Which Players Survive This Disastrous Year?

[Stevec]

Tired of small out gunned and out muscled forwards
This includes Dias ,Freebairn, Pole ,Musgrove
Glad the their going
This includes Tuilagi, Garner, Madden ,Tamou , and I think Peachy
Tired of backs who are wingers at best
This includes Toa
Only ones I would keep Laurie just for effort but maybe not fullback
Douehi , Brown as bench utility
Ofengauhe but disturbed at his fall off last few weeks maybe he wants out?
Maumalo,Simpkin or Liddle as reggies hooker as back up for Api but only one
and Naden as winger?
So I've only kept 7 of the 17 squad today
Sure is a lot of recruiting to do Tim

 

[Lukic]

I'd like to see Ken actually healthy too. Guy's played just about every game this year completely busted. I don't think he's anything special when healthy either, but he'll be a load better when he can move rather than going down with a groin / knee / ankle every second game.

 

[jadtiger]

Have to agree, Tuilagi, Toa, Mamaulo and Simpkin were disgraceful, should never see first grade again, that was disgraceful, Sheens needs to own this

Good luck trying to get Sheens to admit to stuffing things up

 

[Yossarian]

Ken isn’t fit. Laurie is too inconsistent. The three quarters generally are reserve graders or backups at best. Gotta hope Talau comes back fit and ready. Noffa slots straight back in. Pole is good, forwards should shape up better with IP and Api. Plenty of opportunities for the Flegg players.

 

[WT2K]

Have to agree, Tuilagi, Toa, Mamaulo and Simpkin were disgraceful, should never see first grade again, that was disgraceful, Sheens needs to own this

I'm sure sheens will throw someone else under the bus before owning it

 

[earl]

Don’t worry. Benji has brought another old mate in

All of a sudden I feel better.

 

[Bula]

Don’t worry. Benji has brought another old mate in

Who? Darren McMullen?

 

[Speed2burn]

Have to agree, Tuilagi, Toa, Mamaulo and Simpkin were disgraceful, should never see first grade again, that was disgraceful, Sheens needs to own this

My 92 year old grand mother could out sprint Kenny

Sometimes I think he’s taking the piss because my god he’s slow

 

[Trevros]

I'd probably keep Pole out of today's pathetic performance and that would be it, the rest can go apart from Hastings.

 

[Harvey]

Who? Darren McMullen?

Sure I read today his personal physio Moussa is taking over as head of performance

 

[KevB]

Most of our players are project players.

None strike me as legitimate first graders despite a handful showing some basic level of skill...

I like Fonua Pole but he's a straight out rookie.
He's been great this year.

Offa has been one of our best but he looks like he doesn't like playing prop...

Laurie has lost me, he's no good.
Local legend, home town hero type that would carve up the local bush footy comp but is abysmal 90% of the time in first grade. The 10% doesn't do it for me, the flashiness and whatnot. I'd rather a worker like Dylan Edwards.

This roster is the worst I've seen in a very long time.

You are a bit tough on Lawrie I thought he was our best today and has been one of our best over the last six weeks. Definetly a keeper.

 

[Demps]

You are a bit tough on Lawrie I thought he was our best today and has been one of our best over the last six weeks. Definetly a keeper.

I read the comments and watch the games... I see he gets a lot of love on here and I don't see it.

It goes hand in hand with guys like Hastings and Joffa - they make be OK but get massively overrated because they appear to care and try , compared to the rest of the team.

Willing to give Laurie a big pre season and see how he goes next year but I wouldn't be rushing to extend him.

 

[PJ2]

Just saw the score.
Wouldn't bother me if none of these [This word has been automatically removed]s came back

 

[Telltails]

You are a bit tough on Lawrie I thought he was our best today and has been one of our best over the last six weeks. Definetly a keeper.

I see plenty of upside in Laurie.

 

[TSP]

Madge would not have allowed our better players to go. That is why Sheens punted him.

That and the fact he was after the job.

He will screw us over for the next 2 years and ruin any coaching aspirations that Benji had

Reasonable minds can reach different conclusions.

There might be signs of a pulse in the last 3 games of Tim’s tenure ( long after the gate has been closed) and then GTA Benji arrives in his custom threads and gets the team to train to his Rap music.

 

[PJ2]

Most of our players are project players.

None strike me as legitimate first graders despite a handful showing some basic level of skill...

I like Fonua Pole but he's a straight out rookie.
He's been great this year.

Offa has been one of our best but he looks like he doesn't like playing prop...

Laurie has lost me, he's no good.
Local legend, home town hero type that would carve up the local bush footy comp but is abysmal 90% of the time in first grade. The 10% doesn't do it for me, the flashiness and whatnot. I'd rather a worker like Dylan Edwards.

This roster is the worst I've seen in a very long time.

And we've put our trust in dev players that are years off.
Hope we got a decent sized cutlery cupboard

 

[BAGNF05]

Pascoe will survive. He was the first on the life raft

And blamed the iceberg

 

[KevB]

I read the comments and watch the games... I see he gets a lot of love on here and I don't see it.

It goes hand in hand with guys like Hastings and Joffa - they make be OK but get massively overrated because they appear to care and try , compared to the rest of the team.

Willing to give Laurie a big pre season and see how he goes next year but I wouldn't be rushing to extend him.

Take your blinkers of mate. Or it could be you are just a bad judge of a footy player.

 

[Demps]

Take your blinkers of mate. Or it could be you are just a bad judge of a footy player.

All subjective.

I'm just a fan, I can be won over at any time...