap and tries to portray his faux respect for the captain.
Just say the guy isn't playing well, his body is slowing down and I don't get on with him. That is justification. Screwing a player out of his contract which seems signed in a way that helped the club at the time is wrong.
