TEAM LIST Wests Tigers Team v Newcastle Knights..

[bigsiro]

Get over it. Have an unbiased vi

Both posts you quoted start off with

"He wasn't amazing" "He wasn't awesome"

He's had plenty of rubbish games over his career but last sat wasn't one of them. If his "horrible" game consists of 2 try assists (should have been 3) and nearly triple the amount of tackles of his 5/8 then you'd take that any day

Let's not talk about the goal kicking tho ..

I don’t even think goalkicking was the problem. 😊.
I just don’t see how anyone can suggest he played the role of halfback adequately.
His Tackling? Terrific! But that should be strictly regarded as bonus content only.

 

[barra]

I did not know if it was just me, but I agree. I thought we had the numbers three times in the first half and big Ken could have bagged four by oranges. Granted I was only getting the TV coverage and that can be misleading

That’s how I saw it. Listened to the game live on radio and they mentioned it at least once.

 

[bigsiro]

That’s incorrect. I corrected that it was a horrible game and commented with facts of his actual performance & lack of effort/support he has been given. Actually said he didn’t have an awesome game.

It’s good to know given you disagreed with my whole statement that you’re happy with the effort of 95% of our other players in the last game.

Everyone knows you’re anti Brooks it’s ok to own it.

Never said I was happy with their performance. Never shirked my role as president either. I own it with pride. 😊

 

[bigsiro]

Both posts you quoted start off with

"He wasn't amazing" "He wasn't awesome"

He's had plenty of rubbish games over his career but last sat wasn't one of them. If his "horrible" game consists of 2 try assists (should have been 3) and nearly triple the amount of tackles of his 5/8 then you'd take that any day

Let's not talk about the goal kicking tho ..

Once again, I didn’t say he was horrible. I just said that he didn’t adequately perform the role of a halfback.

 

[Speed2burn]

I don’t even think goalkicking was the problem. 😊.
I just don’t see how anyone can suggest he played the role of halfback adequately.
His Tackling? Terrific! But that should be strictly regarded as bonus content only.

You do realise doing all that defending can greatly impact your offensive game? that's where i'm getting at. All things considered, he did well

Sucks about the rest of the team eh?

 

[bigsiro]

You do realise doing all that defending can greatly impact your offensive game? that's where i'm getting at. All things considered, he did well

Sucks about the rest of the team eh?

Yes it’s sucks. There is a lot of work to do. I don’t blame any one player for that loss. Storm are formidable and crucial errors at key moments were costly. I don’t blame the individuals this time. Not even Brooks!

 

[Tigersmurf]

Cummins couldn't referee an under 6s footy match.. 🗑🗑🗑

To be fair, I've done this many times and its not easy....I lost the support of the players

 

[earl]

I’m only calling out those that say Brooks had a good game.

You are wrong. He created plenty for us and his defense was good. It was a good game.

 

[PJ_]

Never said I was happy with their performance. Never shirked my role as president either. I own it with pride. 😊

Got my vote

 

[tiger_one]

Are Brooks, Maumalo and Simkin injured?

 

[tony soprano]

Are Brooks, Maumalo and Simkin injured?

I think the mail is based on they weren't at Tuesday training but guess work what happened since then

 

[tony soprano]

anyone got access to the Brooks artical

 

[tony soprano]

I'd be inclined to start Peachey at 9. Don't think Jake's up to starting. Put him in after 20 mins.

 

[BAGNF05]

Tackling isn’t his job.
Organising the attack is his job. One he didn’t do well at all.
As per usual.

Can see why we had the second worst defense last year if blokes aren’t paid to tackle. It’s not NFL.

 

[cktiger]

Can see why we had the second worst defense last year if blokes aren’t paid to tackle. It’s not NFL.

Of course they’re paid to tackle… but that’s not the priority for a halfback.

 

[sparci]

I'd be inclined to start Peachey at 9. Don't think Jake's up to starting. Put him in after 20 mins.

whatre you on about, he did really well starting, issues came later on after about 60 mins, but his play was fine until then. Peachy had terrible service when he played there in the trials, starting with him would stifle things even more

 

[tony soprano]

whatre you on about, he did really well starting, issues came later on after about 60 mins, but his play was fine until then. Peachy had terrible service when he played there in the trials, starting with him would stifle things even more

Yeah just thinking to help him last the 80

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Never said I was happy with their performance. Never shirked my role as president either. I own it with pride. 😊

 

[Cobarcats]

I really couldn't give a rats about the Storm
Kenny had a blinder on the weekend, could be out 4-8 wks

Oh no 😱 if Ken is out this weekend who is going to captain the side?

 

[TieDye]

Oh no 😱 if Ken is out this weekend who is going to captain the side?

I am. D cap'n