Please Please Please..
Get through the Banner...
Get through the Banner...
Seven seasons 50 games?
C
Cobarcats
Guest
I had 1 game and was brilliant 🤣
Yeah, I had to look it up as well to double check. Surprised by that.
We need him to have an injury free run he is just starting to get some positive form emerging for us. Going to be a crucial cog over the coming years for us.
I actually think it's smart of Madge to start him still regardless if Stefano is coming back from injury slowly and on minutes watch.
Next year if Tamou leaves Musgrove right now starts next to Stefano.
Musgrove has next to no miles in the body for the last few seasons and we need him to get his body use to week in week out footy. His best years are ahead of him as well.
Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan
Well-known member
Dude is a marshmallow. Runs soft, does not hit hard in defence. He gets cut down so easily with ball in hand. Even hookers can chop his legs without much worry.
He's on the Aaron Woods spectrum. Maybe worse.
He's on the Aaron Woods spectrum. Maybe worse.
The SHADOW
Well-known member
Not a first grader in the NRL
Tim Sheens
Well-known member
The less said the better.
The SHADOW
Well-known member
Disagree, the more roar and out
Madge
Well-known member
He is nothing more than a bench forward imo. Max.
Become a disappointment. I think he's passable as the 4th best prop in your team, but if you're asking for big minutes from him you're in trouble.
Joe is by far the pick of the players in our pack and it's not really close. Pole's shown some promise and hopefully Utoikamanu can come back with his 2021 form but we definitely need some help in the front row.
Joe is by far the pick of the players in our pack and it's not really close. Pole's shown some promise and hopefully Utoikamanu can come back with his 2021 form but we definitely need some help in the front row.
More like just give him away free to a good home…..actually any home
clontarfkid
Well-known member
Musgrove and Tamou ,despite being same size,simply chose not to stand up to big Sharks forwards,and throw in sporadic effort of both 2nr rowers who have one foot out the door,we got comprehensively steamrolled up the middle.
Our other 2 largest forwards Mikaele and LL have been let go. to save a few pennies this year...not real smart
Include a no6 who is totally coasting in defence close to the ruck...final score somewhat flattered us
Definitely Tamous last year..Musgrove not starting..and buy someone consistently willing to take it up with aggression like Lodge or even Hass.
We have $$$
And I'm firming on Madden and Hastings in halves and punting 1.6 mill of underachievers in Douhi and Brooks who both prefer to be elsewhere..and playing like it
Maybe pick up Brown from eels to add class to halves
Our other 2 largest forwards Mikaele and LL have been let go. to save a few pennies this year...not real smart
Include a no6 who is totally coasting in defence close to the ruck...final score somewhat flattered us
Definitely Tamous last year..Musgrove not starting..and buy someone consistently willing to take it up with aggression like Lodge or even Hass.
We have $$$
And I'm firming on Madden and Hastings in halves and punting 1.6 mill of underachievers in Douhi and Brooks who both prefer to be elsewhere..and playing like it
Maybe pick up Brown from eels to add class to halves
Last edited:
king_sirro
Well-known member
For us to make the 8 we need our front row stocks strong enough to have Musgrove play reserve grade and be a back up only. I actually think if we have a fully fit squad that will be the case. Hastings at lock, Joffa and stef starting, with Pole and Twal off the bench. Possibly Blore as well. Leaves Musgrove 6th choice with Aitasi James maybe even pushing him to 7th. That's where he belongs.
Fully fit Twal, Stef and Blore, along with Papali'i make a huge difference last night. If Hastings plays we score over 24 points IMO.
Fully fit Twal, Stef and Blore, along with Papali'i make a huge difference last night. If Hastings plays we score over 24 points IMO.
Jedi_Tiger
Well-known member
sheens will keep Brooks 2024 and beyond if he can get the salary down with the discount e.g. 750k with 200k discount 550k.
if Brooks wants to chase big money at Newcastle e.g. 850k or above then he can leave
That is a better option than paying 450k for Madden for example
I think the club should say to douhie we see you as a centre and here is 450k to 500k to play centre, if he doesn't like it he can leave
We needs one of
Dylan Brown
Munster
Burton
to play 6
if Brooks wants to chase big money at Newcastle e.g. 850k or above then he can leave
That is a better option than paying 450k for Madden for example
I think the club should say to douhie we see you as a centre and here is 450k to 500k to play centre, if he doesn't like it he can leave
We needs one of
Dylan Brown
Munster
Burton
to play 6
earl
Well-known member
I like him but this is what he is. He can have an impact from the bench. I think you can start him as well but he only gets small minutes.
I'm less worried about our middle forwards now. I'm assuming we let Tamou go. Pole, Stef, Joe O, Twal and then Blore, Musgrove etc as back-ups.
Long Term Fan
Well-known member
Musgrove off the bench for short stints only. Need to get him fired up for each game.
