Willow's match report and player review

[happy_tiger]

Thanks Willow Thought Gibbsy had a pretty good game today with Ellis and Ayshford . Great report as usual

 

[Snake]

Your effort in writing these reports are certainly appreciated Willow especially when overseas you are a dedicated Weststigers supporter.

 

[The_Phantom]

Thanks Willow I am in full agreement with your summarisation of the match.Keep up the great work.

 

[mike]

Thanks Willow, your reports are always read with great interest. Much appreciated.

 

[MightyMaggy]

every week you are way too harsh on moltzen, as if today he was equal worse player on the field!
he was fine today….

Not on my TV screen he wasn't.

 

[bradexl]

I dont know wahat game you were watching and to take the stats of nrlstats site which is a load of rubbish. I feel you a to harsh and should keep your opinions to yourself. The thing about this forum they write the team off before the game is over and eat their words when they win.

:crazy Yeah Willow you are too harsh and next time keep your opinions to yourself :laughing: :laughing:
Next time you write up your match summary please only write what you think the majority want to hear, not what is on your heart and mind :laughing: :laughing:
Great report Willow….never read a bad one yet.

 

[cktiger]

I like your reports Willow but think you're being kind to Lui - he got pulled of the field because he was having a shocker …. again.

 

[tiger05]

To only give Moltzen 5/10 you must be having a laugh ????

Yep. The Willow report has gone down hill in a major way over the last couple of weeks. Two of the worst performers over the past 2 weeks have been rated highly (Robbie last week and McKinnon this week) and Moltzen keeps copping it.

 

[eyewonder]

Im batting on your side willow.

Thankyou for your consistently good and fair reports.

 

[jadtiger]

Keep up the good work Willow.Your ratings are always fair even if i dont always agree with them as we have different points of view.

 

[Guest]

I like your reports Willow but think you're being kind to Lui - he got pulled of the field because he was having a shocker …. again.

Is that confirmed, or was he pulled because he had suffered and injury and couldn't shake it? Personally i think 5/10 was fair, yes he missed a few tackles once again, but he also set up the Tigers first try which counts towards something.

 

[Guest]

To only give Moltzen 5/10 you must be having a laugh ????

Yep. The Willow report has gone down hill in a major way over the last couple of weeks. Two of the worst performers over the past 2 weeks have been rated highly (Robbie last week and McKinnon this week) and Moltzen keeps copping it.

Moltzen was quiet and did nothing. McKinnon missed a few tackles but take a look at the rest of his stats…He was hardly poor. And given that Farah came up with 2 try assists and kicked the winning field goal in golden point extra time against Newcastle...well some people clearly have an agenda because the Tigers would not have won that game without Farah.

 

[Deano1]

To only give Moltzen 5/10 you must be having a laugh ????

Yep. The Willow report has gone down hill in a major way over the last couple of weeks. Two of the worst performers over the past 2 weeks have been rated highly (Robbie last week and McKinnon this week) and Moltzen keeps copping it.

You seriously think McKinnon was one of our worst performers out there today!!!! :roll

 

[cktiger]

I like your reports Willow but think you're being kind to Lui - he got pulled of the field because he was having a shocker …. again.

Is that confirmed, or was he pulled because he had suffered and injury and couldn't shake it? Personally i think 5/10 was fair, yes he missed a few tackles once again, but he also set up the Tigers first try which counts towards something.

He didn't seem to be favouring it - looked as though he could still pass ok.
They might have put some " magic" spray on it that eventually wore off but I think it was his form - you have to admit he's had a real run of poor games.
The pass for the try wasn't anything out of the ordinary .
From memory Farah changed the direction quickly from dummy half to give him some time.
Allocating points is not an easy job and opens you up for criticism - but it also gives us something to talk about.
I'm happy for you to call it as you see it and let the rest of us discuss it from there.

 

[Guest]

No doubt Lui is not playing well overall. I like his passing game, he knows how to put a player through a gap and occasionally he'll sneak over close to the line himself, but yeah, his defence is terrible. He seemed to show improvement last year when Ellis came over to help him, maybe it was a psychological boost for him, i don't know, but he needs some help and needs to put his body into it more.

 

[tigeress]

Thanks for the great match report Willow. We won the match that's what is important- 2 in a row, lets hope we can keep up the good work

 

[happy_tiger]

To only give Moltzen 5/10 you must be having a laugh ????

Yep. The Willow report has gone down hill in a major way over the last couple of weeks. Two of the worst performers over the past 2 weeks have been rated highly (Robbie last week and McKinnon this week) and Moltzen keeps copping it.

If you think they are so bad Tiger05 don't read them Simple . Many of us enjoy them .

 

[The_Tooth]

I thought Galloway was very good going forward when the game started to turn. Deserves a mention.

I'm a big Lui fan, but agree he is struggling in defense bad. We didn't need him in attack as it turned out either. Maybe his ball playing skills aren't critical to us and Moltzen would be a more reliable defender. I hate it when TIgers are injured but Lui having a week or 2 off might just give us all a chance to see Moltzen at 7 again.

I've had it with Brown, two handling errors in his first 2 touches and a horrible looking attempt at the bomb with 5 minutes to go that could have cost us the game. Simona looks much more reliable and dangerous.

 

[tiger05]

To only give Moltzen 5/10 you must be having a laugh ????

Yep. The Willow report has gone down hill in a major way over the last couple of weeks. Two of the worst performers over the past 2 weeks have been rated highly (Robbie last week and McKinnon this week) and Moltzen keeps copping it.

If you think they are so bad Tiger05 don't read them Simple . Many of us enjoy them .

I am simply trying to provide some constructive feedback. Please note I only said the last two weeks. Maybe Willow has simply lost his touch for a small time period and his sensational reports will be back to the usual high level soon.

 

[happy_tiger]

To only give Moltzen 5/10 you must be having a laugh ????

Yep. The Willow report has gone down hill in a major way over the last couple of weeks. Two of the worst performers over the past 2 weeks have been rated highly (Robbie last week and McKinnon this week) and Moltzen keeps copping it.

If you think they are so bad Tiger05 don't read them Simple . Many of us enjoy them .

I am simply trying to provide some constructive feedback. Please note I only said the last two weeks. Maybe Willow has simply lost his touch for a small time period and his sensational reports will be back to the usual high level soon.

As long as he keeps you satisfied and gives people rating that you think are right and not what he thinks are right .