Worst Signing in Wests Tigers History

[Camel2281]

Based on Money spent to on Field output Luke Brooks, Josh Reynolds and Moses M'Bye by a margin

 

[TurnStyle]

Hard to say the worst. Would have to say Ballin to pick one.
For me there have been "disappointments" rather than worst.

- I was stoked they got Jimmy the Jet as he was probably my favourite non tiger, but he wasn't his old self.

- Lolohea I thought was awesome. Then he came to the tigers. 😐

- Jamal Idris I was more disappointed for, not with. He seemed like he was just getting back and he'd get injured again.

- thought Mbye was a great signing but they kept bloody moving him to a different position every week! So he was not great at the tigers and like Idris I was more disappointed for him.
Really respected that he openly said he wasn't giving value, whilst Packer, et al were always injured and riding the gravy train.

Jesus, is that even still a saying?! Gravy train! 🤣

 

[HUNT 101]

No one is pointing the finger at John Hopoate ☝️😂

 

[Droppy05]

Every year we always seem to add another chapter to our Book of Recruitment Failures

It's more like an encyclopedia !

 

[Droppy05]

No one is pointing the finger at John Hopoate ☝️😂

Careful!

 

[BAGNF05]

Our use of top 30 spots on development players in recent times has been nothing short of diabolical. Have any players gone from development contract to competent first grader?

 

[Merlot]

stretching the brain -but its got 2b Ballin,on a work/wage output.

 

[Halbrowne61]

The worry with this list of worst buys is that we keep making the same bad decisions, repeatedly.
Insanity rules at the WT.

 

[BrissieTiger67]

Just to derail the thread, remember when lote tuqiri came to tigers and in the first game ran down the side to score. Gee that was a good couple years of being a tigers fan with Ellis and Co.

Sorry , back to the regular televised misery 😉👌

 

[TurnStyle]

The worry with this list of worst buys is that we keep making the same bad decisions, repeatedly.
Insanity rules at the WT.

Thanks Einstein... 🤣

Note: this is a joke, not a sarcastic comment in case anyone doesn't get it. I'm sure you get it Hal. 😊

 

[Merlot]

Thanks Einstein... 🤣

Note: this is a joke, not a sarcastic comment in case anyone doesn't get it. I'm sure you get it Hal. 😊

throw in some numbers,that baffles a few.lol.

 

[Merlot]

Tim Bailey n his cronies .

 

[Bigtom]

Not even close. He got us to 9th with Robbie sulking and Tim Simona throwing games. Luke Brooks dally M came under him.
Benji will go down as the worst.

Pretty sure Brooks Dally M under Cleary

 

[weststigers]

Gotta be Josh Reynolds for wage vs output.

Jayden Sullivan getting pretty close these days.

 

[Tigerdazz2]

Ballin......why? just why?Packer......debatable, would have delivered but for injuries.Mbye.......not worth the coin. Blair......failing to deliver likewise Sullivan & Papali'i. Bateman.......antagonist, ratbag, more trouble than he is worth.

 

[twentyforty]

What I don’t understand is this..
There are 10 candidates for our worst signing playing for Manly and they make the top 8 and we win the spoon?
There‘s definitely some kind of injustice in this?

 

[Red88_Tiger]

What I don’t understand is this..
There are 10 candidates for our worst signing playing for Manly and they make the top 8 and we win the spoon?
There‘s definitely some kind of injustice in this?

Manly just turn up the boost on turbo