Thoughts on Lui
- Thread starter happy_tiger
- Start date
A
alien
Guest
lui and moltzen had average games. moltzen hasnt shown much this year because he has been out of position most of the year. lui hasnt shown much this year because he hasnt been up to firstgrade standard
MacDougall
New member
When has Moltzen shown that he is a better option at halfback than Lui, except for 2 years ago?
Balmain_Bug
New member
Lui played well. He is our best option.
M
micko2521
Guest
CHRIST!!!! We win and yet most ppl still whinge and wine!!! Wish you'd all piss off to the rabbitohs
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
benjibrotown
New member
His kicking game was great tonight, in fact it was probably our best kicking game of the year due to him. He is our best option.
A
alien
Guest
@MacDougall said:
when he has been allowed to play in the halves with benji. we have won most games when that has happened
MacDougall
New member
When Moltzen has been given the halfback role alongside Benji this season, he has been poor. Lui has been slightly less poor. Lui was very good in our great season last year. Moltzen was excellent the season before. Lui is still ahead imo.
But, you are absolutely entitled to your opinion, and at times I have lost faith in Lui too. This game redeemed him for now in my eyes.
But, you are absolutely entitled to your opinion, and at times I have lost faith in Lui too. This game redeemed him for now in my eyes.
innsaneink
Well-known member
@micko252 said:
People see more than just the score.
Imo hes never going to be a half, sheens will stubbornly persist with him much like Morris
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
@micko252 said:
every set of supporters whinge
i don't know why people have this attitude of 'go follow the rabbitohs' if they are gonna whinge,as if saying rabbitohs fans have a reputation for whinging more then others
so wat,do you think tigers fans are above that or something?
:crazy
M
micko2521
Guest
Gnr4life all u do on here is whinge!! I've never read a post nor comment from you that was supportive!! No I'm not saying where above anyone so as to your comment I typed rabbitohs as they where the first that popped in my head. I'm sick of seeing u hijack every post with your snide and sinister remarks!! U and alot of others on here to be fair!! FFS do u love or hate the tigers? Coz all I read is hate
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
bigsiro
Well-known member
@benjibrotown said:
I watched his game closely and he had one good kick tonight. ONE.
The other good kicks came from Benji and Robbie.
IMO if you are pleased with Lui at half then what you are saying is either:
1 - "he's our best option" - That's sad. Firstly, he is not. Secondly, we shouldn't settle.
2 - "he's a good halfback" - He is not. Evidenced by our cheering if he gets through 20 minutes mistake-free.
3 - "he's got potential" - Maybe. But we've waited long enough and he's still below par.
Regarding potential, I support giving the young guns a go, but once they've had their chance and failed then….to borrow a quote - “Waiting is a trap. There will always be reasons to wait. The truth is, there are only two things in life, reasons and results, and reasons simply don't count.”
Disagree all you like, but don't call me disloyal or a Rabbitohs fan just because I refuse to settle for mediocrity.
I've said it before, I'd rather have no halfback at all than Lui. Worst case, put another centre or winger in, at least they will run off Benj/Robbie effectively and won't trick the rest of the team into thinking there is another genuine playmaker out there!
Sad thing for me (and all that agree) is, that it doesn't matter how much we may rant and rave on these forums, Lui will keep getting picked. http://www.weststigersforum.com/forum/posting.php?mode=quote&f=68&p=205165&time=1310828101#
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
@micko252 said:
do you know what hijacking a thread means? it means you use that thread as a tool to rant about something totaly off-topic.I'm sure considering i do this on every thread, you won't have any trouble giving me an eaxmple of this?
M
micko2521
Guest
GNR4LIFE 10.38pm Sun 10 Jul
what about after the Warriors game when they were stranded in Auckland,and they come out and said that being stranded was a 'blessing in disguise' and it brought them 'closer together',and will have a positive affect? pfft all talk and no action
\
\
\
\
\
\
Yeah really positive
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
what about after the Warriors game when they were stranded in Auckland,and they come out and said that being stranded was a 'blessing in disguise' and it brought them 'closer together',and will have a positive affect? pfft all talk and no action
\
\
\
\
\
\
Yeah really positive
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
WestsSupporter
New member
He is improving with each game. Those people bagging on him after tonight probably didn't watch the entire game. I'm sure Tim Sheens knows a little more about coaching than 90% of us do. Its common knowledge that if you mess someone around, their performance will be messed around. Shuffling Miller and Lui about would not do any good.
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
@micko252 said:
if memory serves,that was in a thread in regards to Robbie Farah coming out saying that their season started against Parra and that the time was now to make a move.I was simply giving an example of how in the past saying something like that didn't neccessarily mean much.Hardly consider that 'hijacking' a thread
FAIL
Tigerdave
Well-known member
still not really happy with his game, it was improved, let's see if that continues on
