Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Stevec]

So if newcastle say they will only pay him 500k are you ok that we will pay between 400 and 600k, depending on who you believe, for him to go. I'm over the club paying for players to play for other teams. We have the money in 2023 to let him sook in reggies. The only way i would pay for him to go is if it means we are able to land a top quality player in a position we need to shore up. As far as i know there is no one available that fits that bill for 2023.

Agree Best + Klemmer and we fork out 350k of Brooks $$

 

[tony soprano]

I Spotted Fafita about a week back at a well known Belmore cafe meeting officials/management. Could well be true

Fafita said on TV once that Pele told him that Pele signed with dogs.

 

[Odessa]

We have Matamua and Faagutu who are both outstanding prospects and both ball playing 13s.

Have you watched much of Faagutu is all the hype real or is he just bigger than the other kids ?

 

[1eyedmel]

So now I'm wondering if all this talk of Brooks to Newcastle is BS. I just read that both Panthers and Newcastle are interested in Adam Keighran to bolster the halves respectively.

 

[Dennisspicer1]

Yeah, we should take @Jedi_Tiger advice and sign Kyle Flanagan.

From the mediocre to the totally ridiculous.

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

So if newcastle say they will only pay him 500k are you ok that we will pay between 400 and 600k, depending on who you believe, for him to go. I'm over the club paying for players to play for other teams. We have the money in 2023 to let him sook in reggies. The only way i would pay for him to go is if it means we are able to land a top quality player in a position we need to shore up. As far as i know there is no one available that fits that bill for 2023.

I was agreeing with you mate, i just stated the fact that if it does drag on even a couple of months that's 2 months less Newcastle pay him and we do for nothing.

 

[Batmans Parents]

It looks like we're letting go of Brooks and a few need to come to terms with this information..

💔

Like I said, they’re Brooks fans first and would rather see the team fail with Brooks than see the team succeed without him.

Better for everyone that they piss off with their favourite pet midget

 

[Kelce68]

Fi-fita.

Unless its a spoonerism and you were going for Fat-fita.

 

[Roar_Power]

So now I'm wondering if all this talk of Brooks to Newcastle is BS. I just read that both Panthers and Newcastle are interested in Adam Keighran to bolster the halves respectively.

I personally think he will be staying on a renewed 3 year contract at a lower annual rate of pay. I'm probably way off though lol....

 

[sleeve]

Looking into my crystal ball in 2024 i see Brooks playing in the halves. I don,t know where!. Crystal ball goes dull, i can,t see Hastings or AD in any clubs 17 players.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Have you watched much of Faagutu is all the hype real or is he just bigger than the other kids ?

He is a very good prospect, some believe to be one of the best from Qld. I've seen a couple of clips. He looks the type to be able to break tackles easily. If you recall the late Illawarra lock Geoff Selby, he had very strong hips and could seemingly break tackles at will.

 

[Batmans Parents]

Yeah, we should take @Jedi_Tiger advice and sign Kyle Flanagan.

He’s so scared of seeing the team succeed with Hastings at 7 that he would rather see us tank with Flanagan 😂

 

[batboy]

Your not getting what I’m saying. Fafita could cruise in our side and still be our best player by the end of the year. Especially with the amount of worker types we have signed.
He single Handedly won games for the Titans. We could only dream of having a player like that.

Put it this way.

Say we resigned Kelma on 400k or so that Manly has signed and he plays identical to how he played this year.
Well I would argue that the out put of the two back rowers on avg was about equal. But with Fafita in addition you get an absolute X factor / game breaker.

The solution is don’t let him go to the defensive line without a pair or an out the back option, develop a before the line pass in him over the off season and you won’t have teams gang tackling him with 4-5 plus defenders to take him out of the game.

I see both sides... Don't worry.
My point, You might be missing - Is if we pay him what he'll probably get,
there's no money left for quality around him...

Leaving him to do it on his own. which he can't do....
And he's not worth decent money, Because he goes missing for most of the game.

 

[WT2K]

FIFITA

 

[weststigerman]

I'd be okay with A Fifita on a bench role for a year but only if we got Klemmer or Leniu.

As someone said we're losing Tamou, Musgrove, and Mikaele. Pole covers for the loss of Mikaele but we need a starting front rower.

 

[The Fresh Oil]

Brooks can't even get punted right. What's taking so long.

 

[851]

@batboy do you have an affiliation with Brooks or something? I get that you don't think Jacko & AD are the answer for our halves problems fair enough, but if the last 9 years have taught us anything Brooks isn't the answer either despite having the most opportunity of the 3 to prove otherwise.....

Amen to that, I like Brooks, and hope he goes well at Newcastle, but doing the same thing over and over again here is just insanity

 

[Camel2281]

Game management/footy knowledge is a massive advantage for at least one player to have on the field. We have been lacking that for awhile.
The Rosters won the GF with Cronk being on field only for those reasons when he had his injured shoulder.

Exactly. It's Brook's biggest downfall. He's the dumbest half I've seen play the game. The number of times he takes the wrong option is mind-blowing

 

[Newtown]

Mate you want to know what clubs like Melbourne & Roosters do when halfbacks have mediocre seasons? (Croft, Flanagan) they get rid of them because that's what good clubs do. They don't sit here making excuses for one player as to why everything goes wrong & how he's not at fault. I'm not saying that the sole of our problems are Brooks fault & Brooks responsibility because that would be unfair & not true, but it's been 9 years & he still hasn't developed into the halfback we expected to him to be & I don't think he's going to do it at the Wests Tigers. There was an immediate difference in the Parramatta & Souths game when Jacko took over the 7 & done majority of the talking & general directing of play which for mine Brooks has shown he's incapable of.

Then why are Newcastle wanting to move their current halfback and replace him with Brooks?

 

[Halbrowne61]

Then why are Newcastle wanting to move their current halfback and replace him with Brooks?

Desperation !