Time For Benji Marshall to Retire

[happy_tiger]

With you saying that and admitting that you know what the consequence will be when religion or politics are introduced into any debate, then why do you allow it to happen??? Why isn't the very first mention of religion or politics deleted there and then? You as an adjudicator having the button at your fingertips to do just that should, no, 'must' realise the door is flung wide open to all sorts of garbage and insults being flung around from that very 1st post containing that inflammatory word or comment.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with 'constructive' criticism as this post is, so I reckon it's about time you adjudicators learned the difference between constructive and inflammatory.
Personally, I doubt you will actually do that as on this occasion Kul was the 1st person to introduce an inflammatory word to the debate.
As I said in a previous post, it's time you adjudicators cleaned up your act.

Because leeway is generally given up until a point when it becomes sesame street is why..like this thread..

If I've told you once I've told you a thousand times .....don't talk to Mr Snuffleupagas Geo

 

[happy_tiger]

Ok that's it Posts that have Nothing to do with Benji have been deleted...

Only 174 days till 2020 kicks off..thank goodness..

So only 175 days until we can start planning for 2021. Sorry stuck a t home with sick wife and kids has this pessimist coming out in me.

Wait until the kids become pessimists at the thought of the WT's as well ...gets pretty funny then

You mock them whether they are winning or losing

 

[watersider]

Benji critics?

 

[momo_amp_medo]

Benji critics?

Hiding under their rocks mate!

 

[Tweed_Tiger]

would have to be the best value player in the NRL

 

[earl]

@watersider I reckon value for money he is our best player. He has been one of our best all year. His worst performance was against the Dogs and he set-up a try that if Momo kicked it the game would have been even.

 

[watersider]

@watersider I reckon value for money he is our best player. He has been one of our best all year. His worst performance was against the Dogs and he set-up a try that if Momo kicked it the game would have been even.

Even tonight I thought it was hilarious him playing hooker and still playing Benji football, was brilliant to watch. He's the most exciting player I've ever seen and this has been a brilliant year for him, probably his second best ever. Nowhere near as fast but great control on his passing, exceptional kicking game and real leadership in directing the team. He's finally learnt how to play halfback.

 

[earl]

@watersider I can't believe how good he has been. He could fill in at hooker next year no problems but he is also so good in the halves.

 

[Geo]

@watersider I can't believe how good he has been. He could fill in at hooker next year no problems but he is also so good in the halves.

I believe the week to week grind of the position would take it's toll..

It was a masterstroke by Madge for this game...teams would soon work it out...

 

[happy_tiger]

@watersider I can't believe how good he has been. He could fill in at hooker next year no problems but he is also so good in the halves.

I believe the week to week grind of the position would take it's toll..

It was a masterstroke by Madge for this game...teams would soon work it out...

Excussssssssssssse me

He read my post from the last 2 weeks and decided I was right ...again ....

 

[Geo]

@watersider I can't believe how good he has been. He could fill in at hooker next year no problems but he is also so good in the halves.

I believe the week to week grind of the position would take it's toll..

It was a masterstroke by Madge for this game...teams would soon work it out...

Excussssssssssssse me

He read my post from the last 2 weeks and decided I was right ...again ....

lol...no

 

[happy_tiger]

@watersider I can't believe how good he has been. He could fill in at hooker next year no problems but he is also so good in the halves.

I believe the week to week grind of the position would take it's toll..

It was a masterstroke by Madge for this game...teams would soon work it out...

Excussssssssssssse me

He read my post from the last 2 weeks and decided I was right ...again ....

lol...no

You know he did .....every was bagging me left right and centre

But when I'm right ...I'm right again

OK .......Grouch

 

[Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan]

Mods please close this thread. I am absolutely charged up and I have decided I love Benji again. Benji is my hero I only started supporting the Tigers because of him.

Had a special bottle saved up if we ever had a win like this. I am so happy. The last time I was able to celebrate like this was our win in round 2 against Melbourne last year. Actually got 2 celebrations in 2 weeks last year thanks to Thompson and Lolohea vs Roosters!

LEGIT! This game proves Benji has shelved his ego. He clearly went to Madge during the week and said "What do you have? Any idea, let me know. If I think it's good, I'll support it." and that's how we got to 30 minutes of Benji at dummy half. This game...wow Benji. Idk man...I love you. I'm probably gonna cry for 8 hours when you retire. I cried for 3 hours when you signed to return. Gonna be tough.

 

[jadtiger]

It was a great performance from Benji but it dosent alter my opinion that it is time for him to retire.Age is an unrelenting foe despite Benji trying to hold it back

 

[boonboon]

How good has Benji been and surprisingly for a older player his 2nd half of the season has been even better

He has played 18 games
First 9 - 5 try assists, 1 line break, 4 line break assists and 6 tackle breaks, 1 try, 3 offloads,
Back 9 - 13 try assists, 4 line breaks, 12 line break assists, 16 Tackle breaks, 2 tries, 6 offloads

I would go as far as to say him and Brooks have been the form halves combination of the 2nd half of the season

 

[Madge]

@boonboon 😳😳😳😳

 

[Geo]

Going round again announcement expected this week..

 

[cochise]

Going round again announcement expected this week..

Good, he deserves another year!

 

[rex2ce]

@cochise Benji has still got “it” the team aren’t carrying him

 

[Tiger_Steve]

It was a great performance from Benji but it dosent alter my opinion that it is time for him to retire.Age is an unrelenting foe despite Benji trying to hold it back

Gallen says hello