The Luai dilemma...

I'd have Latu and Douehi on the bench with 4 forwards.

If we are struggling to gain yardage then put Douehi at lock to do the long kicking, or if we are struggling to take advantage of overlaps then have Douehi there.

If we need help creating space on the outside or if Madden isn't able to straighten the attack, then id put Latu there who's very good at creating space.

Also I feel Douehi needs some rest as his hamstring are definitely not 100%
I like that you're keeping Jock there but many fans would be up in arms if Douehi is put on the bench. Also, he's way to damaging and valuable to the team as a talker and leader to be left out. What's with this hamstring/ needing rest issue? He certainly doesn't look like he's carrying an injury. I agree, Latu is a great sub to have, and will do a job for us.
 
AD needs to stay in our team but not at half back or 5/8 when Luai is fit.

AD is benefiting from having a proper half back in the team and good go forward.

He isn't an organiser, his kick game isn't accurate and is erratic. He doesn't dig into the line or get our players deep.

He is a good strong and effective runner with an improving passing game. He isn't a half back.

Keep him at 7 and we get a repeat of the South's game.
Rightly O, u pick the souths game to use as your reasoning! Luai played that game as well. It wasn’t a great game by both. But Doubie being closer to the ball has him killing it, he loves playing in the halves. Do u really want to kick him now??
As I have said rest Luai this week, and if we win again put Luai in the bench against the slime greens. I say keep the winning team together until they lose or individuals play poor.
Look I love how madden has been playing but it’s not like he’s got heaps of try assists. I know he has massively helped with tries but not the guy who puts them over the line!
 
Pole definitely has been the weakest of all forwards but I don't want to put Twal at front row. Mentally, he needs to keep his job the same and having Douehi at lock would make him think he needs to do more ball carrying instead of doing what he's doing now.

Douehi imo is not a good centre either. He's a very good playmaker and he has certain strengths. He needs options inside and outside him whereas at centre he only has one option outside him.
Pole is not a great starter, he needs the opposition players to be tired. His main move is his footwork which works better on tired defence. That’s why he seems better in his second run. But no need to change a team that’s winning!
 
I like that you're keeping Jock there but many fans would be up in arms if Douehi is put on the bench. Also, he's way to damaging and valuable to the team as a talker and leader to be left out. What's with this hamstring/ needing rest issue? He certainly doesn't look like he's carrying an injury. I agree, Latu is a great sub to have, and will do a job for us.
He's not taking any kicks- goal kicking or general play. His stride lengths are very short when he's running and with when he gets in open field, he looks to pass straight away.

His play the balls are always slow because he can't get off the ground as quickly as he used to.

This guy is still a weapon even at 80% but I think he's too valuable to risk with Luai there.

Also he's wearing a compression garment on the R hammie for support. Maybe he hasn't had a tear that's why they're still playing him but he's definitely in pain IMO.
 
I like that you're keeping Jock there but many fans would be up in arms if Douehi is put on the bench. Also, he's way to damaging and valuable to the team as a talker and leader to be left out. What's with this hamstring/ needing rest issue? He certainly doesn't look like he's carrying an injury. I agree, Latu is a great sub to have, and will do a job for us.
He's not taking any kicks- goal kicking or general play. His stride lengths are very short when he's running and with when he gets in open field, he looks to pass straight away.

His play the balls are always slow because he can't get off the ground as quickly as he used to.

This guy is still a weapon even at 80% but I think he's too valuable to risk with Luai there.

Also he's wearing a compression garment on the R hammie
 
Most of the discussion on the Luai dilemma has been about our attack but what about the impact on our defence.

Luai plays left side, Doeuihi plays right side. Both have proven to be very good in the defensive structure on both sides of the ruck. How many tries did Luai save last year with his defensive efforts!

So Madden comes in and replaces Luai on the left side. Firstly, does anyone know if that is Jock's preferred side in both attack & defence?

If I was to rate the 3 of them defensively, I would have AD & Luai almost equal ahead of Madden. I'd also have Latu ahead of Madden defensively.

Not to say AD can't play another position to fit in Madden but just looking at it defensively.
 
Most of the discussion on the Luai dilemma has been about our attack but what about the impact on our defence.

Luai plays left side, Doeuihi plays right side. Both have proven to be very good in the defensive structure on both sides of the ruck. How many tries did Luai save last year with his defensive efforts!

So Madden comes in and replaces Luai on the left side. Firstly, does anyone know if that is Jock's preferred side in both attack & defence?

If I was to rate the 3 of them defensively, I would have AD & Luai almost equal ahead of Madden. I'd also have Latu ahead of Madden defensively.

Not to say AD can't play another position to fit in Madden but just looking at it defensively.
Madden seems quite R side dominant. He does good when playing R side of the ruck, straightening th attack well. However he did play a couple of L side shirt sides well too. You're right though that Luai being back would help out L side D.
 
Most of the discussion on the Luai dilemma has been about our attack but what about the impact on our defence.

Luai plays left side, Doeuihi plays right side. Both have proven to be very good in the defensive structure on both sides of the ruck. How many tries did Luai save last year with his defensive efforts!

So Madden comes in and replaces Luai on the left side. Firstly, does anyone know if that is Jock's preferred side in both attack & defence?

If I was to rate the 3 of them defensively, I would have AD & Luai almost equal ahead of Madden. I'd also have Latu ahead of Madden defensively.

Not to say AD can't play another position to fit in Madden but just looking at it defensively.
Luai probably nails those cover tackles that Madden missed on Twiddle and Young over the last couple of weeks
 
He's not taking any kicks- goal kicking or general play. His stride lengths are very short when he's running and with when he gets in open field, he looks to pass straight away.

His play the balls are always slow because he can't get off the ground as quickly as he used to.

This guy is still a weapon even at 80% but I think he's too valuable to risk with Luai there.

Also he's wearing a compression garment on the R hammie
Thanks for answering. Yes, he does wear a compression sleeve but I'm not sure about some of your other observations. His stride doesn't look shorter to me and he seems to be able to run some distance before passing. Case in point was his run before setting up the try for Bula v Warriors, but that was 2 games back I suppose. Also, Douehi has always played the ball a bit slowly, partly because he regulary fights and struggles before going to ground. Maybe a week off is a better idea if he really is struggling. Interestingly he threw a couple of his best passes all season while 'delivering early'!
 
Most of the discussion on the Luai dilemma has been about our attack but what about the impact on our defence.

Luai plays left side, Doeuihi plays right side. Both have proven to be very good in the defensive structure on both sides of the ruck. How many tries did Luai save last year with his defensive efforts!

So Madden comes in and replaces Luai on the left side. Firstly, does anyone know if that is Jock's preferred side in both attack & defence?

If I was to rate the 3 of them defensively, I would have AD & Luai almost equal ahead of Madden. I'd also have Latu ahead of Madden defensively.

Not to say AD can't play another position to fit in Madden but just looking at it defensively.
You are right, i believe Luai and Taylan will lock down that left side defensively. I also believe we will look better in attack. Luai and AD just need a few weeks to really click. I dont belive AD is anywhere near being an organising 7 however Benji im sure has them both playin a hybrid 6/7 role. AD kicks long and bombs, Luai kicks short. AD plays 7 on left side shape and Luai seems to be playing 7 on right side shape. Need to see a few more games to confirm this. Luai is much more involved than he was when playing 6 at Penrith, where he was somewhat passive in attack.
 
Rightly O, u pick the souths game to use as your reasoning! Luai played that game as well. It wasn’t a great game by both. But Doubie being closer to the ball has him killing it, he loves playing in the halves. Do u really want to kick him now??
As I have said rest Luai this week, and if we win again put Luai in the bench against the slime greens. I say keep the winning team together until they lose or individuals play poor.
Look I love how madden has been playing but it’s not like he’s got heaps of try assists. I know he has massively helped with tries but not the guy who puts them over the line!
It's not my only reasoning Lathami, I was citing an example. Just because I suggest Douehi move to the centres doesn't mean I am devaluing him as a dynamic, key member of the Tigers. He will have space and, hopefully, get lots off good service, enabling him to run, which is his go. Anyway, I expect Benji to stick with Luai and Douehi in the halves so you needn't worry.
 
Rightly O, u pick the souths game to use as your reasoning! Luai played that game as well. It wasn’t a great game by both. But Doubie being closer to the ball has him killing it, he loves playing in the halves. Do u really want to kick him now??
As I have said rest Luai this week, and if we win again put Luai in the bench against the slime greens. I say keep the winning team together until they lose or individuals play poor.
Look I love how madden has been playing but it’s not like he’s got heaps of try assists. I know he has massively helped with tries but not the guy who puts them over the line!
THe South's game was an example of playing two 5/8 in the halves.

It resulted in no depth to our attack, no organisation and a rubbish kicking game.

Luai is the best 5/8 at the club by a country mile so that position is his when fit. He is yet to have the benefit of playing with a proper half back at the tigers.

Luai when partnered with a proper half back has 4 rings, State of Origin victories and Victories with Samoa.

AD isn't a half back. He is a a strong runner with an improving passing game. His kicking game is rubbish. Can't organise the attack let alone provide depth. He also tends to be sideways rather than straightening the attack.

He has operated as a 5/8 in every game this year, put what ever number you like on his back but he isn't nor ever will be a half back.

He needs to be in the team but should be humble enough to play where the team needs him and not demand to play where he wants to play.

Jock is a half back and by your definition he's been winning so should stay in the team.
 
THe South's game was an example of playing two 5/8 in the halves.

It resulted in no depth to our attack, no organisation and a rubbish kicking game.

Luai is the best 5/8 at the club by a country mile so that position is his when fit. He is yet to have the benefit of playing with a proper half back at the tigers.

Luai when partnered with a proper half back has 4 rings, State of Origin victories and Victories with Samoa.

AD isn't a half back. He is a a strong runner with an improving passing game. His kicking game is rubbish. Can't organise the attack let alone provide depth. He also tends to be sideways rather than straightening the attack.

He has operated as a 5/8 in every game this year, put what ever number you like on his back but he isn't nor ever will be a half back.

He needs to be in the team but should be humble enough to play where the team needs him and not demand to play where he wants to play.

Jock is a half back and by your definition he's been winning so should stay in the team.
Yeah I’m really torn. I’d love to see Luai paired with Madden in the halves, I think it would be exactly what we need to get the best out of Luai as you say, but I really think Doueihi has been our best player this season, he has to stay in the team. Sure Benji can shift him to centre, but will he really be as effective in that position with less hands on the ball?
 
When asked by the media so how far is Jarome

Benjis response He asked me to today to play

Api trying not to laugh
He’s a showman. You can’t take anything he says at face value. A few years ago Cleary was injured, had missed a couple weeks. At the end of one game, Luai’s being interviewed and is asked about Cleary. He said he’d be back the next week. He didn’t come back for 6 weeks.
 
Back
Top