Michael Maguire leaves club

Status
Not open for further replies.
Stevec said:
I don't think madge is a bad coach but we are going backwards and the fans deserve better. Sick of waking up Monday morning depressed after another poor show . Problem is changing coach now for just anybody who is available is not going to achieve much. I do wish Madge would put our best team in terms of skill, experience and effort on the field each week and not have it influenced by who's in or out of his good books each week . The same should apply to Hastings who can't dictate who he will or won't play with.
Having said that Ciraldo seems to be the one who will build club using pathways and attracting talent .
Click to expand...
Who is Hastings off?
 
BAGNF05 said:
Lee was careful to point out Sheen’s was heading up the football department. Everyone else just looks after the gardens at Wests Tigers apparently. The flowers look good 👍
Click to expand...

He also mentioned he would not guarantee anyone role including ceo.

But your probably right probably safe
 
BAGNF05 said:
Who is Hastings off?
Click to expand...
I read a few days ago that Hastings was pissed at nofo over his night out while on concussion protocols and insisting he not be picked .Not sure what thread I read this and hope untrue but can't have one player dictating anothers future
 
Stevec said:
I read a few days ago that Hastings was pissed at nofo over his night out while on concussion protocols and insisting he not be picked .Not sure what thread I read this and hope untrue but can't have one player dictating anothers future
Click to expand...
Who hasn't passed off nofo
 
for me if I could choose any coach in the game , I would choose Todd Payton . He was the heir apparent , and probably knew it hence the whiteanting .
It sux that he couldn’t hide his time one to two more years as all this merry go round stuff wouldn’t have happened . And I honestly believe that .
As for anyone not named Madge . I’d rather see a proven winner in Wolfe , he’s killed it in the super league , and help galvanise the Tonga team to what it is now .
Ciraldo SCREAMS bust to me ! He works at the panthers because he’s apart of well oiled machine , granted he’s may have been a huge contributor to the building of that machine , but it would be a huge risk , as no panthers assistant has done anything .
 
Strongee said:
for me if I could choose any coach in the game , I would choose Todd Payton . He was the heir apparent , and probably knew it hence the whiteanting .
It sux that he couldn’t hide his time one to two more years as all this merry go round stuff wouldn’t have happened . And I honestly believe that .
As for anyone not named Madge . I’d rather see a proven winner in Wolfe , he’s killed it in the super league , and help galvanise the Tonga team to what it is now .
Ciraldo SCREAMS bust to me ! He works at the panthers because he’s apart of well oiled machine , granted he’s may have been a huge contributor to the building of that machine , but it would be a huge risk , as no panthers assistant has done anything .
Click to expand...
Woolfe is in a lower standard comp.

He isnt the one to rescue this club nor is john Morris.
 
Strongee said:
for me if I could choose any coach in the game , I would choose Todd Payton . He was the heir apparent , and probably knew it hence the whiteanting .
It sux that he couldn’t hide his time one to two more years as all this merry go round stuff wouldn’t have happened . And I honestly believe that .
As for anyone not named Madge . I’d rather see a proven winner in Wolfe , he’s killed it in the super league , and help galvanise the Tonga team to what it is now .
Ciraldo SCREAMS bust to me ! He works at the panthers because he’s apart of well oiled machine , granted he’s may have been a huge contributor to the building of that machine , but it would be a huge risk , as no panthers assistant has done anything .
Click to expand...
Yep he is the only one I would support. He always wanted the job knows the club inside out and is great mates with Sheens.
 
Spartan117 said:
Woolfe is in a lower standard comp.

He isnt the one to rescue this club nor is john Morris.
Click to expand...
Well he did wonders for Tonga , is well liked in the industry , and has a strong reputation . And the last 2 coaches to come out of that league with similar results have gone on to win the comp in the nrl . Robbo and Madge for those wondering . I think to dismiss a guy who’s spent the last 3 years winning , for guys sitting on thier butt , or Guys who have been riding the success of a golden generation .
I dunno seems dismissive for me , and confirmation bias .
 
Stevec said:
I read a few days ago that Hastings was pissed at nofo over his night out while on concussion protocols and insisting he not be picked .Not sure what thread I read this and hope untrue but can't have one player dictating anothers future
Click to expand...
Does not surprise me. I watched Hastings spray Noffa when he let in a try v Souths in the game we beat them. I get the feeling Noff would not take that sort of thing too well. Seems like he thinks he’s all that. And yes, going out partying while your supposedly still struggling with headaches is just another display of guys who aren’t professionals, just collecting cheques.
 
Stevec said:
I don't think madge is a bad coach but we are going backwards and the fans deserve better. Sick of waking up Monday morning depressed after another poor show . Problem is changing coach now for just anybody who is available is not going to achieve much. I do wish Madge would put our best team in terms of skill, experience and effort on the field each week and not have it influenced by who's in or out of his good books each week . The same should apply to Hastings who can't dictate who he will or won't play with.
Having said that Ciraldo seems to be the one who will build club using pathways and attracting talent .
Click to expand...
I would like a compromise situation with regards to coaching for the rest of 2022 .This would entail Madge remaining as co-coach with Ciraldo as his offsider coach for the rest of 2022 and would give Ciraldo a really good chance to prepare himself for full time coaching in 2023.
 
BAGNF05 said:
Does not surprise me. I watched Hastings spray Noffa when he let in a try v Souths in the game we beat them. I get the feeling Noff would not take that sort of thing too well. Seems like he thinks he’s all that. And yes, going out partying while your supposedly still struggling with headaches is just another display of guys who aren’t professionals, just collecting cheques.
Click to expand...
Ok but out 4 weeks now more than enough sanction for the "crime of the century" and my post said it was Hastings who was pissed off at Nofo not the other way round
 
Newtown said:
I would like a compromise situation with regards to coaching for the rest of 2022 .This would entail Madge remaining as co-coach with Ciraldo as his offsider coach for the rest of 2022 and would give Ciraldo a really good chance to prepare himself for full time coaching in 2023.
Click to expand...
Throw in a really awkward situation to really bugger the season you reckon?
 
Stevec said:
Ok but out 4 weeks now more than enough sanction for the "crime of the century" and my post said it was Hastings who was pissed off at Nofo not the other way round
Click to expand...
I think Hastings is off noffa for more than one thing. Hastings is a winner.
 
Stevec said:
I read a few days ago that Hastings was pissed at nofo over his night out while on concussion protocols and insisting he not be picked .Not sure what thread I read this and hope untrue but can't have one player dictating anothers future
Click to expand...
Sorry to disagree but that's exactly what we need. No more of this BS boys club who carry on like flogs in their little sandals and pants that dont reach the ankles on boats in Sydney Harbour. Call it as it is. Be a leader. Call out bad behaviour.
 
Strongee said:
Well he did wonders for Tonga , is well liked in the industry , and has a strong reputation . And the last 2 coaches to come out of that league with similar results have gone on to win the comp in the nrl . Robbo and Madge for those wondering . I think to dismiss a guy who’s spent the last 3 years winning , for guys sitting on thier butt , or Guys who have been riding the success of a golden generation .
I dunno seems dismissive for me , and confirmation bias .
Click to expand...
Fifita started the "Tonga Revolution" And Taumalolo to a point.
By getting all the better players to commit.

The last coach to come out of there with similar results is Justin Holbrook
- Has a squad full of Origin Players and has the same amount of wins as us!!

When Woolfe was in Aus, He was coaching ressies in Townsville.... Nothing special results wise.

I get your point, I'd probably prefer him over Flanagan.
But there's plenty of coaches that kill it over there and come back to leave not much of an impact on anything.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 1,657 (members: 24, guests: 1,633)
Back
Top