Your Team vs Panthers Round 8

[Spud_Murphy]

Why is everyone advocating for Packer to be in the team? Did you all not watch his lack of performance a few weeks back?

 

[hobbo1]

Why is everyone advocating for Packer to be in the team? Did you all not watch his lack of performance a few weeks back?

We /I want him to belt Cleary ...

 

[rihannafan1]

Mikaele and Douhei in doubt, replacements ?

Corey Thompson would be handy.

Mbye to fullback, some rando to centre.

 

[rihannafan1]

Mikaele and Douhei in doubt, replacements ?

Oh nooooo! We can’t go in to play a side like the Panthers so under strength!

We can if it means we have more strength against Souths next week. They're the team we'll most likely have to surpass if we're to get in the 8.

But yeah, no Mikaele or AD against Penrith has me thinking we'll really be on the back foot.

 

[Deleted member 3518]

Mikaele and Douhei in doubt, replacements ?

Corey Thompson would be handy.

Mbye to fullback, some rando to centre.

Talau to centre mate . Hoffman on the wing

 

[rihannafan1]

Mikaele and Douhei in doubt, replacements ?

Corey Thompson would be handy.

Mbye to fullback, some rando to centre.

Talau to centre mate . Hoffman on the wing

Getting really inexperienced on an edge there. Lawrence may be a better choice to have in centre

 

[TrueTiger]

The only thing I would do if things get deperate is leave Talau on the wing ,move Mbye to fullback and put MCK or maybe Lawrence in the centres ...its nowhere near ideal but who has Madge got that we can put in the centres that has at least some experience,Panthers would crucify a young inexperienced player in the backline..

 

[avocadoontoast]

Mikaele and Douhei in doubt, replacements ?

Corey Thompson would be handy.

Mbye to fullback, some rando to centre.

Talau to centre mate . Hoffman on the wing

Getting really inexperienced on an edge there. Lawrence may be a better choice to have in centre

Lawrence would get eaten alive playing centre.

To be honest if AD and Mikaele are out we're no chance. At full strength Penrith would be extremely hard but without Twal, AD, Mikaele it's beyond us.

 

[Spud_Murphy]

Why is everyone advocating for Packer to be in the team? Did you all not watch his lack of performance a few weeks back?

We /I want him to belt Cleary ...

All well and good, but I’d rather actually win the game than just see Cleary belted. Besides it’s the wrong Cleary, I’ve nothing against Junior, it’s his old man that needs the belting.

 

[Spud_Murphy]

Mikaele and Douhei in doubt, replacements ?

Corey Thompson would be handy.

Mbye to fullback, some rando to centre.

Talau to centre mate . Hoffman on the wing

Getting really inexperienced on an edge there. Lawrence may be a better choice to have in centre

Lawrence would get eaten alive playing centre.

To be honest if AD and Mikaele are out we're no chance. At full strength Penrith would be extremely hard but without Twal, AD, Mikaele it's beyond us.

And Musgrove as well, no chance!

 

[avocadoontoast]

Mikaele and Douhei in doubt, replacements ?

Corey Thompson would be handy.

Mbye to fullback, some rando to centre.

Talau to centre mate . Hoffman on the wing

Getting really inexperienced on an edge there. Lawrence may be a better choice to have in centre

Lawrence would get eaten alive playing centre.

To be honest if AD and Mikaele are out we're no chance. At full strength Penrith would be extremely hard but without Twal, AD, Mikaele it's beyond us.

And Musgrove as well, no chance!

The only good news is Roberto Jennings being unavailable for selection.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

The only reason I would advocate for Packer to return is to decapitate Cleary.

 

[avocadoontoast]

The only reason I would advocate for Packer to return is to decapitate Cleary.

Nathan or Ivan? Or both?

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

The only reason I would advocate for Packer to return is to decapitate Cleary.

Nathan or Ivan? Or both?

Well, Nathan is first preference. He can always clock Ivan in the car park after the game.

 

[avocadoontoast]

The only reason I would advocate for Packer to return is to decapitate Cleary.

Nathan or Ivan? Or both?

Well, Nathan is first preference. He can always clock Ivan in the car park after the game.

I support this strategy.

 

[TrueTiger]

The only reason I would advocate for Packer to return is to decapitate Cleary.

Now,now CB,its unlike you to incite violence...even though its a great idea..:clap:

 

[TrueTiger]

Mikaele and Douhei in doubt, replacements ?

Corey Thompson would be handy.

Mbye to fullback, some rando to centre.

Talau to centre mate . Hoffman on the wing

Getting really inexperienced on an edge there. Lawrence may be a better choice to have in centre

Lawrence would get eaten alive playing centre.

To be honest if AD and Mikaele are out we're no chance. At full strength Penrith would be extremely hard but without Twal, AD, Mikaele it's beyond us.

And Musgrove as well, no chance!

The only good news is Roberto Jennings being unavailable for selection.

Oh no Russ will be doing cartwheels again...I hope he doesn't injure himself..

 

[Nelson]

Mikaele and Douhei in doubt, replacements ?

Corey Thompson would be handy.

Mbye to fullback, some rando to centre.

Talau to centre mate . Hoffman on the wing

Yeah I would say something like that. Mbye fullback, Talau centre and a rookie on the wing - Hoffman or Bradley or maybe.

 

[Newtown]

The only reason I would advocate for Packer to return is to decapitate Cleary.

Nathan or Ivan? Or both?

Well, Nathan is first preference. He can always clock Ivan in the car park after the game.

I support this strategy.

That is one battle we can win.

 

[TrueTiger]

Mikaele and Douhei in doubt, replacements ?

Corey Thompson would be handy.

Mbye to fullback, some rando to centre.

Talau to centre mate . Hoffman on the wing

Yeah I would say something like that. Mbye fullback, Talau centre and a rookie on the wing - Hoffman or Bradley or maybe.

Nelson,I agree to an extent of your changes,however in my way of thinking is that Talau has been great on the wing,I don't know how he would go in the centres even though I have faith in the kid making it in NRL,especially this being a crucial game for us if we want to be contenders in the finals..
I said earlier that this Penrith team would crucify a young inexperienced player in the backline and would rather put MCK or maybe Lawrence there because of their experience in the game,not ideal but I would hate to see a young genuine up and comer getting hammered and losing confidence and that goes for Hoffman and Bradley as well..
I don't know the answer but no doubt Madge has a plan and we just have to keep the faith...