The worst season by any club, ever?

Sometimes you can screw up your roster so bad that the NRL team performs horribly and this has a flow on effect to the reserve grade team.

Managing to run last in both women's and men's competition is some feat since they should have no influence on each other.

Can't blame Richo for this given he hasn't had enough time. I'd expect significant improvement next year in all grades. If there isn't, then nothing has changed.
Screwing up recruitment in every single grade? Not sure that's down to any one person. That's an organisational issue, a complete lack of ability to identify players of the required quality, the complete lack of coaching and tactical nous.
 
Last edited:
Has there ever been a worse season for a club in the history of the NRL/ARL?

NRL = Last
NRLW = Last
NSW Cup = Last
Jersey Flegg = 7th, missed finals
HNWNSWCup = 3rd last, missed finals
SG Ball Balmain = Last, winless
SG Ball Wests = 8th, missed finals
Harold Matts Balmain = Last, winless
Harold Matts Wests = 2nd, lost GF
Tarsha Gale = 9th, missed finals

Across the top 10 grades we only had one team make the finals. With 5/10 teams coming dead last.

This about as toxic as culture gets. Loser mentality, accepting/aspiring to mediocrity, atrocious recruitment, poor coaching. It's just not good enough. And it's why we've failed year after year to develop players.

Yes we had some young sides, and a few talented youngsters here and there - but so does every other club. And while it's unlikely you'll have success in every single grade, to fail so miserably in almost every single grade leads me to think this is the worst season a club has ever had. This is why we're a laughing stock of a club.

Are there any other contenders?
Many players playing up grades for experience this year. Galvin, Lauilili, Fainu, Miller. A few players dropped and told to move on Naden, Sullivan. Papalli and Uto leaving. Let’s hope the moves made to get experience and free up cap work.
 
Many players playing up grades for experience this year. Galvin, Lauilili, Fainu, Miller. A few players dropped and told to move on Naden, Sullivan. Papalli and Uto leaving. Let’s hope the moves made to get experience and free up cap work.
Other clubs have players playing up a grade too. The issue is we haven't recruited players with speed or power for many years. We have the slowest team in every grade. And we lose n every grade. There is no production line of talent as there is no identification of talent.
We have just been an unprofessional mess, it doesn't matter who was making the decisions, every one of them got the decisions wrong
 
Many players playing up grades for experience this year. Galvin, Lauilili, Fainu, Miller. A few players dropped and told to move on Naden, Sullivan. Papalli and Uto leaving. Let’s hope the moves made to get experience and free up cap work.
On a related note, it's why clubs like the Panthers and perhaps the Bulldogs (let's see them do it again next season but they were excellent across most grades) are so strong. Young players are learning in reserve grades there rather than being exposed to higher levels too early.
 
On a related note, it's why clubs like the Panthers and perhaps the Bulldogs (let's see them do it again next season but they were excellent across most grades) are so strong. Young players are learning in reserve grades there rather than being exposed to higher levels too early.
Having competition for spots and forcing players to play well and earn promotions is how you build a successful club. Gifting promotions makes players, current and future, feel more self entitled.
 
Yep. It's bad. But it's what you gotta do to reach critical mass for being a development club. The best of our juniors were playing NRL, hence the results. Those results are skewed by how many youngsters we had playing in our first grade side this season.

1999 was a pretty grim year for me as a young magpie fan in Campbelltown. That was an abysmal side. But it still contained two young players who would go on to win premierships and SOO etc. We still haven't played finals footy without Skando in the team. However, yea, that team finished last and ceased to exist.
 
With all the changes in personnel over the years, why is this a surprise? The good clubs are stable clubs, and have long-term plans.

WT are once again in Year 1 of the strategy having moved on from Madge's philosophies, to Sheens and McDonnell, then knifed both with Fulton, then decided after 7 months that he wasn't the right one either.

HBG need to stay out of football (board). Hire/maintain capable administrators, and provide them with the financial resources to do their job.

yes you are exactly right.

We are always in 'year 1' of someone's cunning plan. It's a very succinct way to put it.
 
Back
Top