WTF Best Ever 17 Second Row

Geo

Moderator
Staff member
Forum Leader
To qualify player must have started 20 games in the second row…

You may make 2 selections...Top 2 highest votes win the positions
 
@Geo. said:
Ellis and Boof for me…

x2 Geo .

i just checked all the games of Andrew Fifita that he has had for our Club? and they were all as Prop or of the bench , now i do admit his best footy was played at the Sharks would you factor that in ? or your just judging a player's form solely on how he performed at our Club?
I know his not on this list of 2nd Rowers but just using this as an example of how we are judging the players ?
Might be a stupid question? 😕

How i wish he never left :frowning: , another Sheenius decision cause he never wanted to go in the 1st place.
 
Ellis and Boof also

Simon Dwyer will be one of the first one I name on my bench

Just couldn't due to the lack of game time

Sorry Simon
 
Only WT games FT…when it comes to the bench it's a bit tricky as the composition is open to opinion some will want a 4 forward bench some a utility some may even want a winger on the bench so when the starting 13 is settled I'll open a thread where peeps can nominate 4 players and those with the most selections will win the bench spots...

It takes a bit of work to go through each players history
 
@Geo. said:
Only WT games FT…when it comes to the bench it's a bit tricky as the composition is open to opinion some will want a 4 forward bench some a utility some may even want a winger on the bench so when the starting 13 is settled I'll open a thread where peeps can nominate 4 players and those with the most selections will win the bench spots...

It takes a bit of work to go through each players history

Well seeing that Sheens coached us for the longest period , I propose we go with two undersized forwards , a winger and an undersized utility

We would be comfortable with that , wouldn't we
 
Ellis was a shoe in and Dwyer's hit on Hargreaves was worth a vote from me .

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_
 
@Geo. said:
Only WT games FT…when it comes to the bench it's a bit tricky as the composition is open to opinion some will want a 4 forward bench some a utility some may even want a winger on the bench so when the starting 13 is settled I'll open a thread where peeps can nominate 4 players and those with the most selections will win the bench spots...

It takes a bit of work to go through each players history

Thanks Geo
 
Perhaps you could use the numbered list of actual Tigers players (from 1st to last ) , and we pick the players ourselves

Would that be easier Geo ??

If you want me just to shut up ,just say so
 
@happy tiger said:
Perhaps you could use the numbered list of actual Tigers players (from 1st to last ) , and we pick the players ourselves

Would that be easier Geo ??

If you want me just to shut up ,just say so

When it comes time for the bench it will be open slather,,,,I will link the WT player list and peeps can chose whomever ….I'll put a cut off and those with the most noms will earn the bench spots,,,,

Those players who have earn t a starting spot will be excluded from the bench selection...
 
@Geo. said:
Ellis and Boof for me…

Ditto. Had Dwyer not been injured I reckon he may have snuck ahead of Laffranchi but as it stands those two are clear cut choices.
 
Ellis and Dwyer for me. Kinda picking Dwyer based on where I think he would be now.

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top