Would you drop BJ?

[AL The Tiger]


The real Warren Smith. Being a bit harsh isn't he?

Warren who hasbeen

Is he wrong?

Worst signing by any club in the NRL era? Really? Leilua was dumb today but he's been pretty good overall this season. Much better than Marsters ever was.

And come on... It was a dog shot but hardly a thing in it. Edwards was up straight away. I hate how BJ carried on like a goose but what can you do

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

He will get some weeks for a swinging arm on a player without the ball regardless of the circumstances.

To be dropped we need other back options, something we lack.

 

[hobbo1]

He'll be forcibly dropped for 3-4 weeks I reckon.

His defensive reads are just as bad as his brain farts

 

[GNR4LIFE]


The real Warren Smith. Being a bit harsh isn't he?

Warren who hasbeen

Is he wrong?

Worst signing by any club in the NRL era? Really? Leilua was dumb today but he's been pretty good overall this season. Much better than Marsters ever was.

And come on... It was a dog shot but hardly a thing in it. Edwards was up straight away. I hate how BJ carried on like a goose but what can you do

Smith grew up a Tigers fan, so there’s probably still some connection there, hence the emotion. It was a dog shot, no but’s.

 

[innsaneink]


The real Warren Smith. Being a bit harsh isn't he?

I think Luke Lewis or the other bloke on ABC grandstand suggested 16 weeks...

I said to my mate when LL got hit that BJ would get sent off... Not surprised... To the bloke suggesting he'd do the same for his bro... That doesn't help win game, controlled aggression does not loose Cannon froot loops

 

[Tigerbuck63]

JL has cost us in this game. His brother got hit, but let the review process deal with it. Bye should have insisted JL be replaced. Poor captaincy and now our great effor tit overshadowed by this behaviour.

Come on in reality he never cost us the game, they were marginally better all night but our defense stood up to the challenge.
Early is the season i was ? his signing but he is adding to the Team and is a player that can win the big games, i like we have brothers playing for each other as well as the team, he might get a week or two but that will ensure he thinks about the Team next time.
Agree not smart bit most footballers are not, but if they play with passion for the team i give them a big tick.

 

[Telltails]

He will never change. I thought playing with his brother might inspire him, but didn't consider the implications of Luci being a victim of foul play until it happened tonight. There was always going to be reaction not sure why it was Edwards though.

 

[nrlsurvivor]

I think it’ll likely be Hoffman brought in, probably to the wing, with Talau shifting to centre.

 

[Rugba]

It was obvious how he reacted with his bro situation , he was going to do something stupid. I was actually surprised the riff didn’t run more at him, as it was obvious he wanted to hurt them and he was going to do something silly. He should have been replaced

 

[old_man_tiger]


The real Warren Smith. Being a bit harsh isn't he?

Warren who hasbeen

Is he wrong?

Yes, not even close to the worst signing of the year let alone ever.
I can give you these names from our recent past without any effort
Ballin
Packer
Mbye (dollar for dollar)

Then from other clubs
Jack Bird
Hunt
Foran

Commentary and fandom don't mix

 

[bbobb]

The emotion isn’t the problem - it’s how it is used. A massive legal hit, an immense carry or heavy involvement is what you want. Inspire your team don’t disadvantage them.

The issue is that BJ is not a kid anymore and we have him for four years. He’s not going anywhere and it is doubtful he will change.

 

[TrueTiger]

But,But,everyone said we need mongrel in our team....now you got one and want to drop him...

He had a brain snap,nothing unusual about that...he just has to learn not to be so blatant with his stupidity...Madge really needs to man manage him otherwise he wont be any use to us....

BJ....when he is good he is great....when he is bad he is horrendous...

 

[hobbo1]

I think it’ll likely be Hoffman brought in, probably to the wing, with Talau shifting to centre.

Not in top 30

 

[Geo]

I think it’ll likely be Hoffman brought in, probably to the wing, with Talau shifting to centre.

Not in top 30

Hoffman can play..development player..

 

[hobbo1]

I think it’ll likely be Hoffman brought in, probably to the wing, with Talau shifting to centre.

Not in top 30


Hoffman can play..development player..

My bad ?

 

[Snake]

That coat hanger thought I was back at Lidcombe oval !

 

[innsaneink]

But,But,everyone said we need mongrel in our team....now you got one and want to drop him...

He had a brain snap,nothing unusual about that...he just has to learn not to be so blatant with his stupidity...Madge really needs to man manage him otherwise he wont be any use to us....

BJ....when he is good he is great....when he is bad he is horrendous...

He's not going to change... Waste of time.and money

 

[Spud_Murphy]


The real Warren Smith. Being a bit harsh isn't he?

I think Luke Lewis or the other bloke on ABC grandstand suggested 16 weeks...

I said to my mate when LL got hit that BJ would get sent off... Not surprised... To the bloke suggesting he'd do the same for his bro... That doesn't help win game, controlled aggression does not loose Cannon froot loops

16 weeks what a load of crap and a complete overreaction! Who has gotten 16 weeks for a shot like that over the past 15 years - no one. No doubt the media’s outrage surrounding it will ensure our player gets the book thrown at him though and he probably will end up getting 16 weeks.

 

[Harvey]

So how long does Korisau cop for the stiff arm on his Brother.

The most disappointing aspect was after he was off and the argy bargy kept going was that in the last melee with 10 seconds to go & the game gone, our players did not throw a couple and beat the living crap out of some of the mouthy flogs in the panthers team.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

So how long does Korisau cop for the stiff arm on his Brother.

The most disappointing aspect was after he was off and the argy bargy kept going was that in the last melee with 10 seconds to go & the game gone, our players did not throw a couple and beat the living crap out of some of the mouthy flogs in the panthers team.

Doubt Api gets suspended at all. There was nothing in it. Which made BJ’s reaction even more unacceptable.