LIVE GAME vs Sharks *SPOILERS*

Live Game Discussion
Something has to change what was dished up today was utter rubbish, Madge should go and Brooks should go at a minimum. Brooks has been moping all season Madge has no idea what to do we’ve gone backwards at a rate of knots.

Bring in Morris or someone fresh get Hastings and Madden in the halves till Doueihi is back and firing. That was just a joke today I’m guessing Ken wasn’t meant to play but with Laurie out maybe he had to because he was on meth or injured.
 
Worked today so just watched the game on Kayo (as an aside, the commentary was so annoying).
We were just awful and very disappointing to watch for the most part. All the effort areas that I’d seen in earlier rounds were gone and we took a big step backwards.
They really looked dejected and broken today.
Looking through the team- some of the performances worth mentioning.....
Toa is not an NRL fullback and showed nothing to make me see him as deserving of a starting spot anywhere.
Mamualo was terrible today. Showed no effort at anything he did all game. Seriously needs to be looked at.
Noffa wasn’t much better and is not putting in at all.
Gildart can not defend at all and was once again responsible for a number of tries. At least Garner made tackles at centre.
Madden was very poor and I don’t think he executed one thing properly. His kicking was off, his D was crap, his passing was misdirected. He has played the dominant half role the last 2 weeks and sorry to say but we have looked worse.
Brooks has either lost all his confidence or has accepted a backseat role. He no longer looks like he wants to play. Once AD is back I suspect he will leave the club.
Our forwards, especially our middles are just too soft to get us any momentum. They have little fight and look like they are just hanging on most of the time.
Basic stuff is killing us. We refuse to chase kicks, we can’t catch or pass, there is no movement off the ball, no players in motion, no runners. Our dummy half is rubbish. There is no kick pressure. We can’t count numbers in D. We backpedal 10 metres out from our own line for god sake!!!!
The list goes on.....
 
Worked today so just watched the game on Kayo (as an aside, the commentary was so annoying).
We were just awful and very disappointing to watch for the most part. All the effort areas that I’d seen in earlier rounds were gone and we took a big step backwards.
They really looked dejected and broken today.
Looking through the team- some of the performances worth mentioning.....
Toa is not an NRL fullback and showed nothing to make me see him as deserving of a starting spot anywhere.
Mamualo was terrible today. Showed no effort at anything he did all game. Seriously needs to be looked at.
Noffa wasn’t much better and is not putting in at all.
Gildart can not defend at all and was once again responsible for a number of tries. At least Garner made tackles at centre.
Madden was very poor and I don’t think he executed one thing properly. His kicking was off, his D was crap, his passing was misdirected. He has played the dominant half role the last 2 weeks and sorry to say but we have looked worse.
Brooks has either lost all his confidence or has accepted a backseat role. He no longer looks like he wants to play. Once AD is back I suspect he will leave the club.
Our forwards, especially our middles are just too soft to get us any momentum. They have little fight and look like they are just hanging on most of the time.
Basic stuff is killing us. We refuse to chase kicks, we can’t catch or pass, there is no movement off the ball, no players in motion, no runners. Our dummy half is rubbish. There is no kick pressure. We can’t count numbers in D. We backpedal 10 metres out from our own line for god sake!!!!
The list goes on.....
It’s sad
 
Joffa 2023 has a mutual option...
He may look for a deal elsewhere as he has a few years left in his career.

Doubt he'll want to waste em trying to carry out team each week.

I've said it a few times but I'm very certain.... our team is in a very bad place.
This is the worst it's been in 10 years and it's on par with 2001 to 2003 sides. We just don't look like winning. All Joffa will need is a offer from another club and he will go that's how bad it is.
 
I just listened to the press conference l don't know who is kidding them self the most madge or tamou the only way out is buy first graders not many here and to think they get paid the same as good players,wonder what price to not win a game all year good chance.
 
It is not the loss, it is the loss in detail. We look like a team that is poorly coached, playing as individuals and lacking the fundamentals as was commented on by Fittler and Johns. Maguire must go tonight.
Our halfback is one of the worst at the moment in the competition he should be controlling the game and trying to mount pressure. Madden has shown that at least he is trying to get things going and his kicking game is far superior. Brooks shows no urgency and it is obvious he wants out, put Madden and Hastings in the halves next week. Fiddler and Johns need to have a hard look at our roster, Jesus Christ couldn't transform them, 70% of them are reserve graders.
 
I just listened to the press conference l don't know who is kidding them self the most madge or tamou the only way out is buy first graders not many here and to think they get paid the same as good players,wonder what price to not win a game all year good chance.
How had was Tamou and his, "back at Penrith
..." garbage.

Thanks. We know. You'd rather be at Penrith. Same as Blore & Laurie. 😂

Madges nonsense also, rinse / repeat.... no accountability. As Hastings said, "Madge will always defend thr players." I'd rather see him take aim and pull people up for their behaviour and performances.
 
This is the worst it's been in 10 years and it's on par with 2001 to 2003 sides. We just don't look like winning. All Joffa will need is a offer from another club and he will go that's how bad it is.
I can't see Joffa sticking around.

The offers will come.
I'm sure he'd rather be back in QLD also and with Wayne & the dolphins- I can see that happening.

I fully expect to see Luciano, Kelma, Garner, Tamou, Offa, Mikaele - all leave and we don't sign anyone and we're even worse off next year.

Daunting, to be honest.
 
Our halfback is one of the worst at the moment in the competition he should be controlling the game and trying to mount pressure. Madden has shown that at least he is trying to get things going and his kicking game is far superior. Brooks shows no urgency and it is obvious he wants out, put Madden and Hastings in the halves next week. Fiddler and Johns need to have a hard look at our roster, Jesus Christ couldn't transform them, 70% of them are reserve graders.
None of our players demonstrated urgency and all have regressed. LL had a good game yesterday but even he has been poor previously. Time to ask the hard questions as to why even our more experienced players have regressed.
 
Even the pitch invader had more flare than the tigers yesterday
The poor guy was probably a frustrated tigers fan & he was just trying to spark something with his flare
💥 🏃‍♂️ 😂
 
I just listened to the press conference l don't know who is kidding them self the most madge or tamou the only way out is buy first graders not many here and to think they get paid the same as good players,wonder what price to not win a game all year good chance.
$29 to not win a game.
 
We got some tankers right now it's obvious.
Twal is tanking out there Mitchell Moses style.
Madge has lost them and they showing it
 
Was at the game with 3 other Cronulla supporters

You know your team is bad when even the opposition teams fans don’t enjoy giving you stick anymore. This team is just like a helpless punching bag

We are so slow across the park, no urgency, looked super flat all game…they don’t even look like they want to be there.
The team looked lethargic in the warm up.
 
I feel really embarrassed and strange watching them, hard to explain... It's cringe worthy... I don't watch them anymore
I turn them off at half time, In the past when I have done that ( rarely ) I would sneak a peak. Not this time. Just could not take the pain anymore. Brooks forward pass on the 3rd in the attacking zone just left me so dumbfounded. It was not just a few inches, it was blatant. I feel very sorry for him, but he is now hopeless and needs to go for his own good and mental wellbeing.
 
I can't see Joffa sticking around.

The offers will come.
I'm sure he'd rather be back in QLD also and with Wayne & the dolphins- I can see that happening.

I fully expect to see Luciano, Kelma, Garner, Tamou, Offa, Mikaele - all leave and we don't sign anyone and we're even worse off next year.

Daunting, to be honest.

Chin up man a week later and everyone is getting 5 year extensions
 
The old saying comes to mind "a week in rugby league is a long time"...
Reading most of these posts everybody wanted 1/2 the team and Madge gone....
We beat EELs with Hastings back in and some decent direction and control.well blow me down we are only about 2/4 points out of the 8 and its celebration time....
People have to trust in Madge and his plans,they dont just happen overnight...
Could be a lesson well learnt......👍👍👍👍
 

Latest posts

Back
Top