Who should we let go at seasons end

[sunshine_coast_tiger]

I don't know about contracts or not but next year I would like to see the following not here:

Utai (yes he has played great but really are we going to be an elite NRL side with him on one wing going forward)
Reddy ( Too slow and too many defensive issues)
Rhino (No impact in attack, misses to many takles has become lazy in cover defence and does not hit hard enough in defence)
Lote (Two years ago he was great for us, age and injuries have caught up with him)
Humble ( he is not a bad player but is going forward we don't have a position for him, since we haver signed Moltzen we have our bench utility player)
Politoni/Iosefa ( Choose one to keep and let the other go, you only need 1 back up number 9\. The guy from Balamin SG Ball will be our next best number 9 in the future)
Ray Cashmere ( we can find a better player goinng forward)
Sean Meaney and Shaun Spence (forgot they wer part of the NRL squad untill I looked at the offical web page, again neither arte needed next year)
\
\
The biggest change is I would replace Tim Sheens, yes he is still a very good cocah but for mine he has been at our club too long and it is time for a change. I personally would replace him with either Daniel Anderson or Phil Gould.

 

[Brndn]

Its noticeable that iosefa is not on anyones list now that he has showed his worth.if robbie starts tonight and he does not play all the massive detractors would be all for him being the first one out.

I thought he had a real dig tonight. Good to see after some questionable performances in the last couple of games.

 

[angeman]

Sheens
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[saundo55]

Why not sack everyone and play bundaberg cup

Where we're you lot when we were winning - talk about fair weather supporters
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[Spartan117]

I found Liam Fults to be particularly Impotent last night…

Very little go forward, and didnt pass the pall at the line.

Kiamma Time.

 

[Guest]

Seriously guys, Heighno, Reddy and Moltzen are all on board for next year. Tuqiri is probably gone after tonight, Humble may not be here, same applies for Bell, Moors and Utai.

Who cares if they are on board, contracts mean nothing, none of them should be here next year if the club is serious about improving.

Ok fine then. So in all seriousness, how many players are the Tigers going to axe at the end of the season?

 

[milford_magic]

1.
2\. Ryan
3\. Lawrence
4.
5.
6\. Sironen
7\. Marshall
8\. Woods
9\. Farah
10.Galloway
11.
12.
13.

14.
15.BMM
16.
17.

There the only players I care about keeping. Some of the other players I've left out are decent but everyone I've left out is definitely replaceable. I wouldn't blink if we lost them. Even Ryan as good as he is playing, with Koribete and Nofolomu coming through isn't an absolute necessity.

 

[claws]

According to the Macquarie School Dictionary Second Edition "LOYAL" faithful and true. devoted, reliable, steadfast, trustworthy and trusty. Lets see how we stand at round 26\. I don't no who provides the bigger roller coaster? The Weststigers or the fans. Go Weststigers!

 

[RatedRKO]

Heighno
Lote
Reddy
Cashmere

Realistically, Heighno and Reddy will probably be resigned, and Moors/Bell/Humble will be let go. If that happens, we will have:

11\. Fulton
12\. Blair
13\. Anasta
14\. Heighington
15\. Thompson
16\. Pettybourne

We need more second rowers! :laughing:

 

[hybrid_tiger]

Seriously guys, Heighno, Reddy and Moltzen are all on board for next year. Tuqiri is probably gone after tonight, Humble may not be here, same applies for Bell, Moors and Utai.

Who cares if they are on board, contracts mean nothing, none of them should be here next year if the club is serious about improving.

Ok fine then. So in all seriousness, how many players are the Tigers going to axe at the end of the season?

I would be letting go of Moltzen, Reddy, Heighington, Tuqiri and Humble.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

I found Liam Fults to be particularly Impotent last night…

Very little go forward, and didnt pass the pall at the line.

Kiamma Time.

Really? he was running good lines and had no support. Still gave 110% in defence too.

 

[TIGER]

Benji

 

[hybrid_tiger]

And Ayshford would be on the verge of my letting go list. Another player who has gone backwards fast.

 

[Twodogs]

Humble was great before Sheens took him off thats one guy i hope stays

Nb - sadly even the bulldogs website has misspelled Mitch brown's name. poor guy can't get a break.

How do you misspell Minch Broom??!!??
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[Twodogs]

Heighno
Lote
Reddy
Cashmere

Realistically, Heighno and Reddy will probably be resigned, and Moors/Bell/Humble will be let go. If that happens, we will have:

11\. Fulton
12\. Blair
13\. Anasta
14\. Heighington
15\. Thompson
16\. Pettybourne

We need more second rowers!

Like NSW lol!
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[kh_canada]

1.
2\. Ryan
3\. Lawrence
4.
5.
6\. Sironen
7\. Marshall
8\. Woods
9\. Farah
10.Galloway
11.
12.
13.

14.
15.BMM
16.
17.

There the only players I care about keeping. Some of the other players I've left out are decent but everyone I've left out is definitely replaceable. I wouldn't blink if we lost them. Even Ryan as good as he is playing, with Koribete and Nofolomu coming through isn't an absolute necessity.

Ryan, Lawrence, Kori & Nofo as wingers/centres then we have Pettybourne & Thompson backrowers. Just need to find a solid bench and fullback - personally I love Timmy Moltzen but I'd rather see his talent used in the halves at another club. Tedesco.. well yeah, easily replaced honestly.

 

[Guest]

Seriously guys, Heighno, Reddy and Moltzen are all on board for next year. Tuqiri is probably gone after tonight, Humble may not be here, same applies for Bell, Moors and Utai.

Who cares if they are on board, contracts mean nothing, none of them should be here next year if the club is serious about improving.

Ok fine then. So in all seriousness, how many players are the Tigers going to axe at the end of the season?

I would be letting go of Moltzen, Reddy, Heighington, Tuqiri and Humble.

That doesn't really answer the question though HT. Moltzen has just been re-signed for 3 years, he's not going to be axed. Lote may retire which is fine and Humble may be released if he gets an offer elsewhere. Realistically I do not expect Heighno and Reddy to be let go until their contracts expire or they get good offers and seek a release.

 

[Spartan117]

I found Liam Fults to be particularly Impotent last night…

Very little go forward, and didnt pass the pall at the line.

Kiamma Time.

Really? he was running good lines and had no support. Still gave 110% in defence too.

A+ for effort, but just not troubling the opposition like we need our 2nd rowers to.

 

[hybrid_tiger]

That doesn't really answer the question though HT. Moltzen has just been re-signed for 3 years, he's not going to be axed. Lote may retire which is fine and Humble may be released if he gets an offer elsewhere. Realistically I do not expect Heighno and Reddy to be let go until their contracts expire or they get good offers and seek a release.

Moltzen hasn't been re-signed yet, nothing official.

Every other club (including ours) moves players on before their contracts are up, I don't see contracts as an issue.

 

[magpiecol]

Why not sack everyone and play bundaberg cup

Where we're you lot when we were winning - talk about fair weather supporters
\
\
_Posted using Roar FEED 2012_

You have no idea about forward planning do you?

Most of the players mentioned in this discussion could be moved on without any major upheaval.

Heino (definite if we sign Lewis), Lote, Cashmere, Humble (although I do not mind him. He has a go), Reddy, Ayshford, Utai, Moltzen (although may have been re-signed), Moors.

Should keep, Ryan, Benji (although not at half), Farah, Anasta, Blair, Woods, BMM, Lawrence, Sironen, Grant, maybe Fulton,both wingers from the NYC.

Everyone has different opinions about who stays and who goes, but we need to constantly upgrade our players to keep the club strong.

And the most important person who should go is Sheens. Stale ideas, stale delivery at interviews and narrow minded as far as changing out of form players.