What’s happened to Josh ALOIAI..

[avocadoontoast]

Cleary is picking the team on form. Rockow is the only forward you might think of relegating, but he has been there from game one and really is getting a job done for Cleary and I dont think his stats reflect his value to the team.

The ball is in Josh's court as we all know he could be anything

I think Rochow started the season well but I think his form has dropped off the last few weeks. And he misses way too many tackles.

 

[mctiger]

Cleary is picking the team on form. Rockow is the only forward you might think of relegating, but he has been there from game one and really is getting a job done for Cleary and I dont think his stats reflect his value to the team.

The ball is in Josh's court as we all know he could be anything

I think Rochow started the season well but I think his form has dropped off the last few weeks. And he misses way too many tackles.

You are correct regarding Rochow. So far this year he has made 291 tackles (teams second best) but missed….46! Compare to Eisenhuth 336/15, Matulino 244/14 and Twal 228/5.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nrl-premiership/stats/players?teamId=55014&sortBy=missedTackles

 

[balmain boy]

Nothing.

Thats the problem.

He's the same player he was 2 years ago. Hasn't improved. Can run well, but is unfit, very inconsistent and makes a lot of mistakes.

 

[Snake]

Will his Bus ticket be cancelled?

 

[Russell]

Cleary is picking the team on form. Rockow is the only forward you might think of relegating, but he has been there from game one and really is getting a job done for Cleary and I dont think his stats reflect his value to the team.

The ball is in Josh's court as we all know he could be anything

I think Rochow started the season well but I think his form has dropped off the last few weeks. And he misses way too many tackles.

You are correct regarding Rochow. So far this year he has made 291 tackles (teams second best) but missed….46! Compare to Eisenhuth 336/15, Matulino 244/14 and Twal 228/5.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nrl-premiership/stats/players?teamId=55014&sortBy=missedTackles

Yes, but there not the ones moving up and cutting the ball off, getting to the outside backs, are they?

 

[TIGER]

Now McQueen has been promoted to the bench in front of him.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Cleary is picking the team on form. Rockow is the only forward you might think of relegating, but he has been there from game one and really is getting a job done for Cleary and I dont think his stats reflect his value to the team.

The ball is in Josh's court as we all know he could be anything

I think Rochow started the season well but I think his form has dropped off the last few weeks. And he misses way too many tackles.

You are correct regarding Rochow. So far this year he has made 291 tackles (teams second best) but missed….46! Compare to Eisenhuth 336/15, Matulino 244/14 and Twal 228/5.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nrl-premiership/stats/players?teamId=55014&sortBy=missedTackles

Yes, but there not the ones moving up and cutting the ball off, getting to the outside backs, are they?

Are you implying that his missed tackles are a result of him defending on the edge rather than in the middle? If so, then why aren't Rowdy's missed tackles at that level (or any other second rower for that matter)?

 

[hsvjones]

He is our one of main forwards that actually dent the line… He needs to be in this team as Panthers forwards are just rolling over us with ease

 

[weststigers]

Cleary is picking the team on form. Rockow is the only forward you might think of relegating, but he has been there from game one and really is getting a job done for Cleary and I dont think his stats reflect his value to the team.

The ball is in Josh's court as we all know he could be anything

I think Rochow started the season well but I think his form has dropped off the last few weeks. And he misses way too many tackles.

You are correct regarding Rochow. So far this year he has made 291 tackles (teams second best) but missed….46! Compare to Eisenhuth 336/15, Matulino 244/14 and Twal 228/5.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nrl-premiership/stats/players?teamId=55014&sortBy=missedTackles

Wow…doesn't Matulino only play about 40 minutes a game? 244 vs 291 considering half the game time is a pretty good defence rate

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Nothing.

Thats the problem.

He's the same player he was 2 years ago. Hasn't improved. Can run well, but is unfit, very inconsistent and makes a lot of mistakes.

You can’t say he’s not fit. That complaint is exclusive to Tui bashers.

 

[joelw2002]

Could have been for a similar reason as Fonua? Discipline issues?
I just don't see how he can be dropped and not making the team over Sue and MCK.

It's not Sue or MCK he needs to replace, It's Rochow. MCK is just a beast and Sue has been playing well of late. Running it hard, making good metres, smashing people like how he smashed a rampaging Matt Scott running it straight at him in full flight and Sue was standing still and still smashed him and injured him. Rochow has just been piss poor.

 

[Nucky_Thompson]

Could have been for a similar reason as Fonua? Discipline issues?
I just don't see how he can be dropped and not making the team over Sue and MCK.

It's not Sue or MCK he needs to replace, It's Rochow. MCK is just a beast and Sue has been playing well of late. Running it hard, making good metres, smashing people like how he smashed a rampaging Matt Scott running it straight at him in full flight and Sue was standing still and still smashed him and injured him. Rochow has just been piss poor.

Not sure i agree with this.

Once the props rotate with twal and sue i always feel we are more likely to be scored against.

Im happy with twal there but we need another prop on the bench thats good with the same impact as packer and matalino.
\
\
Sue needs to go.