simonthetiger
New member
@Balmain Bug said:
Do you get tired of trolling,or is this really you?.
I really can't tell.
Either way it's just sooooooo boring,
Tom Fumble
- Thread starter AmericanHistoryX
- Start date
Do you get tired of trolling,or is this really you?.
I really can't tell.
Either way it's just sooooooo boring,
S
system
Guest
Click his profile, click add foe and you don't have to read his inane drivel anymore.
Certainly made my forum experience richer
Certainly made my forum experience richer
citizen_cub
New member
Don't know why you want to crucify him for one error, doubts over whether it was a knock on anyway. You can't put it down to individual errors, we just didn't capitalise despite abundant chances to score and our defence was weak defending our own line, as you'd expect early in the season. That's what cost us victory.
I think he's been great in the 2 games he's played so far, a great reflection on the depth at the club currently, Tedesco gets injured, so Humble steps up and fills the void and performs well and if he gets injured by any small chance, John Grant comes in.
I think he's been great in the 2 games he's played so far, a great reflection on the depth at the club currently, Tedesco gets injured, so Humble steps up and fills the void and performs well and if he gets injured by any small chance, John Grant comes in.
simonthetiger
New member
@smeghead said:
I would do it,but I would hate bb spreading rubbish, and no one refuting it.
Can we foe him en masse?
southerntiger
New member
Simon,
This is the guy who said Gallant would play origin, that Gower would make us pay at the Dragons and that Moltz is clearly and unequivocally the best 7 at the club. He is the worst judge of footballer i have ever seen. And now his creme de la creme, the fact that Jake Mullaney scored 4 tries against one of the worst west sides in history (and that is saying something). The amazing things is that keeps coming back even though he is batting 0%.
This is the guy who said Gallant would play origin, that Gower would make us pay at the Dragons and that Moltz is clearly and unequivocally the best 7 at the club. He is the worst judge of footballer i have ever seen. And now his creme de la creme, the fact that Jake Mullaney scored 4 tries against one of the worst west sides in history (and that is saying something). The amazing things is that keeps coming back even though he is batting 0%.
simonthetiger
New member
@southerntiger said:
Thanks ST.
Its his awful calls that makes me REALLY think he is some disgruntled Souths fan that just wants to stir the pot.
He has little knowledge of form or our players….. It's confusing.
Balmain_Bug
New member
Im a Humble fan. But for the life if me I could never understand why WT never offered Mullany a contract but they offered Humble one.
Mullany was treated poorly by WT for no reason. He is a better player than Humble.
Tick foe and dont read my drivel. LOL !!! I dont write it for you people. You are giving yourselves a wrap.
\
\
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
Mullany was treated poorly by WT for no reason. He is a better player than Humble.
Tick foe and dont read my drivel. LOL !!! I dont write it for you people. You are giving yourselves a wrap.
\
\
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
Balmain_Bug
New member
Gallant was treated poorly by Sheens. He turned our 2009 Season around.
Pity he has succomb to injury.
Dont verbal me on the other issues.
Behave yourselves.
\
\
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
Pity he has succomb to injury.
Dont verbal me on the other issues.
Behave yourselves.
\
\
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
king_sirro
Well-known member
Im a fan of Humble and believe he is a genuine first grader. I just cant work out what his best position would be. I think he can handle fulback but is better suited in the front line as a halfback, 5/8 or even hooker
Balmain_Bug
New member
Southern Tiger why do you call Wests Magpies one of the worst sides in history ? That is a disgraceful comment by you . The team has no support by Wests Tigers what so ever. How can they compete ?
You are a disgrace. How dare you.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
You are a disgrace. How dare you.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
southerntiger
New member
KS he is perfect as a number 14 that Sheens always wants have in his side (wrong or rightly). I agree what you are saying about the frontline. He certainly looks sharper than Moltz.
BB you have made it your mission to criticise Sheens for 4 years. Yet, every player you said he should have picked (I forgot about Pritchard) has done nothing at other clubs. If you cant handle being criticised back for your views then perhaps you shouldnt criticise others.
Re Mullaney, any who watched Balmain games last year said he wasnt delivering and werent surprised he was let go. Unlike Humble, Mullaney can also only play one position which means he was never going to have the value that Sheens likes in fringe first graders.
BB you have made it your mission to criticise Sheens for 4 years. Yet, every player you said he should have picked (I forgot about Pritchard) has done nothing at other clubs. If you cant handle being criticised back for your views then perhaps you shouldnt criticise others.
Re Mullaney, any who watched Balmain games last year said he wasnt delivering and werent surprised he was let go. Unlike Humble, Mullaney can also only play one position which means he was never going to have the value that Sheens likes in fringe first graders.
southerntiger
New member
@Balmain Bug said:
I said one of the worst Wests sides in history. Unfortunately, on paper this side is very poor and to be honest they are out of their depth. I stand by that view and dont consider it a disgrace. Whatever the reasons for it are irrelevant. Mullaney scored 4 tries against a side that would struggle against a park football team.
simonthetiger
New member
@king sirro said:
Agreed, he looks a very good 6/7 to me.
I really am starting to think that Moltz may go back to one and Humble to halves.
Tedesco getting injured really has thrown a spanner in the works.
hybrid_tiger
Well-known member
Bug if Mullaney is so good why didn't he play first grade for Parramatta last week when Hayne was out?
Why isn't he playing first grade this week?
The reason he was let go is because Tedesco is far better. Tedesco's injury will cripple us this year.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
Why isn't he playing first grade this week?
The reason he was let go is because Tedesco is far better. Tedesco's injury will cripple us this year.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
simonthetiger
New member
x2
bonstonker
New member
@Balmain Bug said:
i agree that he was great when he got his chance in 09.
but what denied him from playing more football at the end of 09.
injury.
what now,injury.
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
If you look at what hurt our charge in 09 the most, it was when Gallant got injured against the Roosters. As soon as he got injured, it messed up our structure which had been settled and firing. After that Moltzen moved back to 1 and Lui was thrown in when he wasn't yet ready. Gallant was realy was unlucky to have gotten injured when he did. If he hadn't, who knows what could have happened
G
Guest
Guest
@simonthetiger said:
I agree, I thought he looked dangerous up in the front line late in the game. I'd even be open to having Tuqiri and Koroibete on the wings this year and shift Ryan to fullback if Humble fails to make it his own. I think Humble does offer good utility value off the bench.
happy_tiger
Well-known member
@willow said:
Willow really like the idea of Ryan going back to fullback once Lote is back and firing
1 Ryan
2 Lote
3 Lawrence
4 Ayshford
5 Reddy
6 Benji
7 Moltzen or Miller or Humble
8 Keefy
9 Farah
10 Woods
11 Blair
12 Ellis
13 Rhino
14 BMM
15 Groat
16 Bell
17 Fulton