Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

ElleryHanley said:
You would hope there are incomings, and not just young players going up.

Fonua Pole will come up, but based on what I have seen this season, he is years away from contributing much. Looks like a smaller Mikkaele.

Tamou
Garner
Luc
Mikaele
Tuilagi

None of them are big losses...but 'combined' that is a lot to lose / very little coming in at this point.

You would think Sheensy must have something up his sleeve.
Click to expand...
Agree apart from Lucy
 
Mmm everyone saying Sheens must have someone lined up to play second row. I don’t think so.

He is not willing to pay more than he thinks they are worth. Luciano going because we wouldn’t match Cowboys. Tuilagi and now Garner going probably for same reasoning.

We didn’t get the Cronulla guy and now looks like Crichton not coming. Some said he was talking to Hipgrove but he’s going to Eels. Aitken going to Dolphins.

I think Sheens has a plan, only it’s not working.
 
cqtiger said:
Mmm everyone saying Sheens must have someone lined up to play second row. I don’t think so.

He is not willing to pay more than he thinks they are worth. Luciano going because we wouldn’t match Cowboys. Tuilagi and now Garner going probably for same reasoning.

We didn’t get the Cronulla guy and now looks like Crichton not coming. Some said he was talking to Hipgrove but he’s going to Eels. Aitken going to Dolphins.

I think Sheens has a plan, only it’s not working.
Click to expand...

Plan is not to spend too much $$ on the next second row.

We already have one of the best in the 600k range why would we spend more than that on the next one?
 
Personally, I think Blore is an upgrade on Kelma and Garner. We do need depth in the position though. Another 700k backrower might not be the best use of coin.

A good Tamou replacement or a quality outside back/fullback would be where we need to strengthen.
 
Last edited:
I know some people dont want nikora but he still hasnt signed yet with cronulla. Does anyone watch the Q cup .
Surely there are some young backrowers on the rise there ?
 
GCfan said:
Sorry if I’ve offended. Whatever the number of posts on Brooks it’s been done to death and a signing suggestions and rumours isn’t the thread for it.
Click to expand...
I am not offended and have you posted to much Brooks in this thread ?
 
tony soprano said:
Plan is not to spend too much $$ on the next second row.

We already have one of the best in the 600k range why would we spend more than that on the next one?
Click to expand...
We shld take quality 1st graders at fair market price in any position where we are deficient...we simply just have so few of them in our 30
 
loklok said:
I know some people dont want nikora but he still hasnt signed yet with cronulla. Does anyone watch the Q cup .
Surely there are some young backrowers on the rise there ?
Click to expand...
There are rumours his re-signing has stalled again. No announcement made yet.
 
tony soprano said:
Plan is not to spend too much $$ on the next second row.

We already have one of the best in the 600k range why would we spend more than that on the next one?
Click to expand...
Yeah I remember @THE_POM posting that a while ago too, especially when we need to be careful on how much % of the cap we dedicate to the backrow when in the next 1-3 seasons, we'll look to upgrade the likes of Tumeth, O'Kane, Kautoga, Matamua, Saukuru.

Personally I'd be happy with our further recruits for 2023 to be:

- Kade Dykes (backup fullback, half, could develop into anything)
- Luke Thompson or Joe Tapine (to replace Tamou as our experienced credentialed prop)
- Jackson Topine (as our backrow recruit to vie with Blore, can also play Lock, very talented & was an underage rep, good values too apparently so held in high regard, can see Madge liking him)
- Jackson Ferris (cover for centre, wing, back row; been forgotten about due to injury but was held in high regard at Sharks 2-3 seasons ago, a Nu Brown type comeback story)
- Nu Brown (utility)

If we can't land Dykes or Thompson for our 30th spot this season, we simply upgrade Brown or Pole this season.

Note - even though there is no star Centre in the above recruits, I have confidence in T'oa, Kepaoa & Naden moving forward (and no quality Centres available unless we get a contracted one like Tesi Niu that may not see a future at current club.
 
tony soprano said:
Plan is not to spend too much $$ on the next second row.

We already have one of the best in the 600k range why would we spend more than that on the next one?
Click to expand...
Because we can’t go into next season with one backrower , I can’t count blore until he comes back , and the young blokes won’t be ready , so u just want us to keep saying sorry we got this one for $ 600 so we ain’t paying u over that , good way to not having a top notch team
 
bptiger 0 said:
Because we can’t go into next season with one backrower , I can’t count blore until he comes back , and the young blokes won’t be ready , so u just want us to keep saying sorry we got this one for $ 600 so we ain’t paying u over that , good way to not having a top notch team
Click to expand...

Don't panic
 
ElleryHanley said:
You would hope there are incomings, and not just young players going up.

Fonua Pole will come up, but based on what I have seen this season, he is years away from contributing much. Looks like a smaller Mikkaele.

Tamou
Garner
Luc
Mikaele
Tuilagi

None of them are big losses...but 'combined' that is a lot to lose / very little coming in at this point.

You would think Sheensy must have something up his sleeve.
Click to expand...
An arm.
 
Getting worried about our backrow for next year. Papali'i is a great signing but we need another quality backrower to partner him. We're getting a bit thin there and there's not much on the market.
Can't be expecting much from Blore either after missing a whole season.
 
We need another one. Currently, there is not one player at the club who has his name pencilled in as a starting back rower in 2023. Think about that. Don’t say Blore. The good thing is the club at least recognises this and is actively looking for someone to partner Pap. We’ll hit on somebody as long as we keep looking.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 262 (members: 2, guests: 260)
Forever online: Tigergran, Geo
Back
Top