T-Rex faces 10 weeks out

Centaur

New member
**Tony Williams facing 10 weeks on sidelines**
Andrew Bryan NRL.com

Manly and Australia have suffered a stunning blow with forward Tony Williams facing up to 10 weeks on the sidelines after he was charged with a grade 4 dangerous throw by the NRL match review committee on Tuesday.

Williams was put on report in the 9th minute of Manly’s 17-14 loss to Cronulla at Toyota Stadium for his tackle on Sharks hooker Isaac De Gois.

If the Sea Eagles enter an early guilty plea, Williams will miss seven weeks, meaning he will be ruled out of Australia’s Test match against New Zealand on April 20 at Eden Park. It will also mean Williams won’t be available for the Sea Eagles until their Round 11 clash with the Roosters at Brookvale Oval.

NSW would be able to select the 23-year-old in the opening State of Origin game at Etihad Stadium on May 23 if he takes the early plea, however he won’t have played a game leading into the clash, which will leave the Blues' selectors with a difficult decision.

The grade 4 dangerous throw charge carries a base penalty of 725 points, but Williams has two prior non-similar offences which have added a 40% loading on the dangerous throw charge.

Williams was charged in the 2011 Preliminary Final against the Broncos with a grade 2 careless high tackle on Bronco Jharal Yow Yeh and then received a one-match ban during the Four Nations tournament in England for a high tackle on England’s Ben Westwood.

If Williams and the Sea Eagles fight the charge or the grading at the NRL judiciary and lose, Williams could face 10 weeks on the sidelines, ruling him out of the opening State of Origin contest.

If the Sea Eagles are successful in downgrading the charge to a grade 3 dangerous throw, Williams would still miss five matches, meaning he would be available for Manly’s Round 9 clash against the Raiders.

It is a major blow to the Northern Beaches club, who will take on St George Illawarra on Saturday night. It is still unknown when Manly’s star pair, Glenn Stewart (finger) and centre Steve Matai (hand), will be right to return.

The Sea Eagles will have until 12pm on Wednesday to respond to the charge.
 
Quite harsh IMO. Mind you, it really was a vicious and reckless tackle. I am not sure if there is any precedent on the kind of tackle he did? It was more like a WWE move than anything.
 
When you consider the crusher tackle he wasnt charged for it probably works out about right.

There should be a gif file of that in the dangerous throw definition
 
Looking at it again, the point is that if De Gois was to land on his head/neck flush - then his neck could have easily snapped in half. The amount of force Williams generated in the throw was brutal.

Needs to be a lesson learnt, don't try that tackle again.
 
for some reason reminds me of old school Zangief from Street Fighter…
\
\
![](http://i89.photobucket.com/albums/k231/Cajun89/finalatomicbuster.gif)

looks like a soft landing for De Giois on first viewing, but a different angle shows it only JUST and I mean JUST misses him landing straight on his head.

I think the complete indifference after the tackle completed didn't help Tony's cause, where Robbie IMMEDIATELY looked up and said "dude, sorry man!" and Hornby was also cool about it.
 
It makes you think What penalty are they going to hand out when someone really get seriously injured and loses their career ?? How do you measure that ??
 
There is no need for tackles like that in the NRL.

10 weeks is harsh but does send a clear message out to all players.

Remember children watch their heros then try to copy them.
 
I don't have Fox so didn't see the game and the 1st half replay on NRL.com is of appaling quality, is there somewhere where i can view this tackle?
 
How far way is Origin?

My bet is he'll get just enough time to fit a game in before it.

It was a massive show of strength but totally uncalled for and he should serve a fairly long sentence for it.
 
@underdog said:
youtube - williams 360 tackle.

the name says it all.

thanks underdog, not sure why i didn't think of youtube..

certainly a vicious tackle….not deserving of a send off or 10 in the bin? 😕
 
@TuiTui said:
@underdog said:
youtube - williams 360 tackle.

the name says it all.

thanks underdog, not sure why i didn't think of youtube..

certainly a vicious tackle….not deserving of a send off or 10 in the bin? 😕

Lol, you know how refs work these days mate,

10 in the bins are usually reserved for stopping a certain try, or a punch up these days - and in punch ups its usually 1 from each side, so it's almost irrelevant.

You would practically have to _stab_ someone on the field these days to cop a send off.
 
@underdog said:
for some reason reminds me of old school Zangief from Street Fighter…
\
\
![](http://i89.photobucket.com/albums/k231/Cajun89/finalatomicbuster.gif)

looks like a soft landing for De Giois on first viewing, but a different angle shows it only JUST and I mean JUST misses him landing straight on his head.

I think the complete indifference after the tackle completed didn't help Tony's cause, where Robbie IMMEDIATELY looked up and said "dude, sorry man!" and Hornby was also cool about it.

Haha "zangief" gold
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 
@underdog said:
@TuiTui said:
@underdog said:
youtube - williams 360 tackle.

the name says it all.

thanks underdog, not sure why i didn't think of youtube..

certainly a vicious tackle….not deserving of a send off or 10 in the bin? 😕

Lol, you know how refs work these days mate,

10 in the bins are usually reserved for stopping a certain try, or a punch up these days - and in punch ups its usually 1 from each side, so it's almost irrelevant.

You would practically have to _stab_ someone on the field these days to cop a send off.

Yeah i know how they work…still confuses the bejeezus out of me.
 
I like T Rex, but he deserves a long stint IMO.

He threw the player down HARD and it could have crippled him. He also showed absolutely NO remorse.

Robbie got straight up and said sorry to Hornby. T Rex didn't say a thing.

The bloke needs to learn it's not right.
 

Members online

Back
Top