Tallyn Da Silva #270

He may prove us wrong, though Api would probably be the only hooker to do so other than Cameron Smith, who relied on a very different skill set to still be able to adequately contribute for so long.

Even now, sure, Api can play 80, but even Penrith knew a few years ago that he was better utilised for 60 minutes or less.
I dont think he can play 80 effectively now.
He has done it 27 times over the past 3 seasons for 5 wins @ 19% success rate.
When he shares the role we have won 9 from 18 @ 50% success rate.
 
Believe Richardson when he is quoted as follows -

“Tallyn's decision I think will be based around what we do with Api and that's fair enough. He wants to play first grade.”

And Newscorp -

Da Silva is off-contract at the same time as Apisai Koroisau, and News Corp are reporting the captain will be offered a new deal.
Yes we are talking about 2027, not now.
This discussion is ridiculous.
 
I dont think he can play 80 effectively now.
He has done it 27 times over the past 3 seasons for 5 wins @ 19% success rate.
When he shares the role we have won 9 from 18 @ 50% success rate.
do you have the 27 games available to share mate.

Id like to dig into that stat, because I find it hard to believe it would be an Api issue.. and more just a convenient stat that can be painted to say we lose when API doesn't share minutes
 
do you have the 27 games available to share mate.

Id like to dig into that stat, because I find it hard to believe it would be an Api issue.. and more just a convenient stat that can be painted to say we lose when API doesn't share minutes
Im not blaming him, but the numbers dont lie. We are much much more likely to win when he gets a break.
As weve always known
For many years now.
 
He may prove us wrong, though Api would probably be the only hooker to do so other than Cameron Smith, who relied on a very different skill set to still be able to adequately contribute for so long.

Even now, sure, Api can play 80, but Penrith knew a few years ago that he was better utilised for 60 minutes or less.
I agree that Api is better utilised for 60 minutes and should have TDS on at the 25-30 minute mark and for the start of the second half thus allowing Api to comeback for the end of the games to close out.

I was watching him in the defensive line on Friday and he was jumping out of the line to effect his tackles and then racing back into the defensive line which is all effort and what we all love about his passion to the club, however it is not sustainable for all games and his longevity.

The use of the bench is not suited to him playing 80 minutes

I would hope TDS sees what is out there and decides to stay loyal to the Tigers as I had the pleasure of touring the COE with him as a host and he is a fine young man.
 
Like when you see a halfback missing a tackle on a winger down the side line, Any old halfback - No one in particular.... all the experts are blasting the halfback for missing the tackle.

No mention of the Winger and Centre that are defending outside him
aren't even in the Frame.

Capewell is a great example - He's missing a few other players tackles...
So is Api
- Says more about our middles than it does about Api.

Old mates point is right though,
He's not going to get less worn out as he gets older while still making them...
Again, Doesn't say much for our middles.
Says a lot our coaching staff and their game management.
 
I can believe that Api is better playing 60-70 mins then 80 minutes. However if I need a backup for 10-20 minutes then I don't want a hooker only on the bench I am looking for someone who can play either lock/second row or backs and that can manage 20 mins in the hooker role be it at the start or middle of the match.

In that case it isn't TDS - if I am looking internally its getting 20 mins out of Mason who can then also cover the halves, fullback and outside backs at a stretch or Charlie Murray who type who could play 20 mins at hooker or Haywood coming through who could cover hooker or halves

Looking outside the club the perfect off contract replacement would be Silvia Havili although at 32 he is aging so a slightly younger version of him
 
I can believe that Api is better playing 60-70 mins then 80 minutes. However if I need a backup for 10-20 minutes then I don't want a hooker only on the bench I am looking for someone who can play either lock/second row or backs and that can manage 20 mins in the hooker role be it at the start or middle of the match.

In that case it isn't TDS - if I am looking internally its getting 20 mins out of Mason who can then also cover the halves, fullback and outside backs at a stretch or Charlie Murray who type who could play 20 mins at hooker or Haywood coming through who could cover hooker or halves

Looking outside the club the perfect off contract replacement would be Silvia Havili although at 32 he is aging so a slightly younger version of him
I would give Api 50 minutes only.
He is on the downhill part of his career and we need a replacement ready within 2 years Id suspect.
 
Im not blaming him, but the numbers dont lie. We are much much more likely to win when he gets a break.
As weve always known
For many years now.
I'm not questioning you mate, I'm asking if you can share the info you are using so I can take a look at it.. Because numbers can very much lie.. I'd like to do some analysis myself
 
I'm not questioning you mate, I'm asking if you can share the info you are using so I can take a look at it.. Because numbers can very much lie.. I'd like to do some analysis myself
I just went through the games hes played and noted the minutes played. The analysis is not any deeper than that. Heres the records:

1750658624117.png
 
3 is a lot man, are you counting this year in that?
I wasn't tbh...I think he can be a starter in 26 & 27 and bench/utility in 28? But hey, predicting what will happen in one week is tricky let alone three years! Don't think he should be playing 80 even now though so who knows, could certainly burn him out if we keep it up IMO...
 
Maybe another pressing issue for us @Droppy05 is that we need a more accessible democratic structure to hold the decision makers accountable.

The Old Mates Act is still in force.

If we get the spoon again, it will difficult to argue from a results perspective that the HB Board coup has achieved anything but prolong the tenure of the incompetent and ineffective. Replaced one set of rascals with another.

If the club expects us to be placated with 5 wins a season, that’s hopeless.
 
The problem with the pro-Api camp is they are measuring the 25 version and not what he’ll be like 2 seasons down the track.
Hang on, this needs to be clarified.

The 'pro-Api camp' are not suggesting we pick Api ahead of TDS by the time '27 rolls around.

In the ideal world it should be a straightforward transition with TDS getting more and more minutes with the aim of starting in '27. Depending how Api is going then, you decide the minutes he gets off the bench.
 
Hang on, this needs to be clarified.

The 'pro-Api camp' are not suggesting we pick Api ahead of TDS by the time '27 rolls around.

In the ideal world it should be a straightforward transition with TDS getting more and more minutes with the aim of starting in '27. Depending how Api is going then, you decide the minutes he gets off the bench.
The "pro Api" camp seem confused and are constantly saying that TDS wants Api position now.
Your third and fourth sentences are exactly what the "pro Tallyn" camp are arguing.
 
Maybe another pressing issue for us @Droppy05 is that we need a more accessible democratic structure to hold the decision makers accountable.

The Old Mates Act is still in force.

If we get the spoon again, it will difficult to argue from a results perspective that the HB Board coup has achieved anything but prolong the tenure of the incompetent and ineffective. Replaced one set of rascals with another.

If the club expects us to be placated with 5 wins a season, that’s hopeless.
That's right
We deserve 6 wins a season!!!
Riot!!!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: TSP
Thinking about the season Harry Grant had with us in 2020.

Smith didn't retire until a month after the end of season.

Grant was willing to go back to Storm and bide his time further to take Smith's spot.

Not to mention, he already waited a couple of years as well without any first grade experience.

Hynes did the same as well until he went to Sharks.

We are recruiting the wrong type of people. We are recruiting players that just want to be seen by the world so they can go to another team.

The recruiting team needs to weed these players out. I'd rather take a play who is 10-15% worse than TDS but is more likely to stick it out with us even when we are losing and want to be the ones to make a change.
 
Thinking about the season Harry Grant had with us in 2020.

Smith didn't retire until a month after the end of season.

Grant was willing to go back to Storm and bide his time further to take Smith's spot.

Not to mention, he already waited a couple of years as well without any first grade experience.

Hynes did the same as well until he went to Sharks.

We are recruiting the wrong type of people. We are recruiting players that just want to be seen by the world so they can go to another team.

The recruiting team needs to weed these players out. I'd rather take a play who is 10-15% worse than TDS but is more likely to stick it out with us even when we are losing and want to be the ones to make a change.
Tallyn is that guy.
If his tune has now changed then question what has been said behind closed doors.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top