Who is the worst?

[jrtiger]

Ivan, then daylight, then daylight savings, then Mitchell Moses. I'll admit I'm still in love with Tedesco and cry about his absence most nights

 

[Telltails]

People forget or choose to ignore the rubbish that Teddy and Woods had to put up with leading up to re -signing of course they were going to consider options. Matterson for mine. Cleary' s obsession with coaching his son made him an easy target for Penrith and he never bagged the club. Matterson on the other hand - disgraceful glad he is gone.

 

[Russell]

Slimy for me wins hands down.

Absolutely loathe a "Tanker" - shows what he thinks of his mates.

 

[PJ_]

Would have picked anasta. Settled for moses

 

[jadtiger]

Slimy for me wins hands down.

Absolutely loathe a "Tanker" - shows what he thinks of his mates.

Which is also the reason i picked him at least the other players had a dig each week for the club

 

[Hbom]

Moses. Tanker. All that needs to be said.

Simona deserves to be on that list. Scum.

 

[gallagher]

Slimy for me wins hands down.

Absolutely loathe a "Tanker" - shows what he thinks of his mates.

100%, absolutely the slimey fart. I would actually laugh if he got a career ending injury.

 

[Tcat]

Moses every day of the week. He has a face id like to punch.

 

[clokan]

I went for Ivan the terrible, but Moses and Matterson were not far behind. Woods was pretty bad, but I cut him some slack cause he's missing a little on top and he did give his all in his last season with us. I didn't hate Tedesco that much, until they did a piece on him during origin, and basically made no mention of his time at Wests Tigers.

 

[tig_prmz]

what ivan did was a dog act but he was happy to finish his contract with us. while he was with us, he did help us through the post JT area and for that im grateful

matterson was unhappy but he never let that show in his performances here

woods/tedesco i understand, they left mainly coz they wanted to win and still gave their all for the club

now moses on the other hand, intentionally played crap and gave away games to get out of contract- to me, he has to be the most hated man. a pathetic low-life selfish human being

 

[Geo]

Ben Teo....

 

[Spud_Murphy]

Hmmm hard to pick just one from that lot really. Cleary, Moses and now Matterson stand out for obvious reasons, but honestly I’d give it to Tedesco because after all the club did for him through his early, injury stricken years he just couldn’t wait to leave us so he could go off and win a Premiership with someone else and now gives us zero credit for where he is today. We are completely dead to him and it really shows.

 

[BZN]

100% in agreement @tig_prmz with everything you said :cherries: :christmas_tree: :mother_christmas:

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

what ivan did was a dog act but he was happy to finish his contract with us. while he was with us, he did help us through the post JT area and for that im grateful

matterson was unhappy but he never let that show in his performances here

woods/tedesco i understand, they left mainly coz they wanted to win and still gave their all for the club

now moses on the other hand, intentionally played crap and gave away games to get out of contract- to me, he has to be the most hated man. a pathetic low-life selfish human being

Ivan was going to see his contract out? Nah, that was a face saving exercise in order to have the club force him out.

 

[Sart0ri]

Adam Blair. It looked like we had signed an elite forward but he had just come for a well paid holiday.

Cameron Smith, I know he never played for us but I hate him more than anyone else involved in the NRL.

 

[the_third]

Bwaith surely gets a mention

 

[Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan]

what ivan did was a dog act but he was happy to finish his contract with us. while he was with us, he did help us through the post JT area and for that im grateful

matterson was unhappy but he never let that show in his performances here

woods/tedesco i understand, they left mainly coz they wanted to win and still gave their all for the club

now moses on the other hand, intentionally played crap and gave away games to get out of contract- to me, he has to be the most hated man. a pathetic low-life selfish human being

Oh yeah I totally forgot this when I voted. I still remember the timeline.

* Moses has had a 900k/year for 3 years offer on the table for at least 6 months I believe. He and his manager had been holding the club to ransom when it was a great option.
* Ivan Cleary comes in, sees the contract and thinks "who made this contract?" and takes it off the table. It was crazy that we were offering Moses that amount of money.
* Ivan Cleary comes out saying "Woods and Tedesco are our priorities".
* Moses throws a tantrum and asks for a release.
* A week or two later, Moses has possibly his best game for us (and possibly his best game in his career to date) against the North Queensland Cowboys.
* After that performance, Cleary thinks to himself "there's no way I can release this guy. He's good. We need him."
* Realising Moses would never get a release if he kept playing well, the tanking begun.
* Isaac Moses, his manager, contacted all his media contacts spreading vicious rumours such as "Wests Tigers were intentionally damaging the mental health of Mitchell Moses."

After all that, we had no choice but to release him. He was moping around training and intentionally playing poor.

 

[happy_tiger]

Scott Prince .........Nick Graham .......Scott Sattler bloody lot of names come to mind really

 

[rustycage]

1. Moses by a long, long way.


2. Cleary
3. Tedesco

 

[jirskyr]

off the bench player with little to look back on but regret.

Ouch