Your side to take on Knights

[Jedi_Tiger]

Cini had a shocker nofo didn't play well and Simpkin didn't have a great game
Joey L and Laurie played well not sure where we go

 

[WeststigsRdaBest]

Cini too centre for me..he’s improved on his d and feel he can really beat his man

 

[Guest]

Cini too centre for me..he’s improved on his d and feel he can really beat his man

He doesn't have the pace to beat many...although he's probably a safer option at centre than wing right now.

 

[TigerLouis]

Laurie
Nofoaluma
Mbye
Leilua
Talau
Douiehi
Madden
Ofahengaue
Blore
Leilua
Mikaele
Brooks
Tamou
Bench
Simpkin
Twal
Musgrove
Stefano

 

[TigerLouis]

Laurie
Nofoaluma
Mbye
Leilua
Talau
Douiehi
Madden
Ofahengaue
Blore
Leilua
Mikaele
Brooks
Tamou
Bench
Simpkin
Amone
Musgrove
Stefano

 

[DarlingSt]

I'm gonna go full cooked, may as well start to shake it up a bit, nothing really to lose from here

1. Laurie
2. Cini
3. Talau
4. Kiah Cooper
5. Nof
6. Doueihi
7. Madden
8. Mikaele
9. Liddle
10. Twal
11. Tuilagi
12. Luce
13. Blore
14. Docker-Clay
15. Utoikamanu
16. Ofahengahue
17. Musgrove

Appreciate dockar clay, cooper and tuilagi may not be eligible.. but I think those 17 could be a good unit

I'm not 100% on madden tbh, but worth giving him a shot

Mbye, bj, brooks, ganer and tamou could use a spell

 

[Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan]

What are everyone's thoughts on Simpkin? He's looked good at some things, and struggled in some areas. Does he need a spell in NSW cup to work on his game or is a tough time in first grade a better option for his development? Maybe swap him with Liddle?

Talau should come back into the side at right centre.

Liddle looked decent and should hold his spot.

 

[Snake]

What are everyone's thoughts on Simpkin? He's looked good at some things, and struggled in some areas. Does he need a spell in NSW cup to work on his game or is a tough time in first grade a better option for his development? Maybe swap him with Liddle?

Talau should come back into the side at right centre.

Liddle looked decent and should hold his spot.

He should of been given a taste and back to Reggie's he is not ready ..

 

[Tigersmurf]

What are everyone's thoughts on Simpkin? He's looked good at some things, and struggled in some areas. Does he need a spell in NSW cup to work on his game or is a tough time in first grade a better option for his development? Maybe swap him with Liddle?

Talau should come back into the side at right centre.

Liddle looked decent and should hold his spot.

Cini and Simpkin need to be given some slack. They are just starting their careers in a very ordinary team. I am happy for the coach to show faith in the younger guys to give them belief but the experienced guys that don't pull their weight need to be shown that you don't have a spot in the team waiting for you because of how much money you earn.

 

[TYGA]

What are everyone's thoughts on Simpkin? He's looked good at some things, and struggled in some areas. Does he need a spell in NSW cup to work on his game or is a tough time in first grade a better option for his development? Maybe swap him with Liddle?

Talau should come back into the side at right centre.

Liddle looked decent and should hold his spot.

Simpkin is a good kid coming into a bad team.
Too good for NSW Cup not ready to dominate first grade. Liddle can’t hit the side of a barn with a pass and can’t tackle so I’m assuming he will stay as he has more upside and under contract Liddle will struggle to get a contractZ

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

What are everyone's thoughts on Simpkin? He's looked good at some things, and struggled in some areas. Does he need a spell in NSW cup to work on his game or is a tough time in first grade a better option for his development? Maybe swap him with Liddle?

Talau should come back into the side at right centre.

Liddle looked decent and should hold his spot.

Simpkin needs to keep gaining first grade experience he needs to start due to the fact liddle has more of a running game with speed from dummy half than Simpkin so probablybetter he comes off bench. Simpkin does defend better than Liddle I think at present neither can go 80 mins so both are needed.
Next year not so sure

 

[Milky]

Same side,

6. Talau
7. Douiehi

 

[jadtiger]

What are everyone's thoughts on Simpkin? He's looked good at some things, and struggled in some areas. Does he need a spell in NSW cup to work on his game or is a tough time in first grade a better option for his development? Maybe swap him with Liddle?

Talau should come back into the side at right centre.

Liddle looked decent and should hold his spot.

Simpkin is a good kid coming into a bad team.
Too good for NSW Cup not ready to dominate first grade. Liddle can’t hit the side of a barn with a pass and can’t tackle so I’m assuming he will stay as he has more upside and under contract Liddle will struggle to get a contractZ

I agree with your first line but the rest of it is completely wrong.We looked a lot better after Liddle came on

 

[Guest]

What are everyone's thoughts on Simpkin? He's looked good at some things, and struggled in some areas. Does he need a spell in NSW cup to work on his game or is a tough time in first grade a better option for his development? Maybe swap him with Liddle?

Talau should come back into the side at right centre.

Liddle looked decent and should hold his spot.

Simpkin is a good kid coming into a bad team.
Too good for NSW Cup not ready to dominate first grade. Liddle can’t hit the side of a barn with a pass and can’t tackle so I’m assuming he will stay as he has more upside and under contract Liddle will struggle to get a contractZ

>

Yes let's continue to pick a hooker who picks up the ball, takes a step, then passes high, low or behind. Don't forget that he also is slower than a hobbled turtle. Simpkin is NOT Harry Grant. Many on here are living in a delusional fantasy.

Also continue to pick can't defend, offers nothing in attack Mbye.

Makes it easy for the punters.

 

[bradexl]

I'm getting onto this one early...

1. Laurie
2. Nofo
3. Talau
4. BJ
5. Mbye
6. Doueihi
7. Madden
8. Tamou
9. Liddle
10. Twal
11. Garner
12. Lucy
13. Joe O

14. Simpkin
15. Stefano
16. Mikaele
17. Seyfarth

Madden has to come in. Is he the answer? I have no idea but Brooks has to go. His confidence is shot and he lacks capacity as an NRL halfback.

 

[Guest]

Mbye last night.

16 tackles

8 missed or innefective tackles.

Not to mention the the number of times that he was just plain out of position.

Yet he STILL HAS NEVER BEEN DROPPED.

Release the photos now Madge and stop the pain.

 

[cqtiger]

I don’t know about next week but my guess would be when we play Storm or Penrith that we look at a forfeit.

 

[mikey]

i thought simpkin was pretty poor again tonight, i think Liddle has to start

Didn't take him long to get 1st grade disease.

 

[Toowoomba_Tiger]

7. BILLY WALTERS

I'd even be happy with Zach Docker Clay, but not sure he is eligible.

 

[Tcat]

Mbye last night.

16 tackles

8 missed or innefective tackles.

Not to mention the the number of times that he was just plain out of position.

Yet he STILL HAS NEVER BEEN DROPPED.

Release the photos now Madge and stop the pain.

Let's be honest. Most of the side except AD, Mikale and Laurie need to be dropped. I'm not exactly a fan of Mbye, but atm is he that much worse then the other clowns that like to refer to themselves as first graders.