West Tigers forum Best Ever 17 : Wingers.

R

Robster

New member
Okay guys : <big>**YOU CAN VOTE TWICE**</big>

Taniela Tuiaki (78 Games)
Lote Tuquri (52 Games)
Matt Utai (40 Games)
Marika Korobeite (16 games, really?)
Beau Ryan (104) Games
Pat Richards (59 Games)
Daniel Fitzhenry (137 Games)
Nick Bradley-Qalilawa (27 Games)
Luke Covell (22 Games)
Jason Moodie (37 Games)
\
\
Please only vote if you have knowledge of all the nominations.
 
Good list of wingers,Tuiaki for my vote because of his devastating runs and his ability to get over the line with his strength and power…
 
Tuiaki for sure, what a beast.

Really wish we could have saw Tui & Lote play at the same time.
Would've been great.
 
:wtf
Koro. with under 20 games, yet no Nofo?

From that list, and picking a left and right winger without Nofo as an option, I have gone for Tuiaki and Ryan.
 
@formerguest said:
:wtf
Koro. with under 20 games, yet no Nofo?

From that list, and picking a left and right winger without Nofo as an option, I have gone for Tuiaki and Ryan.
Click to expand...

Stupid me, read the OPs list and did not look at the vote section properly. Should have voted other for Nofo, who should be on the list?
 
richards and tuiaki are definately top two imo.

always reckoned that richards was very unlucky not to have played soo in 2005\. still love the face plant fend on the cowboys winger when scoring THAT try
 
@Blackpearl said:
richards and tuiaki are definately top two imo.

always reckoned that richards was very unlucky not to have played soo in 2005\. still love the face plant fend on the cowboys winger when scoring THAT try
Click to expand...

The most unbelievable play EVER!!!

Peeps rightly go on about Bunji there, but man Pattycake had some work to do and didnt he just nail it….pretty much on one leg too.
 
Tuiaki and Richards no brainer.

The Forgotten Fend - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hTKOSLLJFTk
 
Tuiaki and Fitzhenry….

No one can march Fitzy's record of a Try in a World 7's Final, NRL GF and World Club challenge...
 
Well out of that lot I'd have to pick Jason Moodie and Nick BQ - champions!

But seriously, I'd have Tuiaki and I'm with Geo in choosing Fitzy, as well. Fitzy gets a bum wrap from us supporters. As a utility he could drive fans to drink, but there is no doubt in my mind that he was a great winger. His try scoring ability far outweighs the rest on that list. As such, he just edges out Richards in my selections.

Gotta ask though - where is Nofoaluma? Since it was a minimum of 20 games played, I'm assuming the OP accidentally put Koro on the list instead of Nofo.
 
If anyone would to take of this please pm me.. I'm a Warriors fan so maybe a tiger fan could help running these polls. Please remember there is a the "other' option.
 
@Robster said:
If anyone would to take of this please pm me.. I'm a Warriors fan so maybe a tiger fan could help running these polls. Please remember there is a the "other' option.
Click to expand...

I nominate Foreveratiger ,,, he loves this stuff lol

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.1.5_
 
We have never had any really good wingers, a lot of those guys are decent, but over 15 years you'd think we would have a couple of rep players at some point
 
@hobbo2803 said:
@Robster said:
If anyone would to take of this please pm me.. I'm a Warriors fan so maybe a tiger fan could help running these polls. Please remember there is a the "other' option.

I nominate Foreveratiger ,,, he loves this stuff lol

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.1.5_
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

I second that nomination, he's got heaps going on already, but I'm sure he could squeeze one more in :laughing:

Thanks for bringing the idea to us, Robster and for getting it kicked off, especially during a dull off season.
 
@Robster said:
If anyone would to take of this please pm me.. I'm a Warriors fan so maybe a tiger fan could help running these polls. Please remember there is a the "other' option.
Click to expand...

If you use the appearances off of this list as a guide i think youll be better off, top 10 to 20?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Wests_Tigers_players
 
This is the list of all Wingers and the amount of games they played for us, well those who have played on the wing at some stage to be exact.
\
\
Lawrence – 153
Fitzhenry - 137
Ryan – 104
Tuiaki – 78
Richards – 59
Elford – 59
Tuqiri – 52
Carlaw - 41
Utai – 40
Brown – 40
Simona – 38
Mc Donnell - 31
Moodie – 31
Nofoaluma – 30
Salah – 30
Tedesco – 28
Hopoate - 28
Miles -28
Bradley-Qalilawa - 27
Reddy – 27
Kaufusi/Richter - 24
Collis – 24
Lolesi -22
Covell - 22
Koroibete – 16
Daniela – 15
Lulia -12
Meaney – 10
Viane - 9
Bajouri - 9
Crocket – 8
Rowe – 8
Tagive – 8
Clayton - 7
Rieck – 6
Hitchcox - 4
Cupples - 4
Beckett – 4
Jeffery – 3
Latu – 2
Duffy – 2
Milford - 1
Milton – 1
 
No hoppa on the list.
Despite his obvious issues, he was probably our best performed winger.
He was a terrific metre eater.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

... and 40 more.
Total: 1,088 (members: 90, guests: 998)
Back
Top