All valid points.
I actually see AD as more of a wide-running option in the back row because of the exact qualities you’ve mentioned. I don’t think lock is his position at all like you. Being in the middle will stunt his running game.
Yeah I agree. If Madden keeps his form up I'd personally like to see AD share lock with Fainu, and Twal just play the same role he already is in the front row. It would actually very closely match Penrith's structure if you think about it.
He’s a career reserve grader …. I have serious doubt that a guy who’s 2 best assets , are mid field kicking and going deep in the line for block shape , can “unlock” the backs …. I like madden . But this is the most ridiculous forum stupidity conversation I’ve ever participated in . I couldn’t disagree more with this . I find it to be a firm example of the “paralysed by the moment” bullshit that people participate in on this forum . Like last week ,people saying that we should drop Bula … or when the red head centre made a break in Wollongong a few years ago and everyone was sizing up his immortal jacket .
I said it after the trials this debate would rage all season. It’s what happens when you pick up a traditional halfback to deputise for your makeshift option.
Calls for Doohey to be lock are high risk. Last night Twal topped the tackle count again with 0 misses. Can AD do that with his dodgy knees and suspect D? Jack Gibson said if it ain't broke don't fix it. Twal is our lock and AD in attack showed his flexibility by running out wide on both sides of the field for those cutting back inside runs. In Def leave AD as either a half or Centre on the right with KPP, who showed his talent again last night. Last night, the right edge stayed solid - it was the left edge that had some issues, but they adjusted well. At least it's nice to be talking about options for a change instead of missed opportunities.
What's wrong with you, that's an over the top rant, Jock had a good game it should be admired.
Good points again. I know man management is a big part of the whole formula and it could be difficult for Benji to 'tinker'. However, I still think an astute coach will be willing to ring the changes if he thinks it will lead to better performance from his team. As many have said, Douehi's running game was fantastic yesterday but so was Madden's, management, unlocking the rest of the back line and relieving pressure with his kicks. Also, the Tigers have had a lot of trouble, for a long time, converting opportunities in the red zone. This has been due to a lack of structure and an overdependence on individual running from players such as Douehi. Anyway, we shall see!
Yea maybe … but geezus man I’ve seen people dropping luai today , others moving AD to centre , others building the team around madden …. Walk outside for a bit . I’m stoked we won as well . and he will and is a great addition to the team especially against teams like the warriors and Penrith , with simple game plans build around field position and forcing errors , taking opportunities .
This is my point . You’ve missed it . Go back and read the comments ; people wanting to sell and drop luai … AD to centres … build the team around jock .
My only contribution to all that - I believe Madden is the best halfback on our roster currently.
Love it! Succinct and spot on.
I know L, these posts that get carried away especially after an exceptional win can get on your goat, best to let them go through to the keeper to prevent steam venting out of your ears.
The 6 man bench probably helps us having so many options around the ball. We won’t experience the same drop off as some teams when the inevitable injuries hit. I’m sure it will all sort itself out, possibly with Latu getting impatient being the biggest risk.
Ain’t that the truth. Some genuine knobs on here.
