Wests Tigers v Penrith Rd 16 live game discussion

[bigsiro]

42/58 possession
3-6 penalties
1-6 restarts

No chance of winning with those stats.

Honestly the refereeing we have copped this year has been so one eyed it’s disgusting. This game has to be up their as one of the worst. I get the NRL want the panthers to succeed , but not to this extent.

One eyed broncos fans blame the refs too.
Give me a break. We suck!

 

[cktiger]

Why dont the tigers jump all over each other after games like the panthers do? The panthers will still be jumping all over themselves in the carpark.

Because they’re all related there.

 

[Moh]

So much arrogance about Penrith.

Tyrone May is a cat.

 

[BAGNF05]

Wow I’ve never seen us with so many metres after contact, and all in reverse. Until we get some grunt it ain’t worth pulling on the boots.

 

[jadtiger]

Like I say every week, our halves are just so bad. Probably the worst in the competition

They were poor no doubt about it

 

[Strider]

Why are people blasting Benji? Did you not see our forwards absolutely out classed? It's like the old days, small forwards except we don't have the speed we used to. Tommy was our worst player clearly. Surely you can't say anyone was worse than Tommy?

 

[cktiger]

42/58 possession
3-6 penalties
1-6 restarts

No chance of winning with those stats.

Honestly the refereeing we have copped this year has been so one eyed it’s disgusting. This game has to be up their as one of the worst. I get the NRL want the panthers to succeed , but not to this extent.

One eyed broncos fans blame the refs too.
Give me a break. We suck!

We suck - but he’s right ... no chance with all the calls going one way.

 

[Geo]

42/58 possession
3-6 penalties
1-6 restarts

No chance of winning with those stats.

We also didn't have a forward crack 100m..

 

[851]

Our 5th tackle options are embarrassing, our halves are bog average, we need 2 new ones ASAP

I think it would be better to score on earlier tackles..

You may be on to something, you know it is blatantly obvious if Braith can point it out, and he said our 5th tackles options were just not good enough

 

[cktiger]

Why are people blasting Benji? Did you not see our forwards absolutely out classed? It's like the old days, small forwards except we don't have the speed we used to. Tommy was our worst player clearly. Surely you can't say anyone was worse than Tommy?

Brooks was worse

 

[the_third]

Some say the coach
Some say the halves

We have had the halves for longer...

I hate Penrith - at least this showed how to beat them if you have the cattle. Melbourne and roaster can roast these muppets in the finals.

Niggle them and they will fall apart if you have the talent.

 

[The_Return]

Doueihi having a shocker.

Who isn't?

Surely you have to praise the effort. Aren't we the bravest of all the inept and physically weak NRL clubs.?

Meh. We are a training run for good teams.

We are less than that. Getting close to an all time low. Although some think the forum and the fans are the problem.

Good question.

Is this the worst Tigers team to be put on the park since 2003??

Yes it is, but we don’t have a young Benji, Robbie, Fulton and Gibbs coming through to change it.

Yeah, the good old days when we had the Tiger Cubs in waiting. Im sure the stellar recruitment people at the Tigers are all over the next batch of kids. :face_with_rolling_eyes:

 

[tiger05premier]

Hardly ever get to watch our games as I work weekends

But 2 things

Eiso cops a hiding on here but if everyone in our team had his heart we would be right up there

At least he tried

Plays to his limits unlike the majority

McIntyre should be number 13

 

[tigerbill]

Same players make the same brain dead decisions each week.Benji and BJ leading the half wit brigade

Lol, everyone including the commentators say that Benji was hard done and yet you persist. If you think Benji was the problem you should watch a bit more NRL.

You keep on defending Benji but he was terrible.He did one good kick and the rest of his game was bilge.I have been an avid supporter since blokes like Raper Beetson Barnes and Kelly were playing so i would say i have watched enough rugby league not just NRL to know what i am talking about.
If you think Ginane and Anasta are good judges it explains a lot

You genuinely think that was a high tackle that deserved a penalty? Yes or no?

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Heard a rumour that the Dogs want Curtis Scott. Canberra will release him if they can have Joey back. Who wants to drive him?

 

[TonyTiger]

Mcguire press conference.
Really proud of our effort out there tonight....blah blah blah
Playing the No 1 team shows we are worthy to be higher on the ladder than what we are. Blah Blah Blah
Came down to key moments blah blah blah
We are still a chance of making the 8. Blah Blah Blah

Summary as i see it.
Many mistakes from back 3 - Mainly AD/TT how many times on 1st tackle running into opposition we lose the ball.
Half's nothing plays again this week.
Overall tried but out classed.

I think we really tried hard tonight but Brooks and Marshall has NO options at the end of each set plus Talau is an absolute embarrassment - can’t catch, can’t tackle, can’t hold the ball, can’t stay in his feet, can’t play the ball! I don’t care about his Dad’s reputation, we can’t carry this guy any longer.
McIntyre was absolutely awesome again tonight.

 

[Geo]

Our 5th tackle options are embarrassing, our halves are bog average, we need 2 new ones ASAP

I think it would be better to score on earlier tackles..

You may be on to something, you know it is blatantly obvious if Braith can point it out, and he said our 5th tackles options were just not good enough

I think Benji tried that when he kicked on he 3rd

 

[Tigerbuck63]

Benji runs behind his own player.... Penalty
His last play and brooks last play options kill us.

We have had not 1 tackle in their 20. It limits what your halves can do.


Mate you sound like your on the Tigers payroll.
I call it as i see it - another dumb play by Benji (Retire)

We. don't have the players. I'm a realist. The Panthers play an ttackkng offensive style and referees reward that positivity. Our style is limited by our roster. I mean not one tackle in their 20.

Agree we don't have the current Rosters
Starting to hope the panthers fall over in the finals.
They are so full of themselves but a good team.

Game 1 - loss / Game 2 - loss - Bundled Out

 

[Snake]

Next year is going to be a massive disaster if 2 new halves are not found .. the team is completely rudderless!

 

[The_Return]

Why are people blasting Benji? Did you not see our forwards absolutely out classed? It's like the old days, small forwards except we don't have the speed we used to. Tommy was our worst player clearly. Surely you can't say anyone was worse than Tommy?

They are probably bagging him because of his woeful defence, hospital passes and pathetic 5th tackle options? Just a thought