Once again , if the Tigs sign Rts , they have to withdraw their offer immediately. Tedescos market value now becomes the next highest bidder( Say Parra at 1m) . His market value has now dropped from 1.2 M cause the Tigs withdrew the offer. His new value is 1M. No rorting there, transparent values .
Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion
- Thread starter MacDougall
- Start date
cochise
Well-known member
It is still a restraint of trade though, money isn't the only consideration when choosing a workplace, there are many reason why someone may choose to work somewhere for less money. Under your system you are preventing someone from choosing their workplace even though the 2 parties have agreed to what they deem a fair salary, that is pretty much the definition of a restraint of trade. There is no way this would hold up.
In reality the salary cap is a restraint of trade as well but in my opinion it could be argued that it is a fair and reasonable restraint.
Hi Cobs sorry just saw your post. Can you transfer these posts please ? Thank you
Odessa
Well-known member
How about this for an idea because I think the point system is to hard you have the 17 nrl coaches 17 media and 17 former players submit a market value for each player ever year at the beginning of season and at the end to assess his value and divide it by all submissions to get market value it would take two/three days to do and in a contract year his value is current year plus previous year
His market value sits in the cap but you can TAP the Sh!T out of it if you want but no more Tedesco on 800k cap value
His market value sits in the cap but you can TAP the Sh!T out of it if you want but no more Tedesco on 800k cap value
C
Cobarcats
Guest
It's ok mate, thanks. We dont move posts now because its confusing. We are only giving friendly reminders now if they go on for pages and/or someone complains. We all go off topic, I need reminding too 👍
What about the desires of the player? Should they not be able to say where they want to play? Also, money is not the only factor to be considered when signing a contract, particularly these young guys with a young family. Respectfully, your proposed model is flawed.
Go_You_Good_Things
Well-known member
Kaito, I love how you buck the trend and post in portrait.
I understand that, but whilst ever the rest is off the books then for all intents and purposes Tedesco is selling below market value and any obstruction from allowing him to do so is a restraint.
Essentially you need to offer the RLPA a reason for them to agree to something that is a restraint.
Your point 2 (in another post) of cap concessions for long serving or developed players may be a start.
Magpie_Magic
Well-known member
Just on teddy, he was my favorite and the biggest ever loss for our club.
But really, I wouldn't have him back now, unless he's happy with $550k, besides he's had quite a few concussions and may be forced out .
His best days are over,
They never come back the same.
But really, I wouldn't have him back now, unless he's happy with $550k, besides he's had quite a few concussions and may be forced out .
His best days are over,
They never come back the same.
trying to make it rhyme
im sure you know what to do
just give it time
dont make it sound
like f(edited)kn haiku
ezybro
Well-known member
RLPA | Rugby League Players Association on Instagram: "RLPA Player Operations Manager Jamie Buhrer caught up with the player leaders at the Parramatta Eels today. "It's a new year, but it's the same goal: agree to the best terms and conditions for p
667 likes, 1 comments - rlplayers on January 12, 2023: "RLPA Player Operations Manager Jamie Buhrer caught up with the player leaders at the Parramatta Eels today. "It's a new year, but it's the same goal: agree to the best terms and conditions for players in the CBA," said Jamie. "We're...
www.instagram.com
Masterton
Well-known member
IMHO, he's developing into one of the best centres in the game, and probably a reasonable price.
Those Sharks centres had hype earlier last year and got found out pretty quick against better oppositions.
Manu is the #1 centre in the game and I'd have a few ahead of Ramien.
He's capable though, I'm not a fan.
Goldust
Well-known member
Manu is in a league of his own .
Olam is floating somewhere near 2nd place.Penisini looks to have huge potential.
Staggs has all the tools ,keeps getting injured.
I like Herbie at centre too,
Skillful.
Kiraz also, could be a gun centre if put there also.
Masterton
Well-known member
I wouldn't have him in my top 3, but he'd be close. I'd rather him than Graham, Crichton, Talakai or Lomax. Manu is a class above, but I suspect he's only moving to play fullback.
I guess I'd have him behind Val, Farnworth, Olam and in-form Staggs.
Red88_Tiger
Well-known member
graham being the best value for money imo after manu
Masterton
Well-known member
With all due respect Rusty , I disagree. If you would like to add anything to the discussion we have moved to the Salary cap thread. 🙂
Goldust
Well-known member
Kiraz told by newy he wasn’t a first grader 🥴
