Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Sheens told him he wasn't a 7 in his plans and that he would be looked at as a 13. Newcastle offered him the 7 and an upgrade. He can sook all he wants but he chose to leave - he could have stayed and proved Sheens wrong.
Hate to tell you but he also said he was happy to play anywhere if it helped the team.
Sheens traded him out.
 
why didn't he stay and play 13
Unfortunately that's not true... no matter how many times people say it.
Seems

Unfortunately that's not true... no matter how many times people say it.
Seems Sheens didn't want him.

From Hastings himself interviewed by SMH...

“Whether I wasn’t wanted or wasn’t needed, it took me a few days to get over it because I was angry at the fact I wanted to be there and be a part of the solution, not the problem."

“But I’m a big boy, I’ve been in way worse situations than what has just gone on. I still love the club, and when I say I want them to do well, I genuinely mean it."

“I’ve got no hard feelings towards anyone at the Tigers. When I go back to Leichhardt in round two, hopefully I’m not booed because I really do love the club and enjoyed the year I had there."
that still makes no comment on Hastings being told by Sheens to play 13
He wanted to play 7 bad luck Sheens abd benji didn't rate him as a 7
Newcastle did and he took Newcastle up on the contract
very simple
if Hastings had wanted to play 13 at tigers he would still be here in 2023
 
why didn't he stay and play 13



that still makes no comment on Hastings being told by Sheens to play 13
He wanted to play 7 bad luck Sheens abd benji didn't rate him as a 7
Newcastle did and he took Newcastle up on the contract
very simple
if Hastings had wanted to play 13 at tigers he would still be here in 2023
More money from the Knights aswell.he is gone
Just hoping brooks has a super season.brooks needs to make the right decisions on the field and do it consistently for us to make the 8
 
Comparing JH to an origin and international rep star?
And yes I know he played some reggie’s reps for some other country that his dad did not play for.

Not comparing anyone… just saying that people that make these calls may not be the greatest judges of talent ..,
 
J A C was not what we needed at that time, We needed forwards,and halves, then FB and then centres. Josh would have fallen asleep,before the ball got to him. The cry for Josh was stupid, yes he is fantastic, but a rediculous buy when the rest of the side was a priority

cmon man,,,we let go a future Aust rep player that we could have retained on the cheap…

i can’t recall,,, who were the forwards we signed instead? Packer and McQueen?
 
Sheens told him he wasn't a 7 in his plans and that he would be looked at as a 13. Newcastle offered him the 7 and an upgrade. He can sook all he wants but he chose to leave - he could have stayed and proved Sheens wrong.
I am a massive Hastings fan but understand its a business and the club has made the right call IF they plan on keeping Brooks or have another half in mind. From Hastings POV he gets to play his preferred position and also pockets 300k extra plus 3 more years and as a player that is a massive win.
Sheen's and Co have had a outstanding offseason to date IMO and if we add Bateman and another one that will be icing on the cake.
 
I am of the belief another pom is signed along with Bateman. May have been mentioned before by one of the usual suspects, can't recall.
WELSBY

Never seen him play but there is massive hype around him. Imagine that present for us long suffering fans.

Now this might be the Xmas juice talking, this would make the saddest of sad Tigers fans get out of bed and believe. These are the results of us taking hard salary cap years, i.e. front loading a bunch of contracts. We've been able to free up a bunch of money for this year and next that we can spend large.

After watching this video, I want him. I want Jack Welsby in a Wests Tigers jumper. GET IT DONE SHEENSY!

 
Last edited:
cmon man,,,we let go a future Aust rep player that we could have retained on the cheap…

i can’t recall,,, who were the forwards we signed instead? Packer and McQueen?

Pretty sure that @sleeve was referring to JAC coming back to WT this season, rather than when he chose to sign with Melbourne long before those players were even considered.
 
why didn't he stay and play 13



that still makes no comment on Hastings being told by Sheens to play 13
He wanted to play 7 bad luck Sheens abd benji didn't rate him as a 7
Newcastle did and he took Newcastle up on the contract
very simple
if Hastings had wanted to play 13 at tigers he would still be here in 2023
You’re conveniently forgetting Sheens traded him for Klemmer.
If you read his quotes he said he didn’t want to go.
 
You’re conveniently forgetting Sheens traded him for Klemmer.
If you read his quotes he said he didn’t want to go.
I think that’s rubbish he didn’t want to go, he got more money and got to play 1/2 back . As for sheens he would have had a idea he would leave if he said he was only been looked at as a lock . And let’s face it he hasn’t good the pace or the size to play there for 20 odd games , think we good a good trade for him .
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top