Sunday morning rambling..

Tiger_heart

Well-known member
Jahream Bula - A natural, no matter what sport he plays in. Given what he has shown to date, are we any chance or retaining him? From what I understand he is contracted until the end of the 2025 season so, with Api, 2/3 of what we need (in the spine) already.

If others stay, like Blore (contracted to end 24?), Papali'i, Funaki, Doueihi, then perhas there is a glimmer of hope. Maybe this season should be seen as the one where the wipe the slate clean (yes, I know, yet again) with the club also deciding who shoud coach.

I don't think that to continue with Sheens is viable. And I also don't think that the coaching merry go round is any better that serving yesterday's soup, to be honest.
In this day and age, 12 months in any job is long enough to prove yourself, in a professional sport. No saying you make the 8's, but at the very least you show improvement on last year (not hard to do when you have the spoon anyway). At the moment, the combo Sheens/Marshall is clearly not working. There should be no shame in admitting it, and say that, yet again, we got it wrong. Only those that don't have a go never make mistakes. But there also comes a time (eg for the board) to step aside - Errare humanum est, sed in errare perseverare diabolicum.

Finally, the grass isn't any greener with clubs that have invested big (see Dogs) or were "expected" to make the eight (see Roosters). Yes, we should be concerned about our own club, but perhaps with this in mind the ongoing self-flagellation can feel a little less painful. It's a strange competition this year, but a deja vu for us West Tigers supporters.

Coffe is calling...
 
Jahream Bula - A natural, no matter what sport he plays in. Given what he has shown to date, are we any chance or retaining him? From what I understand he is contracted until the end of the 2025 season so, with Api, 2/3 of what we need (in the spine) already.

If others stay, like Blore (contracted to end 24?), Papali'i, Funaki, Doueihi, then perhas there is a glimmer of hope. Maybe this season should be seen as the one where the wipe the slate clean (yes, I know, yet again) with the club also deciding who shoud coach.

I don't think that to continue with Sheens is viable. And I also don't think that the coaching merry go round is any better that serving yesterday's soup, to be honest.
In this day and age, 12 months in any job is long enough to prove yourself, in a professional sport. No saying you make the 8's, but at the very least you show improvement on last year (not hard to do when you have the spoon anyway). At the moment, the combo Sheens/Marshall is clearly not working. There should be no shame in admitting it, and say that, yet again, we got it wrong. Only those that don't have a go never make mistakes. But there also comes a time (eg for the board) to step aside - Errare humanum est, sed in errare perseverare diabolicum.

Finally, the grass isn't any greener with clubs that have invested big (see Dogs) or were "expected" to make the eight (see Roosters). Yes, we should be concerned about our own club, but perhaps with this in mind the ongoing self-flagellation can feel a little less painful. It's a strange competition this year, but a deja vu for us West Tigers supporters.

Coffe is calling...
Not a bad ramblings for a Sunday morning. I reckon Sheens should leave the coaching bit to Benji and go back to Director of Coaching and if Benji feels tentative still make a good offer for Holbrook as head coach for 3 years whilst he is still available.
 
On the bright side - Wests Tigers sell Stefano and Bula at an astronomical price. Then buy 6 bargain basement players. That is good business. Lee & Pascoe keep Wests Tigers economically viable. And sign Holbrook as coach. Now that's business. Good business. For the fans they can throw in food coupons, rental vouchers etc in the membership packages- and a free 1 year subscription maybe for Lowe's or Rueben F Scarf....... and 2 free hot dogs at 1 home game. Since they have 5 home grounds - thats 10 free hot dogs - another bargain.
 
On the bright side - Wests Tigers sell Stefano and Bula at an astronomical price. Then buy 6 bargain basement players. That is good business. Lee & Pascoe keep Wests Tigers economically viable. And sign Holbrook as coach. Now that's business. Good business. For the fans they can throw in food coupons, rental vouchers etc in the membership packages- and a free 1 year subscription maybe for Lowe's or Rueben F Scarf....... and 2 free hot dogs at 1 home game. Since they have 5 home grounds - thats 10 free hot dogs - another bargain.
I love when people use this logic seriously. Like “hey guys, we don’t need to sign Cam Munster for 1.3. We could sign 3 or 4 players with that money”
 
On the bright side - Wests Tigers sell Stefano and Bula at an astronomical price. Then buy 6 bargain basement players. That is good business. Lee & Pascoe keep Wests Tigers economically viable. And sign Holbrook as coach. Now that's business. Good business. For the fans they can throw in food coupons, rental vouchers etc in the membership packages- and a free 1 year subscription maybe for Lowe's or Rueben F Scarf....... and 2 free hot dogs at 1 home game. Since they have 5 home grounds - thats 10 free hot dogs - another bargain.
Why would you sell Stefano and bula post something sensible for heavens sake
 
I love when people use this logic seriously. Like “hey guys, we don’t need to sign Cam Munster for 1.3. We could sign 3 or 4 players with that money”
Why would you sell Stefano and bula post something sensible for heavens sake
You dont have to sell them. They can leave on their own accord. They want to play semi final football. Take advantage of this once in a life time players. The cream of the crop if you will. Apologies Ancient Magpie if I offended you.
 
Keeping to the theme of the thread......about 7, 8 mins into the Newcastle Wests Tigers game....after Newcastle looked to score again.....or did.... the commentator was already talking about the rest of the games this round.
 
wasnt going to make a new thread so Sunday morning rambling makes a good a place as any.

If we are to get another expansion team, I reckon the NRL should hit the top 6 teams from the previous seasons ladder to supply (willingly or not) 2 x players from their top 30 listed players as at end of season, and those of course remaining with that club, to help fill the player requirements of the expansion team to get to 30 by August.

That will give the new team 12 NRL standard, or near NRL standard, then the new coach and club still has 18 spots for which to recruit.

Hit the top clubs with their depth of talent first.
 
Also in yesterdays Brisbane Canterbury match that half back that Wests Tigers let go to Brisbane - yawning late in the game on the bench just after Brisbane scored another try.
 
Jahream Bula - A natural, no matter what sport he plays in. Given what he has shown to date, are we any chance or retaining him? From what I understand he is contracted until the end of the 2025 season so, with Api, 2/3 of what we need (in the spine) already.

If others stay, like Blore (contracted to end 24?), Papali'i, Funaki, Doueihi, then perhas there is a glimmer of hope. Maybe this season should be seen as the one where the wipe the slate clean (yes, I know, yet again) with the club also deciding who shoud coach.

I don't think that to continue with Sheens is viable. And I also don't think that the coaching merry go round is any better that serving yesterday's soup, to be honest.
In this day and age, 12 months in any job is long enough to prove yourself, in a professional sport. No saying you make the 8's, but at the very least you show improvement on last year (not hard to do when you have the spoon anyway). At the moment, the combo Sheens/Marshall is clearly not working. There should be no shame in admitting it, and say that, yet again, we got it wrong. Only those that don't have a go never make mistakes. But there also comes a time (eg for the board) to step aside - Errare humanum est, sed in errare perseverare diabolicum.

Finally, the grass isn't any greener with clubs that have invested big (see Dogs) or were "expected" to make the eight (see Roosters). Yes, we should be concerned about our own club, but perhaps with this in mind the ongoing self-flagellation can feel a little less painful. It's a strange competition this year, but a deja vu for us West Tigers supporters.

I will be eating yesterdays soup tomorrow…

Two points I might add…

-The grass is a little greener with Dogs and Roosters because they occasionally win a game
- I note that Buzz is already saying that one of Benji/Fulton has to go as neither side is going with what the other proposes in terms of recruiting
 
I will be eating yesterdays soup tomorrow…

Two points I might add…

-The grass is a little greener with Dogs and Roosters because they occasionally win a game
- I note that Buzz is already saying that one of Benji/Fulton has to go as neither side is going with what the other proposes in terms of recruiting
I really hope the Benji Fulton rumour is true.
 
wasnt going to make a new thread so Sunday morning rambling makes a good a place as any.

If we are to get another expansion team, I reckon the NRL should hit the top 6 teams from the previous seasons ladder to supply (willingly or not) 2 x players from their top 30 listed players as at end of season, and those of course remaining with that club, to help fill the player requirements of the expansion team to get to 30 by August.

That will give the new team 12 NRL standard, or near NRL standard, then the new coach and club still has 18 spots for which to recruit.

Hit the top clubs with their depth of talent first.
And if there is a 18th team - hope they dont get a good coach. Wests Tigers get a chance then of being only 1 place away from the bottom. Dolphins didn't do them any favours.
 
On the bright side - Wests Tigers sell Stefano and Bula at an astronomical price. Then buy 6 bargain basement players. That is good business. Lee & Pascoe keep Wests Tigers economically viable. And sign Holbrook as coach. Now that's business. Good business. For the fans they can throw in food coupons, rental vouchers etc in the membership packages- and a free 1 year subscription maybe for Lowe's or Rueben F Scarf....... and 2 free hot dogs at 1 home game. Since they have 5 home grounds - thats 10 free hot dogs - another bargain.

It’s great business for Pascoe and Lee… judge us next year they say….this season is a practice…
 
My feelings on Sheens is that he sounds a bit old and jaded .However I don't think any coach could have made finals with this roster and weak backline .
I think the 3 headed coach approach hasnt worked .Better with one master chef in the kitchen . I feel if we had Sheens as Head of Football ( boss of recruitment manager )
Benji as head coach . And Robbie as CEO -couldnt do worse
A better arrangement
 
Back
Top