Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[earl]

Disappointing if true.

I think it's good.

 

[Bones]

Apparently N Brown to dogs

Is there anyone that isn’t going to the dogs?

 

[tony soprano]

Is there anyone that isn’t going to the dogs?

Nope

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

Is this full strength 2023 ?

1 Daine Laurie
2 Starford Toa (Nofo, IF he returns)
3 AJ Kepoa
4 Brent Naden
5 Ken Maumalo
6 Adam Douihei
7 Jock Madden or Luke Brooks
8 Joe Ofahengauie
9 Api Korosau
10 Stefano Utoikamanu
11 Shawn Blore
12 Isahia Papali'i
13 Jackson Hastings

14 Alex Twal
15 Fonua Pole
16 Zane Musgrove
17 Alex Seyfarth / Tommy Talau

musgrove & seyfarth shouldn't be near the team imo

 

[supercoach]

The Dogs will be moving players on to accommodate all their signings. Not that a Dog’s reject is anything to get excited about, but I get the feeling the big Pom will be in our colours next year And maybe one other. The way our roster is shaping for 2023 any regular FG would be welcome.

We just need a few troops to at least give us some hope of having a outside chance of the eight, at present we are hoping API and Papi might save us from back to back spoons

 

[batboy]

Tigers have been the most reckless club at signing players Brooks $960k ave
Mbye $900k also huge money $800 k to joey L Josh R Russell P and more bad signings in fact the Peachy $375 small by comparison .
Its no wonder with all that cap spent on players that spent much of their time
on the bench or Reggie's no wonder we struggle

I noticed you left your winger off that list

 

[Long Term Fan]

With Api coming to WT in 2023 and he can play 80 mins could Nu Brown play Lock and Hastings back to the halves.

Still prefer AD in the Centres.

Love to know Forum Member's insightful opinions.

 

[batboy]

If you want more recent data tim did coach the all star England team to win against the England team.

1 rep game….
Where the players from the superior hemisphere beat the players from the inferior hemisphere..,
Like they do most years that game is on?

You’re taking the piss now - surely….

Why leave out the other clubs where he failed and was sacked?
- including ours

 

[batboy]

With Api coming to WT in 2023 and he can play 80 mins could Nu Brown play Lock and Hastings back to the halves.

Still prefer AD in the Centres.

Love to know Forum Member's insightful opinions.

I would have though Nu Brown / Peachey was the obvious replacement for Hastings when he went down with the boys coming in at Hooker…

But nope - they went full 180… worked a treat

 

[Halbrowne61]

Aaron woods I reckon

Im actually heart broken with the Club.

The effort being shown by the club is deserving of coming last.

I wish the players and employees would care as much as we do.

Pity we don’t have the chance to ask WTF questions to TS,LH and JP directly. Everyone keeps saying that they are concerned for the fans. Well then walk the talk !
One proper question each where we might get an answer to our concerns. Be it on here or a fan question day. We could put our heads together and work out 20 major questions.
Would at least stop endless speculation on this site.
If you are watching Tigers heirachy then please respond. Our hearts are aching for WT to succeed.
Yes, I know I’m probably dreaming.

 

[tony soprano]

1 rep game….
Where the players from the superior hemisphere beat the players from the inferior hemisphere..,
Like they do most years that game is on?

You’re taking the piss now - surely….

Why leave out the other clubs where he failed and was sacked?
- including ours

Just like you leave out all the good he has done.

Our club has certainly only been worse since he left.

You do you mate, I happened to get back into footy when Sheens was at Tigers and glad to have seen the 05, 2010 periods for the club. I am still a fan because of these periods.

I've had enough with the club like everyone else up until Sheens was appointed.

The club has stunk year after year without him.

I don't think sheens has ever lost it, again, the England game you scoff at some expects mentioned the England coach as a WT coach candidate but again with a lesser named team with less resources sheens beat England. If you watched the game you'd see modern game tactics were used. I highly doubt you even watched the game.

 

[Cobarcats]

Corruption, corruption, corruption at the highest level.
Because the NRL crooks have promised their Tycoon friends that they will not change a thing and make the NRL a level playing field.
A fair salary cap system does not exist, it is just a mockery.

The corruption in the NRL is rife,
And even when the unexpected team seems like they are going to win a game or even worse, after the game, their Crook refs, will make sure that the unexpected result does not occur.

What I can't understand is there was a feeling in the rugby league circles that when clubs like Western Suburbs and Balmain were going good then the state of the game was also very healthy. This can be reinforced by the fact that a huge following of WT fans view games on the TV and when WT won in 05 Fox and 9 smashed the ratings.
Since a huge amount of revenue comes from fox and the 9 network you would think that the NRL would be doing it's utmost to help clubs like us survive.
Instead they allow us to be media cannon fodder to fox and struggle maintaining an honest salary cap.

 

[Hbom]

Joey Manu

 

[851]

The leaks have stopped?

I think the boat has sunk, we are at the bottom now

 

[FinestTigers]

What I can't understand is there was a feeling in the rugby league circles that when clubs like Western Suburbs and Balmain were going good then the state of the game was also very healthy. This can be reinforced by the fact that a huge following of WT fans view games on the TV and when WT won in 05 Fox and 9 smashed the ratings.
Since a huge amount of revenue comes from fox and the 9 network you would think that the NRL would be doing it's utmost to help clubs like us survive.
Instead they allow us to be media cannon fodder to fox and struggle maintaining an honest salary cap.

Spot on Cobar,
It would be similar to the corrupt government when they sell the many valuable public assets, short term gains but not realising or denying the long term pains.

 

[batboy]

Just like you leave out all the good he has done.

Our club has certainly only been worse since he left.

You do you mate, I happened to get back into footy when Sheens was at Tigers and glad to have seen the 05, 2010 periods for the club. I am still a fan because of these periods.

I've had enough with the club like everyone else up until Sheens was appointed.

The club has stunk year after year without him.

I don't think sheens has ever lost it, again, the England game you scoff at some expects mentioned the England coach as a WT coach candidate but again with a lesser named team with less resources sheens beat England. If you watched the game you'd see modern game tactics were used. I highly doubt you even watched the game.

I didn't leave it out
- I just fully realise and acknowledge that it was a VERY long time ago....
And am cautious in the fact he never backed it up.
Something you seem to not be interested in referencing.

Just a reminder, His winning record as a coach over his career (Which has been sporadic at best - for the last 10 years) is less than 45%....
With a team of Raiders internationals and winning a comp with us.

You want to hang your hat and hopes on that - You go right ahead...
- Another reminder, Mick Potters is north of 50%...
(But our captain didn't like him either)

You back Sheens endlessly - He's done nothing of substance in recent memory....
I'm hopeful - Don't get me wrong....
You're delusional.

 

[balmain boy]

Write this down. 1st November.

You realise we need players for next season more than 2024, right?

 

[851]

Yep Angus wanted 800+ but apparently is signing for 450 .. go figure .. nothing to see here, right .. !!

Even the chooks couldn't register him for $450k a year surely

 

[tony soprano]

I didn't leave it out
- I just fully realise and acknowledge that it was a VERY long time ago....
And am cautious in the fact he never backed it up.
Something you seem to not be interested in referencing.

Just a reminder, His winning record as a coach over his career (Which has been sporadic at best - for the last 10 years) is less than 45%....
With a team of Raiders internationals and winning a comp with us.

You want to hang your hat and hopes on that - You go right ahead...
- Another reminder, Mick Potters is north of 50%...
(But our captain didn't like him either)

You back Sheens endlessly - He's done nothing of substance in recent memory....
I'm hopeful - Don't get me wrong....
You're delusional.

You're not a bit excited to see some attacking footy?

 

[batboy]

You're not a bit excited to see some attacking footy?

We've seen that - It doesn't work.....
We had the best at it There's ever been.....
It doesn't work... He didn't work.

I want to win.
He didn't win then with that crap, He won't win with it now...

He won't buy back rowers - He won't buy centres (Like he didn't back then)
and we'll all go round again, Living off one great year and 2 OK ones....

Anyone who thinks he's set to repeat his miracle 05 run is set for heartbreak...
He's already eluded to the fact that we couldn't and still can't defend - And he doesn't seem focused on it now with his "We've gotta score some points"

The game is twice as fast as it was back then - And Sheens is twice as slow...