Who here actually supports Western Suburbs in the KOE NSW Cup?

I think it had more to do with it being closer to concord for training purposes than a wests vs Balmain decision
I agree, but what I did post regarding that was factual, yet some on here are attacking me without any evidence I was wrong....and I did state I'd support our KOE team wether it was branded as the Magpies or Wests Tigers. More than anything I was pointing out what Sheens did, and why it might just have irked Western Suburbs Macarthur.
 
I can only speak for myself.
I can only wave one flag. Do we need Dutton to sort it out?
Teams by their very nature are opposed to each other and that’s the way I see Magpies and Tigers. While I don’t mind if the Magpies win a string of GFs, it doesn’t change my body chemistry because they are not Wests Tigers.
 
We have had game plans?
you score 28 we score 30 is not a game plan.

Sheens stood up at a Pre 2005 Season Function (may have been the 04 GF Luncheon)
and stated exactly that...

To Paraphrase, His words were,
We're going to let in some points next year - But were also going to score plenty.
How'd that work out?

Your game plan is the only one the Tigers have ever had
- Only problem was, It didn't work without a Prime Benji - Ever
 
There are 10 NRL clubs which have a stand alone reserve grade team, but only one of those clubs insists on referring to its reserve grade team by another name.

The argument used to be the other way round....
Parra has Wenty, Roosters has the Jets, Rabbitohs has the Bears, Raiders has Mounties, Knights have the Centurions Yadda, Yadda, Yadda....

Slowly but surely, All those clubs realised they were shooting themselves in the foot by not having uniform Branding through the grades....

Yet still some here can find excuses.
 
The argument used to be the other way round....
Parra has Wenty, Roosters has the Jets, Rabbitohs has the Bears, Raiders has Mounties, Knights have the Centurions Yadda, Yadda, Yadda....

Slowly but surely, All those clubs realised they were shooting themselves in the foot by not having uniform Branding through the grades....

Yet still some here can find excuses.
How do I say this without hurting someone’s feelings or getting 10 in the bin? The evolutionary process has been slow for some p……s. 😂Got it! Just left off the last word.
 
Sheens stood up at a Pre 2005 Season Function (may have been the 04 GF Luncheon)
and stated exactly that...

To Paraphrase, His words were,
We're going to let in some points next year - But were also going to score plenty.
How'd that work out?

Your game plan is the only one the Tigers have ever had
- Only problem was, It didn't work without a Prime Benji - Ever
On the second time around Galvin was going to be the prime Benji. Sacking the coach not only stopped the process but also encouraged the second Benji to reassess dreams an aspirations.
 
We have had game plans?
you score 28 we score 30 is not a game plan.
I loved those scrum plays. Also the ruck speed up. The 1st graders had more than a year to develop the required level of teamwork. No reserve grader playing a different style of footy is going to pick it up in a couple of games. But of course a club with a record 18 spoons knows better than one with only 3.
 
On the second time around Galvin was going to be the prime Benji. Sacking the coach not only stopped the process but also encouraged the second Benji to reassess dreams an aspirations.

Na...
There's only ever been one Benji!!
Johnson was probably as close as anyone has (is likely to) come for a while yet.

Galvin is all effort (with the ball),
Benji was all skill and speed (skills at speed)
and it changed the game (For a moment)
 
Na...
There's only ever been one Benji!!
Johnson was probably as close as anyone has (is likely to) come for a while yet.

Galvin is all effort (with the ball),
Benji was all skill and speed (skills at speed)
and it changed the game (For a moment)
He was quick in the first half of his career kids following NRL were copying his sidestep for years lot of gloom on here for Benji at times B hope he succeeds going forward coaching tragedy if a club legend fails.
 
Na...
There's only ever been one Benji!!
Johnson was probably as close as anyone has (is likely to) come for a while yet.

Galvin is all effort (with the ball),
Benji was all skill and speed (skills at speed)
and it changed the game (For a moment)
In my mind, the closest playing style I’ve seen to Benji’s is Luai’s. The stand out (comparison wise) is the repetitive left foot step and the slick passing. You’re right about Galvin, there’s more physicality in his tackle evasion, more forceful contact. Like you would see from a back rower. No way was I comparing playing styles, rather the skills involved to fit in with a teams playing styles. I still think Benji could have been better utilised if the rest of the team knew what he was doing at least half the time.
 
In my mind, the closest playing style I’ve seen to Benji’s is Luai’s. The stand out (comparison wise) is the repetitive left foot step and the slick passing. You’re right about Galvin, there’s more physicality in his tackle evasion, more forceful contact. Like you would see from a back rower. No way was I comparing playing styles, rather the skills involved to fit in with a teams playing styles. I still think Benji could have been better utilised if the rest of the team knew what he was doing at least half the time.
His admiration for Benji probably a big reason he came across T, do think Galvan may end up in the forwards eventually just had another growth spurt if he fills out may be too big for 5/8.
 
In my mind, the closest playing style I’ve seen to Benji’s is Luai’s. The stand out (comparison wise) is the repetitive left foot step and the slick passing. You’re right about Galvin, there’s more physicality in his tackle evasion, more forceful contact. Like you would see from a back rower. No way was I comparing playing styles, rather the skills involved to fit in with a teams playing styles. I still think Benji could have been better utilised if the rest of the team knew what he was doing at least half the time.
The key to paying unstructured footy is structure. I know it sounds like gibber but players, outside of the unstructured playmakers, need to run lines and be in postions so the Benjis, Munsters and Luais of the world know where to hit once they have done their thing. If the side has no structure it just becomes a mess of headless chooks.
 
There is no squabbling. We are Wests Tigers. And should be in all top grades. There is no legitimate argument otherwise
Well there is a legitimate reason. It may not be the logical one or the one that most people on here agree with. And the reason is because what was agreed upon by both clubs at the time of the joint venture starting. It was written in to the agreement that both foundation clubs would continue to exist at the level immediately below NRL. You mightn't like it but its legitimate.
 
Well there is a legitimate reason. It may not be the logical one or the one that most people on here agree with. And the reason is because what was agreed upon by both clubs at the time of the joint venture starting. It was written in to the agreement that both foundation clubs would continue to exist at the level immediately below NRL. You mightn't like it but its legitimate.
While legitimate we are 25 years on from that decision and we need to move with the times otherwise we will continue to be stuck in 1999. While it was a great party at the end of that year and that century 1999 is in the 20th Century. We need a 21st Century approach to support the strategy that we have embarked upon.
 
The key to paying unstructured footy is structure. I know it sounds like gibber but players, outside of the unstructured playmakers, need to run lines and be in postions so the Benjis, Munsters and Luais of the world know where to hit once they have done their thing. If the side has no structure it just becomes a mess of headless chooks.
Team playbook calls so inside and outside knows what you are about to do?
 
Well there is a legitimate reason. It may not be the logical one or the one that most people on here agree with. And the reason is because what was agreed upon by both clubs at the time of the joint venture starting. It was written in to the agreement that both foundation clubs would continue to exist at the level immediately below NRL. You mightn't like it but its legitimate.
Well regardless of what sort of reasoning produced that outcome it's fair to say that it doesn't suit present day circumstances. Both parties should realise this after 25 years?
 
Team playbook calls so inside and outside knows what you are about to do?
Possibly,, but I don't think the Benjis and Munsters of the world know what they are going to do. They react to what they see and they know that they will have support or be able to hit a runner in different parts of the field so they just react and then the support picks them up. As far as a playbook- maybe two up for a Munster on the left post? 🤣
 
Back
Top