Top 10 Wests Tigers were robbed moments

[Yossarian]

I’m probably forgetting some but vote now!

2012: v Dogs. Dogs try allowed despite a glaring obstruction. Dogs go on to win in the 89th minute. NRL admits call was wrong. Official involved: Ben Cummins/Jarrod Maxwell

"The video referee decision on Friday night was incorrect. It was wrong," Harrigan said

2018 v Broncos. Brisbane get a penalty for our markers not being square despite ball being played at a 45 degree angle. Broncos win 9-7. Official involved: Ashley Klein

2003 v Canberra. Match winning try disallowed for a forward pass. Pass was not forward. Raiders win 28~26. Official involved: Shayne Hayne

2004 v Canberra. Get pinged 13-3 in the penalty count. Sheens refuses to go to presser and gets fined. Official involved: Shayne Hayne

2006 v Canberra. Tigers pinged for stripping the ball despite it looking like ball was out before second player joined. Canberra massively offside all golden point. Raiders win 20-18. Official involved: Tony Archer

2006 v Canberra. As Fairfax reported “ On at least two of those occasions, replays showed Raiders players up to four metres offside when trying to charge the kicker but they were not penalised.” Raiders won 19-18. Official involved: Steve Clark.

2022 v Cowboys. NQ allowed to take a captain’s challenge despite no decision being made. Bunker rules escort even though Kepaoa is heading towards the ball and Cows player would not have got to the ball. Cows win 27-26. Official involved: Ashley Klein.

2004 v Souths. Officials forget extra time is 5 minutes each way and let play go on. Bunnies win by a point 7 plus minutes in. Officials involved: unknown

2004 v Broncos. Corey Parker ignores officials and enters the field as an interchange mid play and scores a try. We led 18-12 at the time and lose 24-32. Official involved: unknown

2004 v Broncos. Pat Richards ruled to have put his elbow out when scoring a would be 78th minute winning try. We lose 20-24. Official involved: whoever was video ref

 

[krissy]

Ok this is NOT helping me feel better.
If I feel this robbed I can’t imagine how the guys that played their guts out feel.

 

[Yossarian]

Dishonourable mentions to the second ball incident at Newcastle. I also vaguely recall a Cowboys player putting the ball on the sideline or touch in goal but getting awarded a try.

 

[jadtiger]

Ok this is NOT helping me feel better.
If I feel this robbed I can’t imagine how the guys that played their guts out feel.

Believe it or not we as supporters are probably more disgusted than most of the players.Some will be angry but not all will be

 

[Yossarian]

Believe it or not we as supporters are probably more disgusted than most of the players.Some will be angry but not all will be

Well they still get paid. Some poor bastards who support us paid money to watch that.

 

[batboy]

You forgot Luciano try against the warriors earlier this year

 

[Tucker]

Believe it or not we as supporters are probably more disgusted than most of the players.Some will be angry but not all will be

Guys like Hastings and Ofahengaue would be ropable and gutted.

 

[Yossarian]

You forgot Luciano try against the warriors earlier this year

Thought about it. That was Ziggy right? Got dropped afterwards.

 

[jadtiger]

Guys like Hastings and Ofahengaue would be ropable and gutted.

Yes they would be and that shows in their efforts every week.Even when hastings has an ordinary game he tries his heart out

 

[Tiger-ferret]

Dishonourable mentions to the second ball incident at Newcastle. I also vaguely recall a Cowboys player putting the ball on the sideline or touch in goal but getting awarded a try.

Thought that would make the 10.

The one irks me was the noffa no try I think against manly a few years ago. He planted it on the line. Ref didn’t go upstairs in the era when they went upstairs for everything minor.

 

[JRDee]

The scrum in the semi final vs Easts and Anasta kicks a field goal ,that was the worst scrum in the history of rugby league it should have been our penalty

 

[bathursttiger1]

I’m probably forgetting some but vote now!

2012: v Dogs. Dogs try allowed despite a glaring obstruction. Dogs go on to win in the 89th minute. NRL admits call was wrong. Official involved: Ben Cummins/Jarrod Maxwell

"The video referee decision on Friday night was incorrect. It was wrong," Harrigan said

2018 v Broncos. Brisbane get a penalty for our markers not being square despite ball being played at a 45 degree angle. Broncos win 9-7. Official involved: Ashley Klein

2003 v Canberra. Match winning try disallowed for a forward pass. Pass was not forward. Raiders win 28~26. Official involved: Shayne Hayne

2004 v Canberra. Get pinged 13-3 in the penalty count. Sheens refuses to go to presser and gets fined. Official involved: Shayne Hayne

2006 v Canberra. Tigers pinged for stripping the ball despite it looking like ball was out before second player joined. Canberra massively offside all golden point. Raiders win 20-18. Official involved: Tony Archer

2006 v Canberra. As Fairfax reported “ On at least two of those occasions, replays showed Raiders players up to four metres offside when trying to charge the kicker but they were not penalised.” Raiders won 19-18. Official involved: Steve Clark.

2022 v Cowboys. NQ allowed to take a captain’s challenge despite no decision being made. Bunker rules escort even though Kepaoa is heading towards the ball and Cows player would not have got to the ball. Cows win 27-26. Official involved: Ashley Klein.

2004 v Souths. Officials forget extra time is 5 minutes each way and let play go on. Bunnies win by a point 7 plus minutes in. Officials involved: unknown

2004 v Broncos. Corey Parker ignores officials and enters the field as an interchange mid play and scores a try. We led 18-12 at the time and lose 24-32. Official involved: unknown

2004 v Broncos. Pat Richards ruled to have put his elbow out when scoring a would be 78th minute winning try. We lose 20-24. Official involved: whoever was video ref

There’s a common factor with all of those referees is they were all arrogant pricks.

 

[jirskyr]

The scrum in the semi final vs Easts and Anasta kicks a field goal ,that was the worst scrum in the history of rugby league it should have been our penalty

I waxed lyrical about that in another thread.

Others:
2021 vs Souths George Burgess given a try when bouncing the ball on the line, Brooks picks it up and runs length of the field, ref awards try to Tigers, bunker over-rules.

There are also two, I cannot remember the opponents exactly. The one with Luch potentially grounding a late ball and they don't refer it. And the one at Commbank when Kelma scores from a bomb, but the video ref says it's a bobble and penalises the player (Souths?) for stripping (in which case it should have been a penalty try).

And above the Korbin Sims incident when he kicks a second ball past Rankin and causes a knock-on that Knights score from.

Are most of the dodgy calls against Raiders, Broncos and Souths, or does OP have a one-track memory?

 

[Yossarian]

They should have been pinged for breaking from the scrum to dive on the ball.

The scrum in the semi final vs Easts and Anasta kicks a field goal ,that was the worst scrum in the history of rugby league it should have been our penalty

 

[innsaneink]

2004 v Canberra. Get pinged 13-3 in the penalty count. Sheens refuses to go to presser and gets fined. Official involved: Shayne Hayne

 

[Carefactor]

They should have been pinged for breaking from the scrum to dive on the ball.

And half the chooks werent even packed in the first place.