Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[happy_tiger]

NOPE.

Even with Klemmer and Nathan Brown we have NOT solved our lack of Aggression.

That is exactly why we are in the mess we were in for 2022. Our culture needs to demand Aggression and pride. Russell Packer, Josh Reynolds, Robbie Roccow were known for their aggression. We clearly had some aggressive players and they mellowed.

We need to demand aggression in our club, training and culture. Else we will be mellowing Klemmer and Brown instead of having them help motivate us!

And so was Edwards ..had that ranga fight at a drop of a hat style early on

 

[hobbo1]

Not sure about you Jirskyr ...but if I was up and leaving for a few years to the other side of the world I'm not sure if I'd be heading via LA ...... and a holiday

Who knows what might end up in your boogie board .....or what happens to everything you are bringing ....but that's just me

But he is a Pom ..hey @hobbo1

L.A > Hawaii >Bankstown

 

[Bones]

Is it just me barring up with all these signings?

Not just yet, but If we get Moses and Farnworth as well as Bateman I’ll sign up for a platinum membership… and probably bar up.

 

[tony soprano]

Worked out for Inglis and Latrell. Herbie has a similar build to both of them, 6ft 3 and 103kg.

He's a powerful runner that finds the line with ease, he can kick goals and he's only 22.

Would be a massive signing if we pull it off.

Not a fullback imo.

Overrated and inconsistent.

 

[happy_tiger]

L.A > Hawaii >Bankstown

Long Bay .....

 

[Tito Santana]

I still fail to see how Twal is in our best 17. I’d trade him.

 

[carltonleach]

Yeah good player but unproven at fullback. All good if you can tackle or run hard. But you have to position yourself to do those things.

I completely agree but I’d tell him he can have first crack at fullback in the trials and pre season and if it didn’t work he’d be straight back in the centres. If he proved himself as a fullback then u are cheering. It’s a win win regardless!! Players say they want fullback for the money but doesn’t mean they get it just look at JAC.

 

[Cobarcats]

I still fail to see how Twal is in our best 17. I’d trade him.

I think Twal needs to be there to stiffen up the "softening up period"

 

[happy_tiger]

I still fail to see how Twal is in our best 17. I’d trade him.

One of the 1st guys I pick ...every week .....I like defenders ...he could play 350 games and not score a try .....defence wins premierships ...not show ponies who wouldn't scare a tackle bag

 

[hobbo1]

Long Bay .....

No

 

[hobbo1]

I think Twal needs to be there to stiffen up the "softening up period"

Defending our 1st set

 

[hammertime]

I still fail to see how Twal is in our best 17. I’d trade him.

He's there for mine.

You can't have world beaters everywhere and I'm pretty sure he's well liked. Team cohesion is a big factor for Sheens and benji

 

[SeanT]

Not a fullback imo.

Overrated and inconsistent.

Not overrated. He outplayed Katoni Staggs often throughout the year bar one or two games. Strong in defence and attack.

Honestly his best quality was his consistency.

 

[tony soprano]

Yet our current Fullbacks value pales in comparison

My man Staines will prove himself next year 💪

 

[tony soprano]

Not overrated. He outplayed Katoni Staggs often throughout the year bar one or two games. Strong in defence and attack.

Honestly his best quality was his consistency.

Katoni overrated too feet lover.

 

[tony soprano]

I still fail to see how Twal is in our best 17. I’d trade him.

Seyfarth

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

I still fail to see how Twal is in our best 17. I’d trade him.

Not every player needs to be a superstar, you need guys like Twal in the team.

 

[happy_tiger]

Seyfarth

Surely you jest .....

 

[Halbrowne61]

Seyfarth

Same.

 

[Cobarcats]

Did someone mention "Sayfart"
Bid red is all effort but not as good as plugging up the middle as Alex imo.
Alex just needs to get some body movement, he's like a lamp pole....hurts if you run into it but easy to sidestep.