Who would you prefer at 5/8, Reynolds at 750K or Moses at 850K?

C

colmcd

New member
I have to ask this out. Because it is so funny hearing the Dogs fans bag Reynolds.

So here we go, please add extra choices on the market that are even possible.

We have:

Josh Reynolds, 750K. Bulldogs 5/8 Origin 5/8 tough player and a decent defender. He doesn't do too many offloads but barges and scores the tries himself. Key to the bulldogs current winning streak.

Mitchell Moses, 850K contract rejected (so 850+). WT Junior and current 5/8\. Does good offloads and can step. Regarded as a "Turn style" with Luke Brooks in defense.

Te Marie Martin, 550k?? (unknown really) Panthers current 5/8 but WT Junior and was forced out of cap.
Does good footwork and can set tries up. Wanted to stay but was forced away because we "invested in the future" in Moses.

Who would you pick? To me it's no contest as we need a decent 5/8 and Josh's defense is the best.
 
Reynolds needs a controlling halfback
Brooks needs a running 5/8

They complement each other so well.

Moses is garbage.
 
@ said:
I have to ask this out. Because it is so funny hearing the Dogs fans bag Reynolds.

So here we go, please add extra choices on the market that are even possible.

We have:

Josh Reynolds, 750K. Bulldogs 5/8 Origin 5/8 tough player and a decent defender. He doesn't do too many offloads but barges and scores the tries himself. Key to the bulldogs current winning streak.

Mitchell Moses, 850K contract rejected (so 850+). WT Junior and current 5/8\. Does good offloads and can step. Regarded as a "Turn style" with Luke Brooks in defense.

Te Marie Martin, 550k?? (unknown really) Panthers current 5/8 but WT Junior and was forced out of cap.
Does good footwork and can set tries up. Wanted to stay but was forced away because we "invested in the future" in Moses.

Who would you pick? To me it's no contest as we need a decent 5/8 and Josh's defense is the best.
Click to expand...

Dogs fans bag Reynolds? Every Dogs fan I know is gutted that Josh is leaving.
 
The extra 100k we save on a 5/8, as well as the extra few hundred K on a prop, and similar amount on a fullback can all be put to use in upgrading our pack. Good times ahead.
 
@ said:
I have to ask this out. Because it is so funny hearing the Dogs fans bag Reynolds.

So here we go, please add extra choices on the market that are even possible.

We have:

Josh Reynolds, 750K. Bulldogs 5/8 Origin 5/8 tough player and a decent defender. He doesn't do too many offloads but barges and scores the tries himself. Key to the bulldogs current winning streak.

Mitchell Moses, 850K contract rejected (so 850+). WT Junior and current 5/8\. Does good offloads and can step. Regarded as a "Turn style" with Luke Brooks in defense.

Te Marie Martin, 550k?? (unknown really) Panthers current 5/8 but WT Junior and was forced out of cap.
Does good footwork and can set tries up. Wanted to stay but was forced away because we "invested in the future" in Moses.

Who would you pick? To me it's no contest as we need a decent 5/8 and Josh's defense is the best.
Click to expand...

First of all, as far as I know, Martin is on nowhere near 550k. Secondly, I completely agree with Milky, Reynolds and Brooks will compliment each other really well.
 
Would've preferred Johnson but certainly Reynolds and the more I think about should be made captain.
He might become really devoted to the club temper his bad plays.
Could be a real winner this move.
 
@ said:
@ said:
I have to ask this out. Because it is so funny hearing the Dogs fans bag Reynolds.

So here we go, please add extra choices on the market that are even possible.

We have:

Josh Reynolds, 750K. Bulldogs 5/8 Origin 5/8 tough player and a decent defender. He doesn't do too many offloads but barges and scores the tries himself. Key to the bulldogs current winning streak.

Mitchell Moses, 850K contract rejected (so 850+). WT Junior and current 5/8\. Does good offloads and can step. Regarded as a "Turn style" with Luke Brooks in defense.

Te Marie Martin, 550k?? (unknown really) Panthers current 5/8 but WT Junior and was forced out of cap.
Does good footwork and can set tries up. Wanted to stay but was forced away because we "invested in the future" in Moses.

Who would you pick? To me it's no contest as we need a decent 5/8 and Josh's defense is the best.

Dogs fans bag Reynolds? Every Dogs fan I know is gutted that Josh is leaving.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

I think theyre bagging him because of disbelief. Not in a million years did they expect Reynolds to get the punt
 
@ said:
@ said:
I have to ask this out. Because it is so funny hearing the Dogs fans bag Reynolds.

So here we go, please add extra choices on the market that are even possible.

We have:

Josh Reynolds, 750K. Bulldogs 5/8 Origin 5/8 tough player and a decent defender. He doesn't do too many offloads but barges and scores the tries himself. Key to the bulldogs current winning streak.

Mitchell Moses, 850K contract rejected (so 850+). WT Junior and current 5/8\. Does good offloads and can step. Regarded as a "Turn style" with Luke Brooks in defense.

Te Marie Martin, 550k?? (unknown really) Panthers current 5/8 but WT Junior and was forced out of cap.
Does good footwork and can set tries up. Wanted to stay but was forced away because we "invested in the future" in Moses.

Who would you pick? To me it's no contest as we need a decent 5/8 and Josh's defense is the best.

Dogs fans bag Reynolds? Every Dogs fan I know is gutted that Josh is leaving.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Should have heard TripleM (although they may be doing their usual dodgy stuff).
People calling in saying that he doesn't throw the ball as much, isn't worth 500k let alone 750k etc.
The Grill team basically said the callers were a "very tough customer", but could be triple M getting fakes calling in.

They also mentioned that Ivan Cleary was doing some work for Fox and watched Josh Reynolds a year ago and said "what a player".
 
So easy to be Monday morning quarterback, however, big mistake was to leave Te Martin and Papanhuyzen. By saying that Raynolds, can be a good (but grossly overpaid) buy.
Go Tigers :sign:
 
My 2 cents.

At the moment with the state of the team and the position we are going to be in Reynolds hands down.
He is an out and out five eight. A runner first, reacting to the defence, doesn't throw a slick ball in a sweeping play but he does get his arms free to link up with his centre or backrower (Jackson). In addition to this, Brooks is an out and out halfback, he will not is yet but he will be a great organiser / game manager half and already has good kicking skill. (In game application needs work).
Reynolds will help mild our team into a consistent finals side.
However.
Once that time comes. The player you want once you become a consistent contender is actually someone like Mitchell Moses. I truely believe that he has more X factor in him and will be a key to a team winning a comp.
As I said at this stage we need a Reynolds type more.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 383 (members: 25, guests: 358)
Back
Top